Run Flat Tyres problems on 335i
Run Flat Tyres problems on 335i
Author
Discussion

mda335i

Original Poster:

3 posts

220 months

Tuesday 1st July 2008
quotequote all
I have a 335i M Sport conv and have had no end of problems with the tyres. I have 19" M sport wheels with Bridgestone RE050A RFT tyres.

At 9500 miles I changed all 4 as they had uneven wear on the inside walls - the rears being the worst, nearly down to the wires....

3500 miles later and I had what I thought was a puncture. It turns out that the rear wheels are both cracked on the inside rim, one being so badly cracked that the air is being lost through the rim. Both the rear tyres are again showing signs of uneven wear on the inside walls, and BMW have advised to rectify the problem needs 2 x new wheels (£500 each), 2 x new tyres (£365 each - as BMW are the only ones who can get hold of them from Bridgestone) as the current tyres which have done 3500 are now deemed not safe!!

BMW has said that there is no known problem with the run flat tyres but it seems to me that the harsh ride of the tyres have caused the wheels to crack, and then the cracked wheels have caused this latest set of tyres to wear unevenly.... It seems that my BMW dealer is not interested in listening to my theories and sees the solution as £1800 and off you go.

Has anyone experienced similar problems with the run flat tyres or cracked wheels?

Webber3

1,228 posts

250 months

Tuesday 1st July 2008
quotequote all
I've read a few things about uneven tyre wear on the RFT's, In fact I think I read about it on this forum.

When I changed the tyres on my 330i M Sport, the fronts looked badly worn on the outside. I'd been checking the pressures once a week, so it wasn't anything to do with low tyre pressure.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Tuesday 1st July 2008
quotequote all
Have a look on www.e90post.com and search for the post on cracked rim.

I have now heard this happening a couple of times, and I would ditch the run flats and put a set of 4 Falken FK452's on al round, they will cost you around £450 fitted and make the ride sublime.

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Wednesday 2nd July 2008
quotequote all
The cracked rim issue is well known in the industry and caused by incorrect removal of the old tyre.

What happens, if using a traditional tyre changer, is this:

The bead breaking blade is positioned as normal and pressure applied.
The bead doesn't break as normal due to the extra stiffness of thesidewall and the extended safety hump of the rim.
The pressure is allowed to build until finally the bead does give way.
The blade, under significant pressure, shoots under the bead of the tyre and whacks the inside of the well of the wheel, cracking it.
No-one notices, new tyre is fitted and off you go.
If you are lucky, the tyre deflates quickly, you go back, the damage is found and you get a new rim and tyre.
If unlucky it goes down very slowly and it's too late to return to the fitter

The UK NTDA, National Tyre Distributors Association, published a bulletin about 18 months, 2 years ago on this subject.


carlovers

424 posts

224 months

Wednesday 2nd July 2008
quotequote all
guys if you get rid of the runflats does it invalidate the warranty?

dphiggins

14 posts

229 months

Wednesday 2nd July 2008
quotequote all
I am thinking of changing my run flats due to ride quality and cost. I also suffer the uneven ware on the outside etc.

What do you guys do for a spare?

Are the falkens a good replacement?. I have a 330 d Msport.

Cheers

Tony 1234

3,465 posts

258 months

Wednesday 2nd July 2008
quotequote all
carlovers said:
guys if you get rid of the runflats does it invalidate the warranty?
I would say it does, car is not then to factory spec.

I informed my insurance co and they wanted another £20.00

Tony

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Wednesday 2nd July 2008
quotequote all
BMW have said that the warranty is fine, the only thing that will change is their breakdown that is included in the first 3 years may only take you to a local tyre supplier or dealer if you get recovered, rather than taking you all the way home.

Insurance should not charge you more?? Seems strange they did.
I would however tell them you have changed the tyres just so they can't wriggle out of a claim.

Methane Bloke

264 posts

233 months

Wednesday 2nd July 2008
quotequote all
Still have approximately 6mm of tread left after 16000 miles on our 335d rears, but it is on 18" Michelins.

Regards

Chris

Tony 1234

3,465 posts

258 months

Wednesday 2nd July 2008
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
Insurance should not charge you more?? Seems strange they did.
I would however tell them you have changed the tyres just so they can't wriggle out of a claim.
A sudden deflation on a run flat you would not notice. but you would/could be all over the road with a sudden deflation on a non runflat?

