Indemnity Chancel Notice of Assignment...
Discussion
If I've read that correctly, you should only owe them £40 if, and only if, the charges should be passed on to you.
New Cost: £200
Estimate: £100
Fee for something unrelated, but not applied: £60
Balance: £40, not £140.
I, however, am not a lawyer.
New Cost: £200
Estimate: £100
Fee for something unrelated, but not applied: £60
Balance: £40, not £140.
I, however, am not a lawyer.
Edited by dave87 on Thursday 5th June 17:08
You could try in the Business forum for more answers but I think the first reply from Dave87 was right:
You owe them (the solicitors who paid, or will pay, something on your behalf) an extra £100.
They charged you for chancel indemnity which they haven't yet bought (at £60) but which you have them money for.
So if you want them to use the funds previously assigned for chancel indemnity, then you owe them a further £40.
(That £140 is an error by them. Solicitors are generally crap at maths.)
If you still want the chancel indemnity then you owe them the full £100 shortfall on the notice of assignment fee.
[ETA: I am not a lawyer either.]
You owe them (the solicitors who paid, or will pay, something on your behalf) an extra £100.
They charged you for chancel indemnity which they haven't yet bought (at £60) but which you have them money for.
So if you want them to use the funds previously assigned for chancel indemnity, then you owe them a further £40.
(That £140 is an error by them. Solicitors are generally crap at maths.)
If you still want the chancel indemnity then you owe them the full £100 shortfall on the notice of assignment fee.
[ETA: I am not a lawyer either.]
Edited by walm on Thursday 5th June 17:41
dibbers006 said:
What is a Chancel Indemnity?! Something about my local Parish wanting money for Roof repairs from a Hundred years ago?!
the local church has a right to demand money from you to repair the roof and other things can leave you bankrupt and unable to sell your house- there is q uite a famous case at the moment where the church is taking one of it's own churchwardens to court for hundreds of thousands of pounds- can't find the link though.
dibbers006 said:
What is a Chancel Indemnity?! Something about my local Parish wanting money for Roof repairs from a Hundred years ago?!
I THINK it's the one where the church can say, we'd quite like to spend 30k putting a new roof on this week, and you owe us 1k. Sooo, I'd get the insurance if I were you.Apart from that, as above, I assume the £100 assigment previously was already put on account by yourself, thus you owe £40 (though I'd pay the damn £60 Chancel Policy) but if it's a dispersement you haven't yet paid then you owe them £140. But I'd call it £200 and get that insurance...
dibbers006 said:
What is a Chancel Indemnity?! Something about my local Parish wanting money for Roof repairs from a Hundred years ago?!
As above. Protects you from the local church wanting you to pay for their roof repairs.Check the Chancel Repair Liability Fact Sheet on this page http://www.clsl.co.uk/background.php
I already hate the church on principle, the Aston Cantlow vs Wallbank case just made my p1ss boil over.
Chrispy Porker said:
and you'll probably be charged for this letter too.........
If he's good, he's got a fixed fee conveyancer....Though I would be concerned that said house register type person doesn't feel it necessary to secure the "church can screw you if they want" insurance.
Edited by Jasandjules on Thursday 5th June 19:54
I believe that there are 2 types of chancel indemnity.
The most common one is a "one off" for you whilst you own the house, and
then when you sell it, the next buyer has to take one out - or risk it.
The other one is a "permanent" one that protects you and all subsequent buyers.
Not sure of the costs on the second one but it WOULD mean that your future buyer wouldn't have this issue - but you only get to find this out after you've spent loads anyway so not sure if it is really worth it.
The most common one is a "one off" for you whilst you own the house, and
then when you sell it, the next buyer has to take one out - or risk it.
The other one is a "permanent" one that protects you and all subsequent buyers.
Not sure of the costs on the second one but it WOULD mean that your future buyer wouldn't have this issue - but you only get to find this out after you've spent loads anyway so not sure if it is really worth it.
Had to fork out around 100 sheets for one of these a couple of months back when we moved house. I couldn't believe my ears at first when the solicitor explained it to me.
Almost made me want to write off to the States for my theological diploma or whatever and set up my own church.
Couldn't believe in this day and age that the church can force me to pay for their buidling repairs. Highly unlikely to happen but still........
Almost made me want to write off to the States for my theological diploma or whatever and set up my own church.
Couldn't believe in this day and age that the church can force me to pay for their buidling repairs. Highly unlikely to happen but still........
Chancel indemnity insurance is a bit of a scam - the chancel search companies almost always reveal a risk that your property is liable, and suggest you take out insurance. However, there's no public register of land which is subject to chancel repair liability, and even if you wanted to check out your land specifically, the Kew public records office does not hold complete info.
Basically, if there is a possibility that the property you are buying is in a parish which has a pre-reformation church, then you might be affected. Parish boundaries have changed, but if you check out the age of all the churches in your modern parish and surrounding parishes (use Pevsner) then you should be able to feel comfortable.
The whole industry is based on the Aston Cantlow case, and is totally scaremongering.
Basically, if there is a possibility that the property you are buying is in a parish which has a pre-reformation church, then you might be affected. Parish boundaries have changed, but if you check out the age of all the churches in your modern parish and surrounding parishes (use Pevsner) then you should be able to feel comfortable.
The whole industry is based on the Aston Cantlow case, and is totally scaremongering.
I bet they wished they'd just paid the £6K in the first place - I wonder how many sleepless nights they've had.
The link is from early 2007 - but I can't find a comment on a final outcome. Any idea how it was resolved?
ETA: looks like they had to pay £187K for the repairs, plus about £400K in legal fees.
Seems the first linked article is wrong - the original bill was £96K not £6K, so challenging it is understandable.
The link is from early 2007 - but I can't find a comment on a final outcome. Any idea how it was resolved?
ETA: looks like they had to pay £187K for the repairs, plus about £400K in legal fees.

Seems the first linked article is wrong - the original bill was £96K not £6K, so challenging it is understandable.
Edited by Deva Link on Wednesday 11th June 09:36
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



