Is teaching easier or harder than working in the private sec
Is teaching easier or harder than working in the private sec
Author
Discussion

schmalex

Original Poster:

13,616 posts

237 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
My mother is down tonight, kindly looking after my son tomorrow. We have just had a debate about whether working as a teacher is harder work than working in a corporate (my Mother was a teacher for 15 years or so before she retired due to ill health). The two sides of the debate are:

Me:

  • Teachers get c. 5 months per year holiday. No matter which way you cut it, this is a whole st load of time off (even if you have to spend some time doing prep work etc).
  • Bearing in mind the amount of time off, a teacher's salary is not too bad (I acknowledge that it could be better, as a good teacher is worth their weight in gold)
  • I work in sales - the pressure of having to close $4.5m business per quarter, every quarter far outweighs the pressure of working with kids
  • I get 20 days holiday per year - I would give my right arm to have that much time off per year
Mother:

  • Holidays as a teacher are not holidays - you have to spend some of the time working
  • The pay is rubbish
  • The pressure of dealing with 30+ kids day in, day out is much worse than corporate life
So, I throw it open to PH - is working as a teacher easier or more difficult than working in the private sector?

mouk786

1,263 posts

228 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Well it depends on what you do in the coporate sector. I imagine a lot of josb that are easier than being a teacher pay more than being a teacher.

I think being a good teacher is becoming increasingly harder and as you say the yare worth their weight in gold

I was considering becoming a secondary shcool teacher, and I wouldn't have been st hot, if I do say myself - but I was put off by the increasingly poor behaviour of todays youth (I could gradually see it getting worse when I was in school)


MitchT

17,167 posts

240 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
The short days and long holidays are a myth.

My OH was a teacher - she did 7am-6pm at the school every day and then 7pm-11pm paperwork at home every night. At least half of the weekend was spent working too. Half of her holiday time was consumed going into the school to sort stuff out and what holiday time she did have totally to herself was consumed by being physically exhausted from the work or emotionally exhausted from dreading going back. Her wage was nearly double what mine was at the time, but divided by the actual hours she put in came to about £4/hour. In the end she quit and got a £9k job that didn't leave her with no life at all.

Make me a coffee

107 posts

220 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
I'm a teacher and it is a slack doss. It really is. Sorry to be hugely arrogant but I would say 99% of teachers get into it for the big holidays and going home early. If you have no flair, you have to work bloody hard and that's what a lot of them do. Teachers get paid enough in my opinion as they don't work a lot of the year.

All the marking, I'm up until 11:30 doing preparation..... bullst! It's like a load of hens clucking. I've worked in OTHER JOBS and teachers wouldn't know hard work if it shagged them up the arse.

The kids aren't a problem if you have the right approach, even the worst punks.

What I do have a problem with are the staff. What a bunch of spineless pricks. I honestly can't tell you how much the most petty, tedious and downright immature characteristics rub off on the most seasoned sport.

Teaching is a total slack off compared to real life.

Edit:- I would actually say that the whiny aspect "No-one knows how much the work hurts" is a wet psychological disposition. They would be twitching like that anyway, even if the workload was halved.

Edited by Make me a coffee on Tuesday 15th July 22:22

deevlash

10,442 posts

268 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Ive got a mate thats a teacher, I think a large part of the problem is that a lot of teachers go straight from school to uni to teaching and know sod all about having a real job. They then bleat about having to stay late at "work" till ooh 6pm and have to do some marking. My pal has about 2 free periods a day too.


Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
I know a lot of teachers - some of them will tell you that it's constant hard work, long hours, and low pay. The rest say it's as much effort as falling off a log and you get paid handsomely for your efforts.

Pay seems to vary massively, going (on those I know) from £20k to £48k.

Pay doesn't seem to correlate to the amount of work put in - the £48k person does bugger all and enjoys virtually every minute of the "extended" holiday, while one on £20k seems to work long into the night every night and all holidays.

All said though, for the same money as I'm on now, there is no way I'd be a teacher and have to put up with other peoples little bds giving me hassle all day.

Nick_F

10,598 posts

277 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
I'm with Armstrong and Miller...

