Bomb-proof all year round commuter - 3k
Bomb-proof all year round commuter - 3k
Author
Discussion

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
Any recommendations?

Basically has to be relatively low mileage to start with, very very reliable, able to take a givi rack, be comfy (relative to my blade), fully faired, have a good tank range, reasonable economy (40mpg is fine, better is better), not require mentally sticky tyres. Character is entirely superfluous. Starting *every* morning and night is utterly essential.

Shall I just go and buy a VFR or are there alternatives?

Thanks,

Mark

PS. I won't buy another kayasaki I'm afraid.

mywifeshusband

607 posts

229 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
Honda CB500 will do all you want and return 50mpg+.

hiccy

664 posts

243 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
Mark1 Fazer 600, preferably the later "foxeye" model with the bigger tank, kitted out for winter commuting with your givi rack, heated grips and oiler. Pocket a grand and spend it on some blade lovin. smile

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
mywifeshusband said:
Honda CB500 will do all you want and return 50mpg+.
I borrowed a CBF600 from Honda Abingdon with about 70bhp and I'd be 'unhappy' with less than that I think.

m3psm

988 posts

252 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
I had the same dilema recently when I killed the TDM. The VFR was the bike that ticked the most boxes. The only let down was chain drive and not comfy.

A custom seat with gel pad and a Scottoiler sorted it.

It's not economical though at around 40mpg and the most I've got out of a tank is 180 miles with mixed roads ranging from dense city traffic to motorway. The worst is 100 miles when gunning it continuously.

The other bike I'd have had was a Varadero but I needed a bike quickly and the VFR came up first.

BMW's should be better, but they cost a lot more and I've heard numerous stories of unreliability of late.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
VFR choice is very safe and predictable though. At the risk of banging a drum for my own bike - have you considered an Aprilia? 3k will get you an awful lot of Falco or even Futura - less than 10k and 53 plate should be achievable for a Falco at that price.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
A BMW twin. Shaft drive, very reliable, lots of torque (better than power for commuting), good finish, useful commuting extras (ABS, heated grips, etc.) and around 50mpg. Choose your fairing size between the S, the RS or the RT/LT.

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
m3psm said:
I had the same dilema recently when I killed the TDM. The VFR was the bike that ticked the most boxes. The only let down was chain drive and not comfy.

A custom seat with gel pad and a Scottoiler sorted it.

It's not economical though at around 40mpg and the most I've got out of a tank is 180 miles with mixed roads ranging from dense city traffic to motorway. The worst is 100 miles when gunning it continuously.
180 is pretty good. The most I get out of the blade is 120 and that's on a run so 180 represents another days commute before filling up. I don't really care about the fuel economy within reason but filling up every two days is a pain.

I've seen the pictures you posted of yours and it looks rather swish... was there much choice and are they good value?

Cheers,

Mark

m3psm

988 posts

252 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
dern said:
180 is pretty good. The most I get out of the blade is 120 and that's on a run so 180 represents another days commute before filling up. I don't really care about the fuel economy within reason but filling up every two days is a pain.

I've seen the pictures you posted of yours and it looks rather swish... was there much choice and are they good value?

Cheers,

Mark
I do 90 miles a day, so it works out just right, but if I have one fast day, I have to then have a slow day to compensate to get it to last two days smile

There were lots around the £3k mark when I got mine and I chose my one because a) it wasn’t red and b) it was from a dealer that I know and trust.

I’d avoided getting a VFR for years because they have a reputation for dullness, if only based on their reliability, but in reality it is a great bike. It handles, goes and stops and I have no problem keeping up with anything other that very well ridden superbikes. It really is better that its dull image.

I found the riding position harsh after the TDM, but coming from a ‘blade you should be fine with it.

If you’re anywhere near me (SW8 by day or Chelmsford eves) you can give mine a go to see if you like it.

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
m3psm said:
If you’re anywhere near me (SW8 by day or Chelmsford eves) you can give mine a go to see if you like it.
That's very kind of you but I'll probably find one a bit nearer. Thanks for the info.

A mate has just suggested that I get another thundercat. I had one for a year about 10 years ago now and that was a very good bike indeed. Autotrader at lunchtime I think.

Cheers,

Mark

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
hiccy said:
Mark1 Fazer 600, preferably the later "foxeye" model with the bigger tank, kitted out for winter commuting with your givi rack, heated grips and oiler. Pocket a grand and spend it on some blade lovin. smile
What year did the 'foxeye' bike come in and what's the benefit of having one?

