A day to forget - moral support and advice needed!
Discussion
I was driving along in the middle lane of a busy three lane carriageway (where two A roads meet) when the car in my lane in front of me stamps on his brakes, as does car at similar distance in the left hand lane. A car in the left hand lane which is parallel with me takes evasive action by trying to get into my lane - i'm now trying to avoid being hit side on and trying to avoid rear-ending the bloke in front so I quickly glance in my right mirror and step on the gas to get me out of this tight spot. That's when I see the reason for all this braking - a mobile speed camera van parked nose end into the shrubbery. Those B@stards nearly caused a pile up. As it is, I'm now worried that my action pushed me above the speed limit and they'll stick me with NIP! How can this be. Is this a mitigating circumstance? At what speed on a dual carriageway will they generally prosecute?
Thanks for your help.
Thanks for your help.
Fimbo said:
I was driving along in the middle lane of a busy three lane carriageway (where two A roads meet) when the car in my lane in front of me stamps on his brakes, as does car at similar distance in the left hand lane. A car in the left hand lane which is parallel with me takes evasive action by trying to get into my lane - i'm now trying to avoid being hit side on and trying to avoid rear-ending the bloke in front so I quickly glance in my right mirror and step on the gas to get me out of this tight spot. That's when I see the reason for all this braking - a mobile speed camera van parked nose end into the shrubbery. Those B@stards nearly caused a pile up. As it is, I'm now worried that my action pushed me above the speed limit and they'll stick me with NIP! How can this be. Is this a mitigating circumstance? At what speed on a dual carriageway will they generally prosecute?
Thanks for your help.
If you went evasive as you describe then the chances are the bounty hunter was still trying to hold a lock on one of the two wThanks for your help.
rs in front of you when you nipped around the out side. Fingers crossed for you.Your description isn't quite clear - did you change out one lane to the right? If so, it sounds like you did the right thing, giving the guy space for his 'evasive' manouver; well done and all that. Alternatively, if you stayed in your lane, I can't see why you 'stepped on the gas' with those in front of you braking hard...
If there were cars in front of you I wouldn't worry about prosecution, you wouldn't have been clearly visible. To answer your question, on an NSL dual carriageway I'd expect them to be 'interested' above 80, and 'positively keen' above 90. Obviously, they can technically pull you over for 71...
If there were cars in front of you I wouldn't worry about prosecution, you wouldn't have been clearly visible. To answer your question, on an NSL dual carriageway I'd expect them to be 'interested' above 80, and 'positively keen' above 90. Obviously, they can technically pull you over for 71...
All you can do is wait the 14 days they have to send the NIP.
The problem with these cases is unless you have other drivers and witnesses to back you up, the police will still have a picture of you speeding - period.
The system is set up so that with most speeding offences, it appears far cheaper and less hassle than to go to court. For if you do not convince the court of the above, they tend to increase the fine quite a bit, take costs and may even up the points.
Without independent witnesses it would be hard, real hard methinks.
Good news is, as others have said, it seems like you were 'covered' by the others.
You must also be fairly new to driving
in the UK if this is over stressing you - most of us, sadly, have learned to get used to that 'will they, won't they' 14 day waiting period.....it tends to come up after every bleedin' drive now, no matter how short.
You just have to let the future take care of itself!
The problem with these cases is unless you have other drivers and witnesses to back you up, the police will still have a picture of you speeding - period.
The system is set up so that with most speeding offences, it appears far cheaper and less hassle than to go to court. For if you do not convince the court of the above, they tend to increase the fine quite a bit, take costs and may even up the points.
Without independent witnesses it would be hard, real hard methinks.
Good news is, as others have said, it seems like you were 'covered' by the others.
You must also be fairly new to driving
in the UK if this is over stressing you - most of us, sadly, have learned to get used to that 'will they, won't they' 14 day waiting period.....it tends to come up after every bleedin' drive now, no matter how short.You just have to let the future take care of itself!
Was done for a similar thing in Australia. Except I was pulled over by a officer with a radar fun who saw the whole incident and still gave me a ticket.
My respect for the police force diminished rapidly on that day. Especially when they said something along the lines of "you may have avoided an accident, but speeding is a dangerous offence and causes accidents and deaths".
