Discussion
S13_Alan said:
I will be corrected soon enough if wrong, but yes, although only if it closed to the public.. ie, has a gate at the end which has been closed while he is driving. Otherwise the same rules apply as any normal road, same as garages, car parks etc.
I don't even think that applies. So long as the road has a gate that is closed to prevent access at some time during the year it can be used. The Gate isn't closed at Tockwith while the "juniors" are driving.Orichalon said:
Okay so near us there's a private road, but it connects to a public road, and so obviously the public can access it. My son likes driving, and has done quite a few driving courses etc. Now, if I got the road owners permission, would my son be able to legally drive on it?
My own understanding, which might be wrong, so quite happy to be put right is that the key word above is "can".It does not matter if the gates are open or closed at any point. If the public can have reasonable access and right to access said road, then the answer is no.
But as I say - only my own understanding, and quite happy to be corrected.
K
A public place is any place where there general public have access by payment or otherwise at the material time isnt it?.
So I would say if there is a private road and the gate is shut then no problem, as the public are 'gated off' from it so dont have access. If the gate was open then I'd say it counts as a public place.
I reckon keep the gate shut and there's no worries with him driving about on it.
So I would say if there is a private road and the gate is shut then no problem, as the public are 'gated off' from it so dont have access. If the gate was open then I'd say it counts as a public place.
I reckon keep the gate shut and there's no worries with him driving about on it.
I am pretty certain that the answer is no, he cannot use it.
The Highways Act defines a highway as being for the passage and re-passage of vehicles. i.e. A Public Right of Way for cars etc.
A private Street merely indicates that it is not maintained at Public expense, but by the owners of the property that have frontages along that road.
Gating of a highway would be something that only the Highway Authority with a Traffic Order can do, or a uniformed Policeman, who have lots of special powers.
A long driveway to a stately home e.g. Goodwood would be a private access and can therefore be gated. This is what you need with the owner's consent
Silverstone is a racing circuit on private land and falls outside these definitions and access is controlled by permanently manned barriers.
By way of a good example, I recall the story of a Prison Officer cycling to work at 6am on a foggy Christmas Day. He normally took a short cut through his local Superstore car park, but on this day the store was closed and he was unable to stop and wrote off his bike and was badly injured. The case was taken to court. The Supestore provided evidence from the Highway Authority that, at the time of planning consent, the road was a defined as a private access road, with a barrier. The defence argued that since that time, the Superstore had become a 24/7 364-day operation and in the public's mind tghe access roads had become a highway and that it was reasonable for them to forsee that closing the barrier one day each year was likely to result in such an accident. The judge agreed and the compensation claim was met.
The Highways Act defines a highway as being for the passage and re-passage of vehicles. i.e. A Public Right of Way for cars etc.
A private Street merely indicates that it is not maintained at Public expense, but by the owners of the property that have frontages along that road.
Gating of a highway would be something that only the Highway Authority with a Traffic Order can do, or a uniformed Policeman, who have lots of special powers.
A long driveway to a stately home e.g. Goodwood would be a private access and can therefore be gated. This is what you need with the owner's consent
Silverstone is a racing circuit on private land and falls outside these definitions and access is controlled by permanently manned barriers.
By way of a good example, I recall the story of a Prison Officer cycling to work at 6am on a foggy Christmas Day. He normally took a short cut through his local Superstore car park, but on this day the store was closed and he was unable to stop and wrote off his bike and was badly injured. The case was taken to court. The Supestore provided evidence from the Highway Authority that, at the time of planning consent, the road was a defined as a private access road, with a barrier. The defence argued that since that time, the Superstore had become a 24/7 364-day operation and in the public's mind tghe access roads had become a highway and that it was reasonable for them to forsee that closing the barrier one day each year was likely to result in such an accident. The judge agreed and the compensation claim was met.
Edited by rdjohn on Sunday 8th June 08:28
I grew up within such a Private Road in the countryside. Main highway access was and still is roped off once a year to ensure the system retains its "Private" status. At all times, the Public do NOT have a right of way with their vehicles - They are allowed to use it for the sole purpose of visiting private houses on the "estate". The concept is no different to your private drive that happens to be ungated except that it is collectively owned, usually by all houses within the private road.
On my particular "Private road", the road is owned by a private trust and all houses contribute to the trust for the road's upkeep and are essentially the trust's owners or beneficiaries. If it was not roped off annually, the local authority COULD "adopt" it and then charge all residents a stupid amount of money to bring it up to highway standards. The grass verges of each property used to be directly owned by the trust but now have been sold back to each resident for a nominal £1.
The issue of non licensed vehicles on the private road has come up time and again - Not for bangers or kids uninsured but residents using self propelled mowers on their verge that obviously touch the road - General consensus is that the Police have no RTA authority whasoever and the local bobbies have acknowledged that.
Other private roads may have a different status however.
hope this helps
On my particular "Private road", the road is owned by a private trust and all houses contribute to the trust for the road's upkeep and are essentially the trust's owners or beneficiaries. If it was not roped off annually, the local authority COULD "adopt" it and then charge all residents a stupid amount of money to bring it up to highway standards. The grass verges of each property used to be directly owned by the trust but now have been sold back to each resident for a nominal £1.
