Dog Hit by Car
Author
Discussion

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
My dog was hit and killed by a car yesterday.
Woman who hit stated to a witness " I saw him running up road before I ran him over" OAP in Honda Jazz.
I am quite happy to leave it as an accident but woman is going to Police.
Anyone have a view on legal stand point?

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
paoloh said:
My dog was hit and killed by a car yesterday.
Woman who hit stated to a witness " I saw him running up road before I ran him over" OAP in Honda Jazz.
I am quite happy to leave it as an accident but woman is going to Police.
Anyone have a view on legal stand point?
Yes sounds like she was careless.... If she saw him why did she not avoid him?

dh1

103 posts

231 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
thats aweful.....condolences paolo

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
paoloh said:
My dog was hit and killed by a car yesterday.
Woman who hit stated to a witness " I saw him running up road before I ran him over" OAP in Honda Jazz.
I am quite happy to leave it as an accident but woman is going to Police.
Anyone have a view on legal stand point?
Yes sounds like she was careless.... If she saw him why did she not avoid him?
My thoughts excatly.
How does the road traffic act deal with pets?
Can she claim for damage to vehicle?

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
paoloh said:
My dog was hit and killed by a car yesterday.
Woman who hit stated to a witness " I saw him running up road before I ran him over" OAP in Honda Jazz.
I am quite happy to leave it as an accident but woman is going to Police.
Anyone have a view on legal stand point?
Yes sounds like she was careless.... If she saw him why did she not avoid him?
no offence to OP, and with sympathy for his loss, but he was just as careless allowing his dog to be running up the road. Just because it was running up the road before she hit it doesn't mean she didn't take evading action and it bolted in front of her despite this.

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Davi said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
paoloh said:
My dog was hit and killed by a car yesterday.
Woman who hit stated to a witness " I saw him running up road before I ran him over" OAP in Honda Jazz.
I am quite happy to leave it as an accident but woman is going to Police.
Anyone have a view on legal stand point?
Yes sounds like she was careless.... If she saw him why did she not avoid him?
no offence to OP, and with sympathy for his loss, but he was just as careless allowing his dog to be running up the road. Just because it was running up the road before she hit it doesn't mean she didn't take evading action and it bolted in front of her despite this.
If you read my other thread, I am quite happy to admit that but please remember if one of your children run into the road.........

selwonk

2,143 posts

256 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Agree with the sentiment paoloh, but didn't some motorcyclists' family recently successfuly sue the family of a child who played chicken with him and lost?

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
paoloh said:
Davi said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
paoloh said:
My dog was hit and killed by a car yesterday.
Woman who hit stated to a witness " I saw him running up road before I ran him over" OAP in Honda Jazz.
I am quite happy to leave it as an accident but woman is going to Police.
Anyone have a view on legal stand point?
Yes sounds like she was careless.... If she saw him why did she not avoid him?
no offence to OP, and with sympathy for his loss, but he was just as careless allowing his dog to be running up the road. Just because it was running up the road before she hit it doesn't mean she didn't take evading action and it bolted in front of her despite this.
If you read my other thread, I am quite happy to admit that but please remember if one of your children run into the road.........
Haven't seen the other thread, but as I say I intend no offence to you at all by my comment and can understand the anguish it has most likely caused you. I was merely saying that just because she's stated seen the animal loose doesn't automatically mean she was careless in her driving generally or toward your dog.

I've witnessed exactly this happen, the dog owner was apoplectic at my friend who'd run it over, they'd taken avoiding action but the four legged friend just decided that was the moment to go from trotting along the verge to chasing an unseen enemy on t'other side.

Edited by Davi on Thursday 5th June 13:17

selwonk

2,143 posts

256 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Ah - here it is:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/bristol/6215351...

Motorcyclist was found to be blameless after boy ran in the road to play chicken with him. Child was killed and the motorcyclist successfully sued the family for compensation

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Sorry to hear this paoloh. Lost a pet (cat) myself this way so know what it's like.

I believe that when dogs were licenced (licence abolished in 1987) there were certain terms and conditions attached to the licence among which was that it was the owners responsibility to keep the dog under control. It's still the case even though the licence doesn't exist.