My respect for the police force diminished rapidly on that day. Especially when they said something along the lines of "you may have avoided an accident, but speeding is a dangerous offence and causes accidents and deaths".
Colonial said:
Was done for a similar thing in Australia. Except I was pulled over by a officer with a radar fun who saw the whole incident and still gave me a ticket.
My respect for the police force diminished rapidly on that day. Especially when they said something along the lines of "you may have avoided an accident, but speeding is a dangerous offence and causes accidents and deaths".
I think I would then have decided to challenge the allegation on that basis as "not getting injured or hurt" ist number one on my priority list. My respect for the police force diminished rapidly on that day. Especially when they said something along the lines of "you may have avoided an accident, but speeding is a dangerous offence and causes accidents and deaths".

I think the only reason why the Handy ist in handbag ist so that I can switch on its "record faciilty" to back up the dictaphone in case of any incident whatever it be ... as there a need to establish truth of what actually said by all parties these days. I would naturally tell the other party of my intention und suggest they do likewise too.
If you get an NIP then I'd be inclined to use the defence of necessity (though one could question why you needed to accelerate to pull into the right hand lane) to avoid an accident as the reason why you may have been nicked - the scamera will have video footage of the carnage and thus should have the car which swerved into your lane.
Even if you got prosecuted and convicted (assuming you can afford to pay the extra tax for having the audacity to try and defend yourself) then this would be a good one for the papers - after all, Cams are to prevent accidents so they claim, thus if you avoided an accident yet are still prosecuted..........
Even if you got prosecuted and convicted (assuming you can afford to pay the extra tax for having the audacity to try and defend yourself) then this would be a good one for the papers - after all, Cams are to prevent accidents so they claim, thus if you avoided an accident yet are still prosecuted..........
Fimbo said:
I was driving along in the middle lane of a busy three lane carriageway (where two A roads meet) when the car in my lane in front of me stamps on his brakes, as does car at similar distance in the left hand lane. A car in the left hand lane which is parallel with me takes evasive action by trying to get into my lane - i'm now trying to avoid being hit side on and trying to avoid rear-ending the bloke in front so I quickly glance in my right mirror and step on the gas to get me out of this tight spot. That's when I see the reason for all this braking - a mobile speed camera van parked nose end into the shrubbery. Those B@stards nearly caused a pile up. As it is, I'm now worried that my action pushed me above the speed limit and they'll stick me with NIP! How can this be. Is this a mitigating circumstance? At what speed on a dual carriageway will they generally prosecute?
Thanks for your help.
There is a LEGAL exemption for motorists to break the speed limit when they are endangered. I don't know where the link to it is as its not a widely publicised piece of news.Thanks for your help.
mark69sheer said:
Fimbo said:
I was driving along in the middle lane of a busy three lane carriageway (where two A roads meet) when the car in my lane in front of me stamps on his brakes, as does car at similar distance in the left hand lane. A car in the left hand lane which is parallel with me takes evasive action by trying to get into my lane - i'm now trying to avoid being hit side on and trying to avoid rear-ending the bloke in front so I quickly glance in my right mirror and step on the gas to get me out of this tight spot. That's when I see the reason for all this braking - a mobile speed camera van parked nose end into the shrubbery. Those B@stards nearly caused a pile up. As it is, I'm now worried that my action pushed me above the speed limit and they'll stick me with NIP! How can this be. Is this a mitigating circumstance? At what speed on a dual carriageway will they generally prosecute?
Thanks for your help.
There is a LEGAL exemption for motorists to break the speed limit when they are endangered. I don't know where the link to it is as its not a widely publicised piece of news.Thanks for your help.
mark69sheer said:
There is a LEGAL exemption for motorists to break the speed limit when they are endangered. I don't know where the link to it is as its not a widely publicised piece of news.
The defence of necessity was the best I could come up with. That would be a full defence to the offence of speeding, if held, i.e I HAD to act in the way I did or else I would have crashed.BUT that's why I said about perhaps not if accelerating whilst pulling into the right hand lane...