The issue of non licensed vehicles on the private road has come up time and again - Not for bangers or kids uninsured but residents using self propelled mowers on their verge that obviously touch the road - General consensus is that the Police have no RTA authority whasoever and the local bobbies have acknowledged that.
Other private roads may have a different status however.
hope this helps
We've recently moved to a converted property where there is a half mile private road now with gate and 10 properties altogether. The management company is not set up as yet, however I thought if the road was privately owned and signed as such you could drive the road disqualified or without a license.
This may be something to look into a bit further by the sounds of things. It seems ridiculous to have to rope it off once a year, never heard of anyone doing that with their own driveway.
This may be something to look into a bit further by the sounds of things. It seems ridiculous to have to rope it off once a year, never heard of anyone doing that with their own driveway.
RoadPest’s road sounds very much like they intend to set-up a gated community. In these cases, the gates are normally-closed and restrict access, so that a public right of way cannot be established.
I feel confident that the road described by Nigello would be classified as a highway as the owner and his friends at No21 have to pass No1 to get access to his property. This means that they have established rights of way for their vehicles. The key issue is the means of control of access, and, as in the case of the Superstore I described before, closing a gate once a year probably is not sufficient.
If some kid driving his dad’s car ran into and injured the person mowing the verge, and the Police became involved, you would probably find that it would fall within their jurisdiction. The car owner’s insurance would probably disallow any claim.
Highway Authorities have a duty to ensure that a Private Street is maintained to an adequate standard and the trust was probably set up to demonstrate this. Local (Highway) Authorities tend not to have funds available to “make-up” and adopt private streets these days, though it was once common.
I feel confident that the road described by Nigello would be classified as a highway as the owner and his friends at No21 have to pass No1 to get access to his property. This means that they have established rights of way for their vehicles. The key issue is the means of control of access, and, as in the case of the Superstore I described before, closing a gate once a year probably is not sufficient.
If some kid driving his dad’s car ran into and injured the person mowing the verge, and the Police became involved, you would probably find that it would fall within their jurisdiction. The car owner’s insurance would probably disallow any claim.
Highway Authorities have a duty to ensure that a Private Street is maintained to an adequate standard and the trust was probably set up to demonstrate this. Local (Highway) Authorities tend not to have funds available to “make-up” and adopt private streets these days, though it was once common.
Well a couple of weeks ago I posted following an incident where someone I know called the police following an incidence of an underage driver on a private road.
The police advice at the time was that no offence had been committed. Had the driver been drunk than an offence would have been committed. The same advice was received from the Police posting on this board.
Basically there is a difference in legislation which means some offences need only to be committed in a public place (which would include a private road), others (licence, insurance offences etc) require one to be on the highway.
So an underage driver can drive on a private road.
The police advice at the time was that no offence had been committed. Had the driver been drunk than an offence would have been committed. The same advice was received from the Police posting on this board.
Basically there is a difference in legislation which means some offences need only to be committed in a public place (which would include a private road), others (licence, insurance offences etc) require one to be on the highway.
So an underage driver can drive on a private road.
Driveway to our property is private. Our house (old Grade two listed farmhouse with barns /garages) is around 2 and half miles off the main road. I NOW own all the land around outright. (I bought it at auction when I first married.. I owed my parents and in-laws and the mortgage broker plenty at the time .. but I think a wise decision even though it placed me and Wildy with a huge debt in all reality at the time. I have since paid off all this debt over the years with interest .. which is a big relief to us now.. and I must, sadly, admit that Widly's compo helped us out quite a bit too).
Anyway .. my own kids use this driveway and adjoining land (also owned by us) to practise pre-age driving skills on and I do allow their pals to do so too. I had to take out an additional insurance policy just in case though.
I have to have this policy in any case as a small section of this land links one "public footpath" to another "public footpath". However, I am apparently liable for any incident on the part of the path which falls under my control as "landlord"
So I would suggest to get permission from owner .. who if he is like me .. with appropriate insurance and one or two legally drawn up clauses to protect against daftness
and made obvious that this is the case..
// I then see zero problems for you - provided common sense is used and applied 
So .. to answer .. not a problem. Make sure you have owners's permission and check he has insurance to cope with the public.
Anyway .. my own kids use this driveway and adjoining land (also owned by us) to practise pre-age driving skills on and I do allow their pals to do so too. I had to take out an additional insurance policy just in case though.
I have to have this policy in any case as a small section of this land links one "public footpath" to another "public footpath". However, I am apparently liable for any incident on the part of the path which falls under my control as "landlord"

So I would suggest to get permission from owner .. who if he is like me .. with appropriate insurance and one or two legally drawn up clauses to protect against daftness
and made obvious that this is the case..
// I then see zero problems for you - provided common sense is used and applied 
So .. to answer .. not a problem. Make sure you have owners's permission and check he has insurance to cope with the public.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