If you could show that you had taken reasonable care to ensure the dog did not get out that might suffice as a defence. Perhaps if the dog had never escaped before, vandals damaged the fence, postman left the gate open or something along those lines. Otherwise refer to your houselhold policy (buildings AND contents) at the occupiers liabilty section.

Amused2death

2,526 posts

227 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
paoloh said:
My dog was hit and killed by a car yesterday.
Woman who hit stated to a witness " I saw him running up road before I ran him over" OAP in Honda Jazz.
I am quite happy to leave it as an accident but woman is going to Police.
Anyone have a view on legal stand point?
First of all, saddened to hear of the loss of your pet in such an horrific manner......

The lady mentioned she is going to the police.....I thought that if you hit a dog, then you had to stop, provide detaild re insurance etc. I do not feel you have any case against the lady re her behavior. The dog was loose, and it shouldn't have been. Harsh though this may be, she did stop, and if your dog was the cause of damage to her car, then she does have a claim against you. Wether or not you "took all reasonable precations" to secure your dog, it got out, the insurance you should have regarding your dog will compensate the lady for the damage to her vehicle (if any).

As far as going to the police is concerned, perhaps she thinks that what she has to do as she has had an accident??

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Amused2death said:
The lady mentioned she is going to the police.....I thought that if you hit a dog, then you had to stop, provide detaild re insurance etc....

As far as going to the police is concerned, perhaps she thinks that what she has to do as she has had an accident??
Highway Code Rule 286 said:
If you are involved in a collision which causes damage or injury to any other person, vehicle, animal or property, you MUST

stop
give your own and the vehicle owner’s name and address, and the registration number of the vehicle, to anyone having reasonable grounds for requiring them
if you do not give your name and address at the time of the collision, report it to the police as soon as reasonably practicable, and in any case within 24 hours
Nothing there about providing insurance details to third parties.

If she didn't give her other details to anybody at the time, she has to report it to the police.

Dibble

13,292 posts

271 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Reportable accidents with regards to animals only include:

Goat
Dog
Cow
Horse
Ass
Mule
Pig
Sheep

Basically "working" animals and/or livestock.

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Dibble said:
Reportable accidents with regards to animals only include:

Goat
Dog
Cow
Horse
Ass
Mule
Pig
Sheep

Basically "working" animals and/or livestock.
I was going to add something like that, I knew that you had to report dogs and not cats, I wasn't sure if sheep were included or not, it used to be in the Highway Code but I can't find it now so I gave up...

Amused2death

2,526 posts

227 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
Amused2death said:
The lady mentioned she is going to the police.....I thought that if you hit a dog, then you had to stop, provide detaild re insurance etc....

As far as going to the police is concerned, perhaps she thinks that what she has to do as she has had an accident??
Highway Code Rule 286 said:
If you are involved in a collision which causes damage or injury to any other person, vehicle, animal or property, you MUST

stop
give your own and the vehicle owner’s name and address, and the registration number of the vehicle, to anyone having reasonable grounds for requiring them
if you do not give your name and address at the time of the collision, report it to the police as soon as reasonably practicable, and in any case within 24 hours
Nothing there about providing insurance details to third parties.

If she didn't give her other details to anybody at the time, she has to report it to the police.
Which goes to demonstrate a possible reason why she went to the Police, doesn't mean either of you have done anything illegal, or that she is going to take the matter any further.

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
paoloh said:
My dog was hit and killed by a car yesterday.
Sorry to hear that paoloh.

MoJo.

steven f

538 posts

231 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
dog should be on a lead not running about on a road

Jasandjules

72,709 posts

260 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
steven f said:
dog should be on a lead not running about on a road
DO you think? Honest? Wow, do you also advise the Govt because you're so sharp.

Try and think about how you'd feel if your child escaped from your hands and ran across the road, under a car.. Because that is how it can feel for some people.

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
steven f said:
dog should be on a lead not running about on a road
How about asking about circumstances before spouting rubbish?!

Gemsbok1000

1,958 posts

235 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
steven f said:
dog should be on a lead not running about on a road
Very helpful & constructive!