Spread betting - any thoughts if this is right?
Spread betting - any thoughts if this is right?
Author
Discussion

Chilli

Original Poster:

17,320 posts

267 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
I had a position open, and went to realise a profit. (The firm I use is something a horse might do!) I pressed "close" and the status went to "close requested". Meantime price fluctuations meant that very shortly afterwards the profit turned into a loss. Then the market closed, and all trades went to "phone". I just called them and they've said that the position is closed and I'll be debited with £128 in the morning as it was closed at a loss. Well that's not what I saw when I hit the close button. Shirley the fact that there was a delay their end shouldn't mean that I lose £250.

Cheers.

2 sMoKiN bArReLs

32,050 posts

266 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
That's what comes of using a firm called Poo.

mitzy

13,858 posts

228 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Chilli said:
I had a position open, and went to realise a profit. (The firm I use is something a horse might do!)

Cheers.
Eat Hay?

MitchT

17,167 posts

240 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
If you read the T&Cs you'll probably notice something to the effect of "if the system f**ks-up and you lose money, tough!" However, people have been known to reclaim losses incurred as a result of technical glitches. I myself have been successful in getting a position re-opened when it was shown as having been stopped-out even though the SB company's own charts clearly showed that the price hadn't been anywhere near my stop level.

Chilli

Original Poster:

17,320 posts

267 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
True. I had one about a year ago, where I tried to realise a nice profit, and the trade was rejected. This obviously then turned into a loss. I moaned and they honoured it.
However, this one is clearly a case of what the screen was displaying, wasn't a true picture of events. Therefore I think that's very misleading. However, I don't really have any hard evidence, unless screen activity is recorded somewhere.

Timmy35

13,014 posts

229 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Chilli said:
True. I had one about a year ago, where I tried to realise a nice profit, and the trade was rejected. This obviously then turned into a loss. I moaned and they honoured it.
However, this one is clearly a case of what the screen was displaying, wasn't a true picture of events. Therefore I think that's very misleading. However, I don't really have any hard evidence, unless screen activity is recorded somewhere.
Chilli please for the love of god stop trying to day trade. Enter into into positions backed by fundamentals and a healthy chart outlook, with a margin large enough not to get shaken out by a spike, enter your stop profit and stop loss and leave the bugger alone.

Just my opinion / advice of course.

Chilli

Original Poster:

17,320 posts

267 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Timmy35 said:
Chilli said:
True. I had one about a year ago, where I tried to realise a nice profit, and the trade was rejected. This obviously then turned into a loss. I moaned and they honoured it.
However, this one is clearly a case of what the screen was displaying, wasn't a true picture of events. Therefore I think that's very misleading. However, I don't really have any hard evidence, unless screen activity is recorded somewhere.
Chilli please for the love of god stop trying to day trade. Enter into into positions backed by fundamentals and a healthy chart outlook, with a margin large enough not to get shaken out by a spike, enter your stop profit and stop loss and leave the bugger alone.

Just my opinion / advice of course.
Oh, I just pop in and out of the Sept contracts at the mo.....Doing rather well, without certain firms trying to screw me.

Horse_Apple

3,795 posts

273 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Chilli said:
I had a position open, and went to realise a profit. (The firm I use is something a horse might do!) I pressed "close" and the status went to "close requested". Meantime price fluctuations meant that very shortly afterwards the profit turned into a loss. Then the market closed, and all trades went to "phone". I just called them and they've said that the position is closed and I'll be debited with £128 in the morning as it was closed at a loss. Well that's not what I saw when I hit the close button. Shirley the fact that there was a delay their end shouldn't mean that I lose £250.

Cheers.
Hello.

Generally, there are a few possible issues:

Your system went slow.

Their system went slow.

The particular market spiked.

You are making too much money and have been switched to manual quote and fill.


Now, the trouble with the first two is that the company has no real choice but to turn round and so, Not our problem. The reason for this is that they have been forced into this position because of the enormous number of punters who when they lose a bet will call up and demand money back with any old fictitious excuse. The net result is that in the old days you could investigate each enquiry but there are now so many people who try it on that it would just swamp a firm to try an entertain them. Even then the vast majority of problems are still on the client side.

A very common problem is people trading in a way that doesn't suite the underlying market and not appreciating this. For example, trying to buy or sell more than exist at Best B&A, or trading something too volatile, which leads me to price spikes: The platform will have built in a level of tollerance against underlying movements during the time it takes for the order to leave the client and hit the broker. If you didn't do this then most trades would get rejected. Different products have different tollerances but very often there is a price spike as the order is sent or someone else lifts some of the liquidity leading to an order rejection.

The last one only applies to very limited number of financial bookies who will monitor winning clients and encourage them to go elsewhere.

If you have continual issues then there is one really easy solution:

Get a DMA account and punt the real products in the real market and see what happens. If all your problems go away then you know it's the bookie or their platform buggering you about. If they persist then you know it is your style which is wrong.

It is a difficult job supplying financial bets as you have to take the real market product and adjust it to fit to a broad spectrum of retail punters. It is essential to keep the market happy on one side and obviously, on the cleints side you just can't get all your clients to fit one mould, as such the end product is a best fit compromise.

It is rarely the broker trying it on. In the old days when they had no competition I would be saying something different, but not now. Clients can move at the drop of a hat there are plenty of competitors all competing hard and there are a limited number of clients. They simply cannot afford to bugger about.

Each broker is slightly different, catering to a slightly different element of the client group but all are a compromise of the real product.

Chilli

Original Poster:

17,320 posts

267 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Thanks mate, appreciate it. Im not doing anything out of the ordinary, and my p/l wouldn't even be seen!
My mate has stopped using them as there platform does seem to be slow, however this is the only one I can log into in the office. I've emailed them and they'll look into it. I'll close the account over this. Its not so much the money I'd have lost, just ther misleading nature of the way their platform is diplsyed and the time period between upddates.

Cheers.