Aussie MMGW Proponent Breaks Ranks
Discussion
(Hope it's not a repost, I did search)
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197...
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197...
Dr David Evans said:
I DEVOTED six years to carbon accounting, building models for the Australian Greenhouse Office. I am the rocket scientist who wrote the carbon accounting model (FullCAM) that measures Australia's compliance with the Kyoto Protocol, in the land use change and forestry sector.
FullCAM models carbon flows in plants, mulch, debris, soils and agricultural products, using inputs such as climate data, plant physiology and satellite data. I've been following the global warming debate closely for years.
When I started that job in 1999 the evidence that carbon emissions caused global warming seemed pretty good: CO2 is a greenhouse gas, the old ice core data, no other suspects.
The evidence was not conclusive, but why wait until we were certain when it appeared we needed to act quickly? Soon government and the scientific community were working together and lots of science research jobs were created. We scientists had political support, the ear of government, big budgets, and we felt fairly important and useful (well, I did anyway). It was great. We were working to save the planet.
But since 1999 new evidence has seriously weakened the case that carbon emissions are the main cause of global warming, and by 2007 the evidence was pretty conclusive that carbon played only a minor role and was not the main cause of the recent global warming. As Lord Keynes famously said, "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?"
There has not been a public debate about the causes of global warming and most of the public and our decision makers are not aware of the most basic salient facts:
1. The greenhouse signature is missing. We have been looking and measuring for years, and cannot find it.
Each possible cause of global warming has a different pattern of where in the planet the warming occurs first and the most. The signature of an increased greenhouse effect is a hot spot about 10km up in the atmosphere over the tropics. We have been measuring the atmosphere for decades using radiosondes: weather balloons with thermometers that radio back the temperature as the balloon ascends through the atmosphere. They show no hot spot. Whatsoever.
If there is no hot spot then an increased greenhouse effect is not the cause of global warming. So we know for sure that carbon emissions are not a significant cause of the global warming. If we had found the greenhouse signature then I would be an alarmist again.
When the signature was found to be missing in 2007 (after the latest IPCC report), alarmists objected that maybe the readings of the radiosonde thermometers might not be accurate and maybe the hot spot was there but had gone undetected. Yet hundreds of radiosondes have given the same answer, so statistically it is not possible that they missed the hot spot.
Recently the alarmists have suggested we ignore the radiosonde thermometers, but instead take the radiosonde wind measurements, apply a theory about wind shear, and run the results through their computers to estimate the temperatures. They then say that the results show that we cannot rule out the presence of a hot spot. If you believe that you'd believe anything.
2. There is no evidence to support the idea that carbon emissions cause significant global warming. None. There is plenty of evidence that global warming has occurred, and theory suggests that carbon emissions should raise temperatures (though by how much is hotly disputed) but there are no observations by anyone that implicate carbon emissions as a significant cause of the recent global warming.
3. The satellites that measure the world's temperature all say that the warming trend ended in 2001, and that the temperature has dropped about 0.6C in the past year (to the temperature of 1980). Land-based temperature readings are corrupted by the "urban heat island" effect: urban areas encroaching on thermometer stations warm the micro-climate around the thermometer, due to vegetation changes, concrete, cars, houses. Satellite data is the only temperature data we can trust, but it only goes back to 1979. NASA reports only land-based data, and reports a modest warming trend and recent cooling. The other three global temperature records use a mix of satellite and land measurements, or satellite only, and they all show no warming since 2001 and a recent cooling.
4. The new ice cores show that in the past six global warmings over the past half a million years, the temperature rises occurred on average 800 years before the accompanying rise in atmospheric carbon. Which says something important about which was cause and which was effect.
None of these points are controversial. The alarmist scientists agree with them, though they would dispute their relevance.
The last point was known and past dispute by 2003, yet Al Gore made his movie in 2005 and presented the ice cores as the sole reason for believing that carbon emissions cause global warming. In any other political context our cynical and experienced press corps would surely have called this dishonest and widely questioned the politician's assertion.
