3 Points or £60
Author
Discussion

Fort Jefferson

Original Poster:

8,237 posts

253 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
There are lots of threads about the money that is made, from speeding fines. But lets face it, if you had the choice, it would be the points you'd sooner not have. So lets say the law said, no fine and 6 points. Would this make you all happy? Not a chance, but what about, £120 fine and no points? you'd like that, no?

Jasandjules

72,703 posts

260 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
IT would be good for the rich. Simply pay the fine and get on your way. Let's face it, it would be simple and cheaper for certain people to pay £100 a pop to get to a meeting on time, than to be late.

IIRC it was mooted that they would start introducing a points structure, of 1, 2 and 3 points depending on speed over the limit (which seemed simply to be a way to ensure motorists weren't so peeved, and to keep the revenue coming!).


Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
id like road policing, not scameras, which is based on safety & good driving not speedlimits. speed is but a small part of safe driving. there are plently of drivers out there who arent safe an any speed but dont get stopped because they dont exceed an arbitary limit. equally their are better drivers who are much safer but punished due to daft limits.
road policing should exist to raise the standard of driving but punishing the crap drivers. it currently appears to only focus on one minor secion of driving & ignore most of the important parts.
i like the idea of a tiny punishment the first time for minor infringements. such as one point & £10 for 40 in a 30 BUT something more like six points & £120 if you repeat it within say two years. that way habitual bad drivers get more punishment than the rest. i know ive used speeding as an example, thats because its easy to detect. its people cutting you up, not using lights in the rain, lane hogging, tailgating, not indicating, not looking so panic braking, not paying enough attenion to nearly cause accidents and so forth that i want to see policed.

Edited by Hooli on Saturday 31st May 18:03

BOF

991 posts

254 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
FJ,

A Trafpol posted somewhere...

"We need either education...or legislation."

Getting done for speeding has been described as 'the only voluntary tax we pay'.

We are fortunate to live in a country where the £60 can NOT be reduced by slipping a tenner to the Officer...I have lived and driven in countries where this is not an unusual practise.

Our KSI statistics are among the best in the world...the few countries with better KSI stats... for example Finland, Sweden...?

Google their traffic laws...

BOF


robwales

1,427 posts

241 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
From a purely selfish point of view, £120 and no points would be ideal. It would be cheaper in the long run, taking insurance into account.
But then you'd get rich people ignoring speed limits. Not attacking the rich BTW, just it wouldn't be right to be able to pay to break the law.
Of course, exceeding said speed limit may well be safe in the first place but that's another thing.

Jasandjules said:
IIRC it was mooted that they would start introducing a points structure, of 1, 2 and 3 points depending on speed over the limit (which seemed simply to be a way to ensure motorists weren't so peeved, and to keep the revenue coming!).
The proposal was to bring the tolerance down, so you get something like 2 points and £30 for 33mph, the usual for 35, and more for more than that.
It sounds good until you find out the details.

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Sunday 1st June 2008
quotequote all
Fort Jefferson said:
There are lots of threads about the money that is made, from speeding fines. But lets face it, if you had the choice, it would be the points you'd sooner not have. So lets say the law said, no fine and 6 points. Would this make you all happy? Not a chance, but what about, £120 fine and no points? you'd like that, no?
No, not happy with that, or any variation on the theme, short of abolishing all penalties for speeding, so long as it is only speeding with no other, more serious, aspects.

Best wishes all,
Dave.

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Sunday 1st June 2008
quotequote all
BOF said:
FJ,

A Trafpol posted somewhere...

"We need either education...or legislation."

BOF
Then it should be education, so far as possible, with legislation held in reserve as a last resort, rather than being the first weapon of choice the moment some busybodying official thinks there's a problem.

Best wishes all,
Dave.

blueyes

4,799 posts

283 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
Fort Jefferson said:
There are lots of threads about the money that is made, from speeding fines. But lets face it, if you had the choice, it would be the points you'd sooner not have. So lets say the law said, no fine and 6 points. Would this make you all happy? Not a chance, but what about, £120 fine and no points? you'd like that, no?
Unless things have changed recently, this is the case in Italy. I think it's due to their privicy laws or something but if you don't reveal the driver you get double the fine but no points.

Oh, and if you aren't naughty for 2 years you get an additional 2 points to play with, up to a maximum of 6. Carrot and stick!


Fort Jefferson

Original Poster:

8,237 posts

253 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
blueyes said:
Oh, and if you aren't naughty for 2 years you get an additional 2 points to play with, up to a maximum of 6. Carrot and stick!
A bit like a no claims bonus then.biggrin