2001 - Nope still don't get it
Discussion
rhinochopig said:
Years since I last saw it, and it still makes no sense to me.
Self indulgent crap or sci-fi masterpiece?
I had to read up on this whilst I was watching it.Self indulgent crap or sci-fi masterpiece?
Essentially, the black doobries make evolution move on a step. First the apes, then humans. The one on the moon is a signal for the real one at Jupiter.
Man then races to Jupiter to discover what is there, which unbeknown to them will trip the next stage of evolution. What they don't figure is that the race is between the humans and HAL9000. Whoever gets there first, trips the next stage of evolution. Because HAL is brighter than the average calculator, he may have figured this out, but even still is going slightly bonkers because of a conflicting mission statement.
The main chap on the ship eventually reaches the black block, and moves forward a stage in evolution to become a "star child".
And there you have it. Quite simply really

It amkes a lot more sense if you read all three books. Humans would still be apes if it wasn't for the earth monolith pushing us forward. Another monolith is planted on the moon, when we uncover this it sends a signal to the third jupiter monolith. The signal is saying "these guys are pretty smart now as they have made it to the moon, come and see how they're doing and make sure things are going OK with them". Of course, the moon monolith is uncovered just as mankind is creating global havoc with war, pestilence and pollution, so we assume that the jupiter monolith will wipe us out to put right it's mistake and stop us evolving any further in the "wrong" trouble-making direction and annoying the rest of the galaxy.
That is my recollection of it all anyway, been a while since I've read them.
That is my recollection of it all anyway, been a while since I've read them.
tinman0 said:
rhinochopig said:
Years since I last saw it, and it still makes no sense to me.
Self indulgent crap or sci-fi masterpiece?
I had to read up on this whilst I was watching it.Self indulgent crap or sci-fi masterpiece?
Essentially, the black doobries make evolution move on a step. First the apes, then humans. The one on the moon is a signal for the real one at Jupiter.
Man then races to Jupiter to discover what is there, which unbeknown to them will trip the next stage of evolution. What they don't figure is that the race is between the humans and HAL9000. Whoever gets there first, trips the next stage of evolution. Because HAL is brighter than the average calculator, he may have figured this out, but even still is going slightly bonkers because of a conflicting mission statement.
The main chap on the ship eventually reaches the black block, and moves forward a stage in evolution to become a "star child".
And there you have it. Quite simply really

I'd never understood why HAL went loopy and tried to kill everyone. I'd got idea of the monoliths triggering evolutionary jumps, but was never sure whether the white room scenes were snapshots of a real-time portrayal of bowman getting older and then evolving into the star child or whether the monolith had speeded up time so he aged, died, and evolved in 5 mins. It didn't help that I'm slightly hungover today so my attention span isn't great.
rhinochopig said:
tinman0 said:
rhinochopig said:
Years since I last saw it, and it still makes no sense to me.
Self indulgent crap or sci-fi masterpiece?
I had to read up on this whilst I was watching it.Self indulgent crap or sci-fi masterpiece?
Essentially, the black doobries make evolution move on a step. First the apes, then humans. The one on the moon is a signal for the real one at Jupiter.
Man then races to Jupiter to discover what is there, which unbeknown to them will trip the next stage of evolution. What they don't figure is that the race is between the humans and HAL9000. Whoever gets there first, trips the next stage of evolution. Because HAL is brighter than the average calculator, he may have figured this out, but even still is going slightly bonkers because of a conflicting mission statement.
The main chap on the ship eventually reaches the black block, and moves forward a stage in evolution to become a "star child".
And there you have it. Quite simply really

I'd never understood why HAL went loopy and tried to kill everyone. I'd got idea of the monoliths triggering evolutionary jumps, but was never sure whether the white room scenes were snapshots of a real-time portrayal of bowman getting older and then evolving into the star child or whether the monolith had speeded up time so he aged, died, and evolved in 5 mins. It didn't help that I'm slightly hungover today so my attention span isn't great.
The Bowman getting older business was a bit of artistic licence I think. In the book Bowman's *being* (memories, soul if you like) is uploaded into the monolith, and the film tried to portray how Bowman experienced this.
The only thing I've always thought dated the film were the scenes where they watch the BBC news.
Other than that, the SFX are still some of the best ever created and the sets and general look of the interiors and space craft all stand the test of time.
I've read quite a bit about the making of 2001 and there are some really wonderful rigs and effects they used to get the effects looking just right back in the day when CGI hadn't yet been invented.
Overall, it is a true masterpiece and all the better for being difficult to interpret.
Other than that, the SFX are still some of the best ever created and the sets and general look of the interiors and space craft all stand the test of time.
I've read quite a bit about the making of 2001 and there are some really wonderful rigs and effects they used to get the effects looking just right back in the day when CGI hadn't yet been invented.
Overall, it is a true masterpiece and all the better for being difficult to interpret.
My view is that it's a masterpiece. It's not just sci-fi, it's a piece of visual art that has easily stood the test of time.
I'll skip writing pages and pages pointing out why. If you need to have it's wonder explained after a couple of viewings then frankly you'll probably never 'get it'.
I'll skip writing pages and pages pointing out why. If you need to have it's wonder explained after a couple of viewings then frankly you'll probably never 'get it'.
corozin said:
My view is that it's a masterpiece. It's not just sci-fi, it's a piece of visual art that has easily stood the test of time.
I'll skip writing pages and pages pointing out why. If you need to have it's wonder explained after a couple of viewings then frankly you'll probably never 'get it'.
Look I get it I think I just want to know why the monolyths/monoliths black things kill those scientists on the moon.I'll skip writing pages and pages pointing out why. If you need to have it's wonder explained after a couple of viewings then frankly you'll probably never 'get it'.
If its just a signal to its mates that Humans have advanced enough for the next stage surely it would have sent that signal as soon as it was discovered not after being fully excavated and floodlit.
ps I love the film, I love its pace and the music
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




And I'm generally a SciFi fan. From some of the posts here it would seem that reading the books first might have helped. Oh well, it's a little late, now.