Tony

merlin5

112 posts

251 months

Wednesday 2nd July 2008
quotequote all
As mentioned earlier - is there any space to keep a spare?

Webber3

1,228 posts

250 months

Wednesday 2nd July 2008
quotequote all
merlin5 said:
As mentioned earlier - is there any space to keep a spare?
No, you'd need to carry some tyre gunk and a small compressor. Not much you can do if you have a blow out though and I don't think BMW would pay for the tow.

Edited by Webber3 on Wednesday 2nd July 23:59

neiljohnson

11,298 posts

238 months

Thursday 3rd July 2008
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
The cracked rim issue is well known in the industry and caused by incorrect removal of the old tyre.

What happens, if using a traditional tyre changer, is this:

The bead breaking blade is positioned as normal and pressure applied.
The bead doesn't break as normal due to the extra stiffness of thesidewall and the extended safety hump of the rim.
The pressure is allowed to build until finally the bead does give way.
The blade, under significant pressure, shoots under the bead of the tyre and whacks the inside of the well of the wheel, cracking it.
No-one notices, new tyre is fitted and off you go.
If you are lucky, the tyre deflates quickly, you go back, the damage is found and you get a new rim and tyre.
If unlucky it goes down very slowly and it's too late to return to the fitter

The UK NTDA, National Tyre Distributors Association, published a bulletin about 18 months, 2 years ago on this subject.
As said this was originally aimed at the Mini range and was something i saw on many of them (used to do tyres for a Bmw dealer) but if Bmw changed your tyres then you should have a valid argument that they caused the damage. As for the uneven wear it seems to affect all Bridgestones especially when coupled with independent rear suspension.

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Thursday 3rd July 2008
quotequote all
neiljohnson said:
DSM2 said:
The cracked rim issue is well known in the industry and caused by incorrect removal of the old tyre.

What happens, if using a traditional tyre changer, is this:

The bead breaking blade is positioned as normal and pressure applied.
The bead doesn't break as normal due to the extra stiffness of thesidewall and the extended safety hump of the rim.
The pressure is allowed to build until finally the bead does give way.
The blade, under significant pressure, shoots under the bead of the tyre and whacks the inside of the well of the wheel, cracking it.
No-one notices, new tyre is fitted and off you go.
If you are lucky, the tyre deflates quickly, you go back, the damage is found and you get a new rim and tyre.
If unlucky it goes down very slowly and it's too late to return to the fitter

The UK NTDA, National Tyre Distributors Association, published a bulletin about 18 months, 2 years ago on this subject.
As said this was originally aimed at the Mini range and was something i saw on many of them (used to do tyres for a Bmw dealer) but if Bmw changed your tyres then you should have a valid argument that they caused the damage. As for the uneven wear it seems to affect all Bridgestones especially when coupled with independent rear suspension.
Do you mean the NTDA bulletin was aimed at the Mini? If so then I have to say you are wrong. It was aimed directly at, and specifically refers to, issues with 3 and 5 series BMWs.

As for wear, I am on my third set of RFTs on my 320. The first two sets, Continentals wore unevenly, in that the inner shoulder wore more quickly on the rears and the outer shoulder on the fronts. Not totally unexpected considering the suspension and drive system.

The first set from new covered 22,000 miles but were never rotated.

The second set were rotated front to back at 10,000 miles and they covered about 25K before being changed for the current set of Michelins. They have now done about 8K and are showing the same pattern of wear.


neiljohnson

11,298 posts

238 months

Thursday 3rd July 2008
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
neiljohnson said:
DSM2 said:
The cracked rim issue is well known in the industry and caused by incorrect removal of the old tyre.

