Mk5 golf GTI
Author
Discussion

chriz1

Original Poster:

739 posts

245 months

Saturday 12th July 2008
quotequote all
Looking at purchasing a mk 5 golf gti,
can any owners give me their views on the car what its like day to day,mpg,performance,comfort any annoying bits etc.
Cheers

Juicetin1

647 posts

220 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Gladly give you some feedback. I have a 2006 3 door in Tornado Red with 18inch Monza 2 wheels, 24k miles.
A Great car to look at and to drive, rides very well indeed, very quiet on the road, great bump absorption and body control considering its weight. Nicely weighted steering, good brakes, accurate if a little light 6 speed box (not DSG on mine).
Its a big car and very roomy inside, much more so than a Mk4 Golf.
Interior is a nice place to be, well laid out, well equipped, brilliant seats & one of the best steering wheels ive ever seen.
The engine has got some “rave” reviews, its okay but I wouldn’t say it’s a particularly charismatic or exciting engine, its quiet, smooth linear power delivery, plenty of torque low down which makes for fast progress, would be even better with a + 40bhp remap (loads of companies doing this from £300) . As standard it “feels” like about 7secs 0-60, quick enough for most people. Mine has averaged 34mpg over 5000miles.
Few minus points... build quality isnt what it used to be with Mk2 and 3s, thin body panels can easily dent, the paint is thin and chips easily, the 18inch wheels mark and corrode very easily because they’re highly polished and lacquered, there can be numerous rattles and squeaks from the interior (particularly the centre aircon vent, which can be DIY fixed, refer to forums on the web or ask me) and at the moment my ABS and traction control is broken and waiting repair. Check out the used reviews on www.whatcar.com.
Overall it’s a really nice car to own and to drive (looks much nicer with optional body coloured bumpers and the 18inch wheels), its fun and fast and the excellent reviews are probably justified, personally I just wish there were fewer niggles as stated above.

Cheers.

chriz1

Original Poster:

739 posts

245 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
thanks for the reply,im also considering the 2.0 desil version anyone got any views on this

Silverbullet767

11,337 posts

236 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
chriz1 said:
thanks for the reply,im also considering the 2.0 desil version anyone got any views on this
How many miles do you do per year?

upwards of 18k I would say go for a diesel. I do 24k a year and a petrol would not suit me.

tvrgaas

1,483 posts

300 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Just got (a new) one. 5dr 17" also in Red. Averaging about 30mpg, once got upto nearly 40mpg trundling along the M25 (M1->M3)in 6th at about 60mph. Performance is, as Rolls used to say, adequate. smile You do however then see the mpg fall. Comfort is nice - 08 spec has leather as standard, although they skimp on the sides of the seats rolleyes
I don't think you can get a GTI diesel, but you can in the slightly different the GT spec. I tried a few A3s before I got the Golf. The 140 diesel redline was at 4500rpm, which compares to the petrol at 6500rpm. I found although it went well, one was always hitting the rev limit, so another gear change required. In the GTI one can nearly use any of the 6 gears. Decided that diesel wasn't for me. They also do a 170PS diesel! I also tried the new 1.8T petrol in a S line A3 on 18" wheels. Thought ride was terrible, so went for the golf.

steebo888

784 posts

228 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
im also looking into this after xmas.
going for either the gti or 140tdi

i think with the price of diesel compared to petrol you need to do over 20k a year but al see what the prices are then

Rob_T

1,916 posts

281 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
bought a mk5 gti from new in may 2006. 42k miles later, no problems whatsoever. trip computer states ave mpg for time of ownership is 28mpg.

have high spec car - dsg, sat nav, leather, 18" monza 5 door, metallic black. nothing gone wrong at all. services fine etc etc.

only downside, road noise from tyres on harsher road surfaces.

no regrets. get one!

cuprabob

19,763 posts

244 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
One thing to note is tht the average mpg figure wil not be for the full 42K miles of ownership. The computer resets the 2nd memory periodicaly after so many miles / time elapsed so your average mpg will probably be higher than the 28mpg you quote

Thorny

1,076 posts

240 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
We've got a black 5dr DSG GTI with all the toys and it is brilliant - fast, smooth and surprisingly roomy; does everything very well. Wheels are a bit prone to kerbing and we swapped the CD changer for an ipod adaptor which isn;t brilliant in terms of functionality but works. Fantastic car - get one. I got ours from Euro Imports which was great value and got great service.

cannedheat

953 posts

305 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Pretty quick cars...



60-100 in about 8secs or a smidge under.

Filmed in my Dads standard Mk5, one up on 95ron but 30k+ miles on the clock...



Edited by cannedheat on Thursday 17th July 23:28