Until now the global warming debate has merely been an academic matter of little interest. Now that it matters, we should debate the causes of global warming.
So far that debate has just consisted of a simple sleight of hand: show evidence of global warming, and while the audience is stunned at the implications, simply assert that it is due to carbon emissions.
In the minds of the audience, the evidence that global warming has occurred becomes conflated with the alleged cause, and the audience hasn't noticed that the cause was merely asserted, not proved.
If there really was any evidence that carbon emissions caused global warming, don't you think we would have heard all about it ad nauseam by now?
The world has spent $50 billion on global warming since 1990, and we have not found any actual evidence that carbon emissions cause global warming. Evidence consists of observations made by someone at some time that supports the idea that carbon emissions cause global warming. Computer models and theoretical calculations are not evidence, they are just theory.
What is going to happen over the next decade as global temperatures continue not to rise? The Labor Government is about to deliberately wreck the economy in order to reduce carbon emissions. If the reasons later turn out to be bogus, the electorate is not going to re-elect a Labor government for a long time. When it comes to light that the carbon scare was known to be bogus in 2008, the ALP is going to be regarded as criminally negligent or ideologically stupid for not having seen through it. And if the Liberals support the general thrust of their actions, they will be seen likewise.
The onus should be on those who want to change things to provide evidence for why the changes are necessary. The Australian public is eventually going to have to be told the evidence anyway, so it might as well be told before wrecking the economy.
Dr David Evans was a consultant to the Australian Greenhouse Office from 1999 to 2005.
FullCAM models carbon flows in plants, mulch, debris, soils and agricultural products, using inputs such as climate data, plant physiology and satellite data. I've been following the global warming debate closely for years.
When I started that job in 1999 the evidence that carbon emissions caused global warming seemed pretty good: CO2 is a greenhouse gas, the old ice core data, no other suspects.
The evidence was not conclusive, but why wait until we were certain when it appeared we needed to act quickly? Soon government and the scientific community were working together and lots of science research jobs were created. We scientists had political support, the ear of government, big budgets, and we felt fairly important and useful (well, I did anyway). It was great. We were working to save the planet.
But since 1999 new evidence has seriously weakened the case that carbon emissions are the main cause of global warming, and by 2007 the evidence was pretty conclusive that carbon played only a minor role and was not the main cause of the recent global warming. As Lord Keynes famously said, "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?"
There has not been a public debate about the causes of global warming and most of the public and our decision makers are not aware of the most basic salient facts:
1. The greenhouse signature is missing. We have been looking and measuring for years, and cannot find it.
Each possible cause of global warming has a different pattern of where in the planet the warming occurs first and the most. The signature of an increased greenhouse effect is a hot spot about 10km up in the atmosphere over the tropics. We have been measuring the atmosphere for decades using radiosondes: weather balloons with thermometers that radio back the temperature as the balloon ascends through the atmosphere. They show no hot spot. Whatsoever.
If there is no hot spot then an increased greenhouse effect is not the cause of global warming. So we know for sure that carbon emissions are not a significant cause of the global warming. If we had found the greenhouse signature then I would be an alarmist again.
When the signature was found to be missing in 2007 (after the latest IPCC report), alarmists objected that maybe the readings of the radiosonde thermometers might not be accurate and maybe the hot spot was there but had gone undetected. Yet hundreds of radiosondes have given the same answer, so statistically it is not possible that they missed the hot spot.
Recently the alarmists have suggested we ignore the radiosonde thermometers, but instead take the radiosonde wind measurements, apply a theory about wind shear, and run the results through their computers to estimate the temperatures. They then say that the results show that we cannot rule out the presence of a hot spot. If you believe that you'd believe anything.
2. There is no evidence to support the idea that carbon emissions cause significant global warming. None. There is plenty of evidence that global warming has occurred, and theory suggests that carbon emissions should raise temperatures (though by how much is hotly disputed) but there are no observations by anyone that implicate carbon emissions as a significant cause of the recent global warming.