There's a 98 fazer 600 for 1700 on bike trader near me with only 17k miles on it which looks ok.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
dern said:
What year did the 'foxeye' bike come in and what's the benefit of having one?
The pre-facelift bike is fugly - I'm guessing that's the main advantage. The newer one looks ok.

Fazer thou might be a good shout!

m3psm

988 posts

252 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
Fazers are great bikes, but after watching my TDM fall apart I'd be wary of Yamaha longevity. That's the only reason I didn't buy another TDM. If they had Honda reliability and build quality I'd have bought the TDM in a heatbeat. Alas they don't so I have the Honda.

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
m3psm said:
Fazers are great bikes, but after watching my TDM fall apart I'd be wary of Yamaha longevity. That's the only reason I didn't buy another TDM. If they had Honda reliability and build quality I'd have bought the TDM in a heatbeat. Alas they don't so I have the Honda.
I must admit that's one aspect of the thundercat I had that I'm a little concerned about. Having said that cleaning my bikes isn't really my forte and cosmetic wear in a commuter doesn't worry me in the slightest. Stuff actually falling off would be an issue thoughwink

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
A BMW twin. Shaft drive, very reliable, lots of torque (better than power for commuting), good finish, useful commuting extras (ABS, heated grips, etc.) and around 50mpg. Choose your fairing size between the S, the RS or the RT/LT.
Looking at the autotrader within budget my choice is restricted to either an F650 or something with a huge number of miles. I understand that a bmw is going to be reliable with a lot of miles on but then hondas are supposed to be like that too.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
dern said:
black-k1 said:
A BMW twin. Shaft drive, very reliable, lots of torque (better than power for commuting), good finish, useful commuting extras (ABS, heated grips, etc.) and around 50mpg. Choose your fairing size between the S, the RS or the RT/LT.
Looking at the autotrader within budget my choice is restricted to either an F650 or something with a huge number of miles. I understand that a bmw is going to be reliable with a lot of miles on but then hondas are supposed to be like that too.
Depends what you mean by ‘a huge number of miles’. Look at adverts for BMWs in general and you will see that in the BMW world ‘a huge number of miles’ are about 75k plus. 20k to 30k is only just run in!

A quick look at Bike Trader immediately found two possibilities:

http://search.autotrader.co.uk/es-uk/www/bikes/BMW...

http://search.autotrader.co.uk/es-uk/www/bikes/BMW...

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
Depends what you mean by ‘a huge number of miles’. Look at adverts for BMWs in general and you will see that in the BMW world ‘a huge number of miles’ are about 75k plus. 20k to 30k is only just run in!

A quick look at Bike Trader immediately found two possibilities:

http://search.autotrader.co.uk/es-uk/www/bikes/BMW...

http://search.autotrader.co.uk/es-uk/www/bikes/BMW...
They both look pretty good actually... I must have been searching closer to home. Thanks.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
dern said:
black-k1 said:
Depends what you mean by ‘a huge number of miles’. Look at adverts for BMWs in general and you will see that in the BMW world ‘a huge number of miles’ are about 75k plus. 20k to 30k is only just run in!

A quick look at Bike Trader immediately found two possibilities:

http://search.autotrader.co.uk/es-uk/www/bikes/BMW...

http://search.autotrader.co.uk/es-uk/www/bikes/BMW...
They both look pretty good actually... I must have been searching closer to home. Thanks.
Don’t forget to factor in to the costs the requirement for a cardigan, pipe and slippers.wink

Kiwi_uk

279 posts

241 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
Yamaha XT660X Supermotard. Okay it's a pretend motard but you can pick them up pretty cheap now. I brought it specifically for commuting at the end of 2005. She has done 24,000 miles now and still hasn't missed a beat. Only thing I've had to replace is the chain and sprockets and the cush drive rubbers.

You are out in the weather so good winter is a necessity. She will cruise at 80mph comfortably and is great around town with all that torque and height.

hugoagogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Monday 23rd June 2008
quotequote all
honda deauville

couriers favourite ntv650 but with a fairing (that isn't made of cardboard boxes)

dead boring, dead reliable, comfy, shaft drive

edit: less than 70 bhp though

Edited by hugoagogo on Monday 23 June 14:54