Garmin Zumo 550 or TomTom Rider V2 Europe?
Garmin Zumo 550 or TomTom Rider V2 Europe?
Author
Discussion

Stig

Original Poster:

11,823 posts

315 months

Friday 11th July 2008
quotequote all
Hi all,

The question's in the title really. I'm after a decent sat nav to replace the TomTom mobile in my phone.

I'd like to use it in both the car and on the bike (so +1 to Zumo for inclusive car mount on this score at least but like the familiar TomTom interface.

Full postscode navigation and European mapping is a must.

Any opinions?

toxgobbler

2,903 posts

222 months

Friday 11th July 2008
quotequote all
As a straw poll, most of the people in my IAM group seem to favour the Zumo over the tomtom. I use an Indago which is actually a car one with a battery.

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Friday 11th July 2008
quotequote all
I bought a second hand Tomtom 700 working on the principal that I only use it on the bike for specific journeys and if it dies due to getting wet then it didn't cost too much in the first place. That was 3 years ago! It’s been soaked through in an absolute downpour in France and been caught in many rainstorms. It has only once actually stopped working due to being wet and I’ve switched it off on a couple of occasions just as a precaution. I’ve had to dry it out under a hot air hand drier before now but it has never failed to re-start.

My suggestion would be to save your money and buy a cheap second hand car one off e-bay.

G Man

4,053 posts

291 months

Friday 11th July 2008
quotequote all
The Zumo is a good piece of kit , but there are some fundamental problems, the mounting kit for bikes must have the security screw locked down else you will see the Zumo heading to the ditch. ( like mine )

The voice directions come very late. The sound level is marginal using autocom and ear plugs, there are internet fixes for this.

What do you need the 550 for, will you use the traffic info stuff else save your money and get the 400

Stig

Original Poster:

11,823 posts

315 months

Friday 11th July 2008
quotequote all
G Man said:
The Zumo is a good piece of kit , but there are some fundamental problems, the mounting kit for bikes must have the security screw locked down else you will see the Zumo heading to the ditch. ( like mine )

The voice directions come very late. The sound level is marginal using autocom and ear plugs, there are internet fixes for this.

What do you need the 550 for, will you use the traffic info stuff else save your money and get the 400
Hi Gareth,

Traffic info not really relevant to me, but European mapping is. What's the spec. difference between the 400 and the 550?

As long as I get voice guidance (speaker/bluetooth/wired) across Europe and 7 digit postcodes I'm a happy bunny smile

I take the point about car versions being alot cheaper too - I'm tempted and may just run with a tank bag with waterproof pouch for the times when I need it on the bike?

G Man

4,053 posts

291 months

Friday 11th July 2008
quotequote all
Zumo comparison chart

https://buy.garmin.com/shop/compare.do?cID=135&amp...

Basically the 550 calls out the street names

AndyDRZ

1,202 posts

267 months

Saturday 12th July 2008
quotequote all
I got a Car TomTOm 720 and just ran a Cig lighter socket to the front of the bike.

The tom tom sits in the map section of my tank bag and I have noise cancelling headphones.

This means I can listen to mp3's from the tomtom and get instructions on which way to turn. It's a lot cheaper than getting a bike one and it's easier to use in the car too.

Cherrybusa

16 posts

220 months

Saturday 12th July 2008
quotequote all
Have both the a Zumo 550 and a earlier streetpilot 2620 with V9 maps - I believe the 2620 to be better. I find the Zumo a little scant on map detail compared with the non NT maps. Also found the Zumo sometimes lags a little on directions.

Chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
G Man said:
The Zumo is a good piece of kit , but there are some fundamental problems, the mounting kit for bikes must have the security screw locked down else you will see the Zumo heading to the ditch. ( like mine )
Yep, this is big PITA. Everyone I know has lost their screw. Garmin are appy to send you another one FOC, but that's not the point I guess. However, the Zumo is brilliant. I'm the worst navi, nava...I get lost all the time, and it's erfect. Get one.

Cheers.

Tazfan

1,186 posts

281 months

Monday 15th September 2008
quotequote all
TomTom Rider here. Cant fault it. In fact, I would be lost without it!

carinatauk

1,617 posts

283 months

Monday 15th September 2008
quotequote all
Zumo experience:

1. Unless its set up properly it will take you down the strangest of routes [I spent a lot of time ignoring the proposed routes whilst in Europe; I have now set it to LORRY!! confused and no U Turns!]. On the Austrian / German border, whilst looking for the "Eagles Nest" [Hilter's Meeting house] we were taken up some country lanes [read off road] when it was set for NO off road experiences

2. It doesn't necessarily take you the most logical way. I compared the tom tom one and zumo in the car; Zumo would have taken me cross country [as in Peterborough to Liverpool meant going via A52, M1 etc] but TT1 took me the most logical route [A1, M62 etc].

2. Mapsource is good for setting up routes and downloading your history

3. I have had two failures with the power cradle that holds the Zumo due to water ingress

In comparison, I have not tried the TTR2 so it is hard to comment. Most folks I have met liked their Zumo and I have only ever met a TTR1 person who also liked his.

Garmin were very good when I have had issues, Tom Tom I can't comment on as I haven't had one fail yet but I understand they are difficult to contact.

The overall Zumo experience wasn't what I had hoped for but I shall continue to try and improve my skills and see if that experience improves too

RizzoTheRat

29,150 posts

223 months

Monday 15th September 2008
quotequote all
Dunno about the Garmin but the Tomtom doesn't have a wired audio connection, however it does come with a Scala Rider bluetooth headset that works pretty well.