3. The satellites that measure the world's temperature all say that the warming trend ended in 2001, and that the temperature has dropped about 0.6C in the past year (to the temperature of 1980). Land-based temperature readings are corrupted by the "urban heat island" effect: urban areas encroaching on thermometer stations warm the micro-climate around the thermometer, due to vegetation changes, concrete, cars, houses. Satellite data is the only temperature data we can trust, but it only goes back to 1979. NASA reports only land-based data, and reports a modest warming trend and recent cooling. The other three global temperature records use a mix of satellite and land measurements, or satellite only, and they all show no warming since 2001 and a recent cooling.
4. The new ice cores show that in the past six global warmings over the past half a million years, the temperature rises occurred on average 800 years before the accompanying rise in atmospheric carbon. Which says something important about which was cause and which was effect.
None of these points are controversial. The alarmist scientists agree with them, though they would dispute their relevance.
The last point was known and past dispute by 2003, yet Al Gore made his movie in 2005 and presented the ice cores as the sole reason for believing that carbon emissions cause global warming. In any other political context our cynical and experienced press corps would surely have called this dishonest and widely questioned the politician's assertion.
Until now the global warming debate has merely been an academic matter of little interest. Now that it matters, we should debate the causes of global warming.
So far that debate has just consisted of a simple sleight of hand: show evidence of global warming, and while the audience is stunned at the implications, simply assert that it is due to carbon emissions.
In the minds of the audience, the evidence that global warming has occurred becomes conflated with the alleged cause, and the audience hasn't noticed that the cause was merely asserted, not proved.
If there really was any evidence that carbon emissions caused global warming, don't you think we would have heard all about it ad nauseam by now?
The world has spent $50 billion on global warming since 1990, and we have not found any actual evidence that carbon emissions cause global warming. Evidence consists of observations made by someone at some time that supports the idea that carbon emissions cause global warming. Computer models and theoretical calculations are not evidence, they are just theory.
What is going to happen over the next decade as global temperatures continue not to rise? The Labor Government is about to deliberately wreck the economy in order to reduce carbon emissions. If the reasons later turn out to be bogus, the electorate is not going to re-elect a Labor government for a long time. When it comes to light that the carbon scare was known to be bogus in 2008, the ALP is going to be regarded as criminally negligent or ideologically stupid for not having seen through it. And if the Liberals support the general thrust of their actions, they will be seen likewise.
The onus should be on those who want to change things to provide evidence for why the changes are necessary. The Australian public is eventually going to have to be told the evidence anyway, so it might as well be told before wrecking the economy.
Dr David Evans was a consultant to the Australian Greenhouse Office from 1999 to 2005.
The labour gumbyment here in aus is about to increase all our energy bills by 16% to somehow cut down on carbon emissions. I have not yet seen anything showing where this money is to be spent.
I fear we are about to start a downward spiral to UK style emissions tax...which will be interesting to see considering most of the cars sold here dont have a hope of meeting even 10 year old euro emission regs.
Public transport is seriously lacking and in most towns there is not enough people living there to pay for anything better so who knows what is going to happen once people cant afford to drive.
Really the sad thing is that the great unwashed here are not smart enough or to apathetic to do anything about the government before its to late. Most people believe whatever they are told by the flipping tv.
I fear we are about to start a downward spiral to UK style emissions tax...which will be interesting to see considering most of the cars sold here dont have a hope of meeting even 10 year old euro emission regs.
Public transport is seriously lacking and in most towns there is not enough people living there to pay for anything better so who knows what is going to happen once people cant afford to drive.
Really the sad thing is that the great unwashed here are not smart enough or to apathetic to do anything about the government before its to late. Most people believe whatever they are told by the flipping tv.
What I found amusing was this:-
I've just come back from Perth and was in the middle of their gas crisis. The gumint told everyone to use less gas and then remarked. "Thankyou for being so gas efficient, we've saved enough energy so far to power a city like Geraldton for 14 days".