Teching consumes a lot of time until you have all your ducks in a row; once you've got some time under your belt, your lesson and course plans organised and so-on then it's not such a challenge.

MitchT

17,167 posts

240 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Make me a coffee said:
Some stuff...
It must vary one hell of a lot from one school to another then. My OH was a wreck and there's no way I'd touch that job with a barge-pole for less than 100 times what she was being paid, based on the state she was in all of the time.

SwissCamel

352 posts

223 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Make me a coffee said:
I've worked in OTHER JOBS and teachers wouldn't know hard work if it shagged them up the arse.
That is perhaps the funniest, and yet most concise way I've ever heard the whole teacher workload summed up. (Speaking as the OH of a teacher, who thinks she is hard done by)

shadowninja

80,192 posts

313 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
MitchT said:
Make me a coffee said:
Some stuff...
It must vary one hell of a lot from one school to another then. My OH was a wreck and there's no way I'd touch that job with a barge-pole for less than 100 times what she was being paid, based on the state she was in all of the time.
I wouldn't mind working in a grammar school. I would hate to work in an Inner London school. (Assuming I would work as a teacher in the first place.)

Edited by shadowninja on Tuesday 15th July 22:42

Deluded

4,968 posts

222 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
My mum's a teacher and has been for the past 20 or so years..she used to work in the private sector then after having me and my sister decided to go into school work due to the lovely hours..luckly in that time you didn't need to do much training..so for the over the years she has managed to support the househould, look after 2 kids and also complete 2 long distance degrees..the final one she is still doing which his her masters. On the side of this for about 4 years she spent literally the whole of her spare time in July and the beginning of August marking SAT papers from other schools to just earn a little extra money.

This is her general day.
7am- she gets into school just to open up and deal with staff sickness and arranging cover (fair enough this comes as part of the assistant head role) during this time she also prepares for the day in general
8.30 - 9 majority of the children start to arrive minus the few from breakfast club
9-12ish - she has 30 children in her class with one teaching assistant if available. 4 of the children are been statemented for special needs and behaviour problems, 2 see a play therapist 1 of these can not be left on his own for literally a second and has to sit at her desk to work..just the other day she allowed him to intergrate with the other children and sat him at a table, this is where he pulls his trousers down and starts 'attacking' children.
12-1ish she has no dinner..she runs a variety of clubs, art, music and drama
1-3.30is - exactly the same as the morning
3.30 - 4pm she has a variety of parents complaining about other children and other parents! and also has parents arguing in the playground which she has to sort out.
4pm - 5.30pm- she runs an afterschool club and also sorts out children who's parents do not turn up! or turn up drunk!

The particular boy who can not be left on his own even has to stay with her for dinner!

between novemeber and decemeber she is constantly sorting out christmas plays and also other performances. June and July she works non stop to do reports for all the children. and literally loads of other little things that people probably wont think about. and then theres her planning and marking she does at home. She says loves her job and is really dedicated to it! you wouldn't think it the way she comes home stressed every night. believe it or not teachers have 'targets' to meet too

Now my other half used to be a nursery nurse.. the last nursery she worked in, she worked in a room which had 40 children..fair enough it was one adult to every 8 children, so 5 adults..but it never worked like that..staff would find ways to get out the room..staff would be sick with no cover at all..she was constantly physically and mentally tired!..now shes a childcare assessor and travels around everyday helping students through their work based child care qualification!..she has a caseload of 30 learners..but been out of a 'classroom' is such a relieve of pressure! as its more one-on-one work..just annoying when they don't do work set and they don't meet their targets.

Glade

4,518 posts

254 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Always a Can of worms... My qualification on this matter.... My other half is a teacher. Her mother is a successful head teacher.

I used to think teaching was nothing like industry... but in many ways it is very similar.

If you work hard and take on roles above an beyond the call of duty, management realise and give you more, and more. This means you work longer days, and have lots of prep in holidays etc. There are a number of schemes and mechanisms for progression, and if you throw yourself into it you can get a good salary. You end up trying to implement new things in an environment resistant to change, and the unions are a pain in the arse. However you get a lot out of it and getting the kids through makes it worthwhile.

