Sheffield to pay back £350,000 in fines
Discussion
At last a council, to use Sheffield's own words "listens to motorists and uses common sense"
After several notices from the adjudicator concerning faulty and misleading signs concerning abus/tram gate and after it lost seven test cases is to write to all drivers fined and return £350 k in fines.
congratulations to the campaigners.
Is the tide turning? Brum next?
link on bbc site soon hopefully

After several notices from the adjudicator concerning faulty and misleading signs concerning abus/tram gate and after it lost seven test cases is to write to all drivers fined and return £350 k in fines.
congratulations to the campaigners.
Is the tide turning? Brum next?
link on bbc site soon hopefully

Obviously there is an element of spin in it, these are politicians but the background in a bit more detail as I understand it is Sheffield applied for this to DfT, who approved the scheme but, and this is crucial, the DfT did not check up that the scheme had been applied correctly. They never ever do.*
The scheme was signed and marked incorrectly and whilst on the one hand it was possible with good observation to work out what was and was not allowed, yet to be fair it was confusing on first approach. Personally, I worked it out, but at the time thought "That's well dodgy signing." Thus a significant number of drivers got a £30 PCN.
A number of test cases went to the adjudicator who pronounced foul play.
Now again, as I understand, it was only when the campaigners threatened a court case against Sheffield council that they backed down and agreed to refund all the fines.
Thus in my view there is political spin at work, and if the council thought they could have got away with the usual stance that most councils take they would have done so. By that I mean taking the attitude of the motorist has admitted the offence by paying the fine, and we can make better use of this money than the motorists and so on and so on.
Of course this is NOT judicial precedent, but I suspect a lot of councils ought to be looking at their stance on such an issue when they know they are continuing to fine people illegally.
The problem occurs when someone proves that one of the three legs is not secure and their penalty is dropped. The councils should morally in my view, stop enforcement at that place for such offences immediately, review the situation and correct the deficiency. They should also review the people who have been fined. In a significant proportion of cases they do nothing, ie continue to issue penalty notices illegaly, don't correct the deficiencies, and don't make a review.
The scheme was signed and marked incorrectly and whilst on the one hand it was possible with good observation to work out what was and was not allowed, yet to be fair it was confusing on first approach. Personally, I worked it out, but at the time thought "That's well dodgy signing." Thus a significant number of drivers got a £30 PCN.
A number of test cases went to the adjudicator who pronounced foul play.
Now again, as I understand, it was only when the campaigners threatened a court case against Sheffield council that they backed down and agreed to refund all the fines.
Thus in my view there is political spin at work, and if the council thought they could have got away with the usual stance that most councils take they would have done so. By that I mean taking the attitude of the motorist has admitted the offence by paying the fine, and we can make better use of this money than the motorists and so on and so on.
Of course this is NOT judicial precedent, but I suspect a lot of councils ought to be looking at their stance on such an issue when they know they are continuing to fine people illegally.
- * Note: when a council applies for the powers for civil enforcement of parking and moving traffic offences it is required to put to rights all the issues where they are deficient in such as signs, road markings, traffic regulation orders. As Richard bentley puts it so eloquently, for an offence to have been committed there are three legs. The law has to be in place and correct, ie the TRO, the signs and markings have to be as prescribed by law, and thirdly the actual offence has to have been committed, eg the parking has to be as alleged. If any of these three legs is not in place then the offence is unenforceable.
The problem occurs when someone proves that one of the three legs is not secure and their penalty is dropped. The councils should morally in my view, stop enforcement at that place for such offences immediately, review the situation and correct the deficiency. They should also review the people who have been fined. In a significant proportion of cases they do nothing, ie continue to issue penalty notices illegaly, don't correct the deficiencies, and don't make a review.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