IF MMGW WAS SO FRIGGING IMPORTANT, WHY NOT DO THIS ALL THE TIME??????
Tax is better, I suppose. Don't use too much hot water, turn stuff off, etc, etc.
Telling people to continually use less fuel and why (not mmgw, but conservation) works better in my opinion than tax. We moan about tax and pay.
I think the australian government being a maverick of old fashioned no-nonsense or liberal firkyfoodling is a bit romantic. They are the same wet hand wringers and soon I expect they will do the best to ruin their own country
I think the conservationists and policy makers could use a big dose of geological time to put things into perspective. Not to rant but........
1. Life has been around for several billion years.
2. Life will be chemically viable for another couple of billion years
3. If we don't use the fossil fuels someone else will.
4. This will be in a geological nanosecond
5. So, can you stop these silly taxes which are pointless, even if they are for the right moral sentiment.
The above points make a pretty good reason and should be valid for opting out of any green tax, whether it carries any weight or not.
When I'm older, I want a V8, not a lithium ion.
I've just come back from Perth and was in the middle of their gas crisis. The gumint told everyone to use less gas and then remarked. "Thankyou for being so gas efficient, we've saved enough energy so far to power a city like Geraldton for 14 days".
IF MMGW WAS SO FRIGGING IMPORTANT, WHY NOT DO THIS ALL THE TIME??????
Tax is better, I suppose. Don't use too much hot water, turn stuff off, etc, etc.
Telling people to continually use less fuel and why (not mmgw, but conservation) works better in my opinion than tax. We moan about tax and pay.
I think the australian government being a maverick of old fashioned no-nonsense or liberal firkyfoodling is a bit romantic. They are the same wet hand wringers and soon I expect they will do the best to ruin their own country
I think the conservationists and policy makers could use a big dose of geological time to put things into perspective. Not to rant but........
1. Life has been around for several billion years.
2. Life will be chemically viable for another couple of billion years
3. If we don't use the fossil fuels someone else will.
4. This will be in a geological nanosecond
5. So, can you stop these silly taxes which are pointless, even if they are for the right moral sentiment.
The above points make a pretty good reason and should be valid for opting out of any green tax, whether it carries any weight or not.
When I'm older, I want a V8, not a lithium ion.
Edited by Make me a coffee on Friday 18th July 08:57
Man this whole MMGW issue pi§§es me off so much - that Gorey bloke has now challenged the USA to wean itself off oil in 10 years - why doesn't anyone start a legal fight with the guy to openly expose that he manipulated and distorted his material to support his pre-determined conclusions? I have just sent the whole of the above article to the BBC with a moany letter asking why this article doesn't appear on the BBC and why the BBC chooses not to discuss the issue. I wonder if they'll bother to respond...
Rant mode off....and relax......
Rant mode off....and relax......
I've gotten to the point where I dont really care what any government tells me. They cant be trusted with
finances - see Gordon the clown changing his rules on borrowing
law and order - see how many knife deaths are occuring
managing essential infrastructure likes roads - congestion charging
Schools and hospitals - council tax and the NHS
Need I go on? In any case, I simply dont believe anything that any governments tell me. I'm only interested in pursuing that which makes me and my family happy \ comfortable, and I'll take my assets with me when I leave the country, which will be sooner rather than later, and I intend on going somewhere that the government has less reach into both my pockets, and my life.
finances - see Gordon the clown changing his rules on borrowing
law and order - see how many knife deaths are occuring
managing essential infrastructure likes roads - congestion charging
Schools and hospitals - council tax and the NHS
Need I go on? In any case, I simply dont believe anything that any governments tell me. I'm only interested in pursuing that which makes me and my family happy \ comfortable, and I'll take my assets with me when I leave the country, which will be sooner rather than later, and I intend on going somewhere that the government has less reach into both my pockets, and my life.
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