If you are slack you can actually get away with not doing a lot... but then you don't progress and get the standard payrise which is ok until you've been there long enough to hit the ceiling for your job. There are strong unions and if you kick up a fuss they will back you regardless... giving you a percived strength (but you're still not going anywhere). Experience shows that some people do the bare minimum but expect automatic promotion, then get disgruntled when they get overlooked, downward spiral.

There are loads of shades of grey in between.


For reference my partner will be turn hit 26 when school starts again. She is an M4 (possibly M5?) and will have 1x TLR1 point for intergrated curriculum co-ordinator, and 1x TLR2 point for KS4 English co-ordinator. This puts her salary somewhat over £30k (the info is out there anyone can look it up)... people who say teacher's salaries are crap are taking horsest... you get out what you put in.

http://www.teachernet.gov.uk/docbank/index.cfm?id=... - Understanding teacher's pay

My 2p, Make of that what you will. (hope i haven't contradicted myself)

Sillybilly

231 posts

221 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
It's piss easy. Did some in my summer holidays at uni.

I've much more respect for youth workers to be honest. Not hard as such but more draining.

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Sillybilly said:
It's piss easy. Did some in my summer holidays at uni.
rofl Fully qualified then!

Catz

4,869 posts

242 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Depends where and who you teach.

My school regularly has the police called by the head teacher, either to stop kids(under 12) and/or parents verbally or physically assaulting others or staff.

If it was just about lesson plans and marking I'd say it could be an easyish job but teachers now have far more roles than this.

Short and sweet from me as I'm on my Summer hols and feeling chilled for a change. smile

R TOY

1,747 posts

259 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Teachers come across as a whinging lot, especially stiking over pay when they already earn more than most of the parents who have to miss a days work/pay to look after their kids. The kids they teach lose respect for the teachers over this sort of behaviour. (to put it mildly). The best one is when they have a teacher training day in term time having just had a bloody 6 week holiday !! WTF is that about.. what message does that send to the kids??
Yes there is homework to mark, etc etc but come on 9-3 is hardly a long day and the holidays more than make up for any extra hours.
Some folk just dont know when they are well off..


Catz

4,869 posts

242 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
R TOY said:
Some folk just dont know when they are well off..

And some people have no idea what being a teacher involves ...

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
R TOY said:
Teachers come across as a whinging lot, especially stiking over pay when they already earn more than most of the parents who have to miss a days work/pay to look after their kids. The kids they teach lose respect for the teachers over this sort of behaviour. (to put it mildly). The best one is when they have a teacher training day in term time having just had a bloody 6 week holiday !! WTF is that about.. what message does that send to the kids??
Yes there is homework to mark, etc etc but come on 9-3 is hardly a long day and the holidays more than make up for any extra hours.
Some folk just dont know when they are well off..

Many teachers don't "choose" to go on strike, if the school is closed they don't have a choice. Likewise, they don't choose when the inset days are held!

But hey, if it's that easy why doesn't everybody do it? smile

R TOY

1,747 posts

259 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
Catz said:
R TOY said:
Some folk just dont know when they are well off..

And some people have no idea what being a teacher involves ...
I have some idea, not from personal experience granted but from talking to friends who teach or work as assistants. A lot of teachers seem to have no idea what not being a teacher involves.


deevlash

10,442 posts

268 months

Tuesday 15th July 2008
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
R TOY said:
Teachers come across as a whinging lot, especially stiking over pay when they already earn more than most of the parents who have to miss a days work/pay to look after their kids. The kids they teach lose respect for the teachers over this sort of behaviour. (to put it mildly). The best one is when they have a teacher training day in term time having just had a bloody 6 week holiday !! WTF is that about.. what message does that send to the kids??
Yes there is homework to mark, etc etc but come on 9-3 is hardly a long day and the holidays more than make up for any extra hours.
Some folk just dont know when they are well off..

Many teachers don't "choose" to go on strike, if the school is closed they don't have a choice. Likewise, they don't choose when the inset days are held!

But hey, if it's that easy why doesn't everybody do it? smile
theyre too busy being policemen, working for the council and being airport firemen...hehe