I posted a short while ago about the exact same thing happening to me, we all just managed to avoid a pile up that day too, although there was a pile up on the opposite side of the road, so that may also have been related to the camera van on the bridge.
Today, it also happened again, but this time two cars anchored up because a guy in a fluorescent jacket walked out onto a bridge.I noticed, as everyone dropped from 60/70 mph to around 45 mph, that he had his push bike with him and was just stopping to look at traffic I assume and take a rest.He had nothing to do with scamming motorists from where I was sitting, but that didn't stop the panic.I also noticed brake lights galore due to a silver van sitting beside a snack bar.Nobody was speeding in either of the above examples btw, but that is how nervous people have become.The roads are becoming more dangerous as a result.
Go back a few more pages on the forum and you can see police footage of people actually crashing as a result of the 'safety' camera.
Today, it also happened again, but this time two cars anchored up because a guy in a fluorescent jacket walked out onto a bridge.I noticed, as everyone dropped from 60/70 mph to around 45 mph, that he had his push bike with him and was just stopping to look at traffic I assume and take a rest.He had nothing to do with scamming motorists from where I was sitting, but that didn't stop the panic.I also noticed brake lights galore due to a silver van sitting beside a snack bar.Nobody was speeding in either of the above examples btw, but that is how nervous people have become.The roads are becoming more dangerous as a result.
Go back a few more pages on the forum and you can see police footage of people actually crashing as a result of the 'safety' camera.
thanks for the posts. in answer to some of the questions raised:
(1) Why speed up to overtake - the car approaching from behind in the RH lane would have been put at risk if I had simply pulled across him - I had no wish to put him (or the cars following him) at risk (regardless of whether or not he was speeding - which he was) and as there was a sizeable gap ahead in the RH lane the safest thing to do (IMHO) was to pull across and accelerate up (all I might add in a short, swift and safely executed manoeuvre) before pulling back into the middle and then left hand lane.
(2) Was I on the phone - not sure where that came from, but answer is NO.
(3) Why not just brake - because person parallel in LH lane was coming across into me. Braking would have done nothing to avoid this. Jumping on the brakes (Tuscan's are pretty good at bringing to a stop, more so than a lot of cars) would (IMHO) have brought the risk of a rear impact as well as a side impact me thinks.
(1) Why speed up to overtake - the car approaching from behind in the RH lane would have been put at risk if I had simply pulled across him - I had no wish to put him (or the cars following him) at risk (regardless of whether or not he was speeding - which he was) and as there was a sizeable gap ahead in the RH lane the safest thing to do (IMHO) was to pull across and accelerate up (all I might add in a short, swift and safely executed manoeuvre) before pulling back into the middle and then left hand lane.
(2) Was I on the phone - not sure where that came from, but answer is NO.
(3) Why not just brake - because person parallel in LH lane was coming across into me. Braking would have done nothing to avoid this. Jumping on the brakes (Tuscan's are pretty good at bringing to a stop, more so than a lot of cars) would (IMHO) have brought the risk of a rear impact as well as a side impact me thinks.
That's fine, what I was getting at is that if you want to use the defence of necessity you would need to show good reason.
So now you have - would crash into car in front, couldn't swerve left, needed to swerve right (but would have caused car behind to swerve/brake) and therefore had to accelerate to be safe. Having the presence of mind to check your offside, see an approaching car, and obviate his risks of a collision also sounds good to me.
I'd get a good lawyer if you want to defend it though, but you sound like you have a fairly good reason for acting as you did. I don't know if a court would rather you crashed than broke a speed limit though - but then, if you were travelling pretty fast (NSL) I suspect it could have been quite an accident if you'd been hit in the side.
So now you have - would crash into car in front, couldn't swerve left, needed to swerve right (but would have caused car behind to swerve/brake) and therefore had to accelerate to be safe. Having the presence of mind to check your offside, see an approaching car, and obviate his risks of a collision also sounds good to me.
I'd get a good lawyer if you want to defend it though, but you sound like you have a fairly good reason for acting as you did. I don't know if a court would rather you crashed than broke a speed limit though - but then, if you were travelling pretty fast (NSL) I suspect it could have been quite an accident if you'd been hit in the side.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



RTOP!!