What happens, if using a traditional tyre changer, is this:

The bead breaking blade is positioned as normal and pressure applied.
The bead doesn't break as normal due to the extra stiffness of thesidewall and the extended safety hump of the rim.
The pressure is allowed to build until finally the bead does give way.
The blade, under significant pressure, shoots under the bead of the tyre and whacks the inside of the well of the wheel, cracking it.
No-one notices, new tyre is fitted and off you go.
If you are lucky, the tyre deflates quickly, you go back, the damage is found and you get a new rim and tyre.
If unlucky it goes down very slowly and it's too late to return to the fitter

The UK NTDA, National Tyre Distributors Association, published a bulletin about 18 months, 2 years ago on this subject.
As said this was originally aimed at the Mini range and was something i saw on many of them (used to do tyres for a Bmw dealer) but if Bmw changed your tyres then you should have a valid argument that they caused the damage. As for the uneven wear it seems to affect all Bridgestones especially when coupled with independent rear suspension.
Do you mean the NTDA bulletin was aimed at the Mini? If so then I have to say you are wrong. It was aimed directly at, and specifically refers to, issues with 3 and 5 series BMWs.

As for wear, I am on my third set of RFTs on my 320. The first two sets, Continentals wore unevenly, in that the inner shoulder wore more quickly on the rears and the outer shoulder on the fronts. Not totally unexpected considering the suspension and drive system.

The first set from new covered 22,000 miles but were never rotated.

The second set were rotated front to back at 10,000 miles and they covered about 25K before being changed for the current set of Michelins. They have now done about 8K and are showing the same pattern of wear.
The mini one was a Bmw internal thing as they were supplying a lot of new wheels under warranty at the time and came out probably 5-6 yrs ago now.

The way you describe your tyre wear is like you say pretty normal for any front engine rwd vehicle the problem with the Bridgestones is that the inner most edges go out of shape ie like a 50p. This seems to be a problem with all Bridgestones on cars with irs be it a Bmw or a Ford Focus and in extreme cases they cause a noise which sounds like a wheel bearing gone. Pirelli p6000 to name one other, have the same problem strangly enough??





pgarvey

2 posts

220 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
I have had the exact same problem with my 335i - both rear wheels having three cracks in equidistant places. I was told by BMW on both occassions it was impact damage - which I dispute. On the second occassion the cracked wheel was identified by a local tyre company before removing or endevouring to remove the tyre. I have had independents, KwikFit and the local tyre company, examine the last wheel - both of who have testified that there is no evidence of impact damage - two weeks ago BMW's Regional Specialist looked at the wheel - I am waiting on his findings - but not optimistic.

mda335i

Original Poster:

3 posts

220 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Here was the "official findings" from the BMW UK regional technical Manager, who apparently, is the highest point of escalation within BMW UK, according to the customer service team.

'Carried out inspection of both wheels. Found kerbing damage to outside edges of rims. Removed both tyres, ran wheel on wheel balance equipment to measure the
radial run-out. Measured the run-out on both rims found one rim 1.20mm, other rim 0.91mm. The max permissible run out is 0.3mm.

The excessive distortion to the rims can only be caused by impact from outside source resulting in the rims cracking. Due to the results of the inspection the
wheels cannot be claimed under the manufacturers warranty.'

Will now be replacing the wheels through my insurance and decide whether to take it further with BMW, although their customer servic team have rejected the complaint and consider it "case closed".

It seems too much of a coincidence that I have now come across 7 or 8 cases of the same problem - 3 of which through my current BMW dealership.

phazon

10 posts

218 months

Friday 26th September 2008
quotequote all
pgarvey said:
I have had the exact same problem with my 335i - both rear wheels having three cracks in equidistant places. I was told by BMW on both occassions it was impact damage - which I dispute. On the second occassion the cracked wheel was identified by a local tyre company before removing or endevouring to remove the tyre. I have had independents, KwikFit and the local tyre company, examine the last wheel - both of who have testified that there is no evidence of impact damage - two weeks ago BMW's Regional Specialist looked at the wheel - I am waiting on his findings - but not optimistic.
pgarvey,

Any update on the regional specialist's report? I have the same issue just discovered today. Need two rear tyres and in dispute with Vines of Guildford - they say I have to buy wheels & tyresand then they will investigate.

Thanks

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Friday 26th September 2008
quotequote all
The 225M rims have been tested by MIRA and been found to have defective casting proccesses, as advised, search for the post on E90. Changing tyres does not affect warranty.

MattOz

4,021 posts

295 months

Friday 26th September 2008
quotequote all
Here's the E90Post link

http://www.e90post.com/forums/showthread.php?t=170...

Good Luck
Matt