Brainstorming session
Author
Discussion

Sillybilly

Original Poster:

231 posts

221 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
This is not a position that I am advocating but I thought it might be interesting to examine how society would be different so any sensible comments would be appreciated.

Suppose baby girls were sold to the highest single male bidder, just after their birth, who would then raise them as their child until they reached around 18, at which point they would have an option (and it would be the usual thing to do) to marry each other. Obviously then the couple have children, selling the girls and raising the boys.

Here are a few advantages:

  • Marriages likely to be very stable and genuine love felt between participants
  • Stability about people's lives
  • Babies most likely to turn out well go to highest bidders - thus society's elite will concentrate but at the same time there ought to be greater genetic mixing; for example poorer parts of the country will have more babies to sell to the richer parts - this will also aid wealth distribution
  • Men will be older when married and thus better equipped to provide for a larger family
  • Paternity leave at the same scale as maternity leave thus helping gender equality

A few disadvantages:

  • Fathers/Husbands-to-be not looking after their daughter/wife-to-be as well as they should as she is not genetically related
  • Potentially social pressure on wommen to get married against their wishes
  • Maybe close to incest

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
I dont know what to say but eek

What on earth prompted this?

escargot

17,123 posts

248 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
So you go from changing its nappy to eventually shagging it?

Did you actually think of this idea? I mean, actually spent time contemplating it properly? - That in itself is hugely unnerving.

KingRichard

10,146 posts

263 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
nuts

Darkslider

3,084 posts

220 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Wouldn't work as you'd never feel sexually attracted to a father/daughter figure.

Sillybilly

Original Poster:

231 posts

221 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
escargot said:
So you go from changing its nappy to eventually shagging it?

Did you actually think of this idea? I mean, actually spent time contemplating it properly? - That in itself is hugely unnerving.
I don't really want to contemplate the acts as such, because clearly to us it is abhorrent, but that's a societal thing.

Suppose we thought it normal. What will the differences between such a society and ours?

Swilly

9,699 posts

305 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Sillybilly said:
This is not a position that I am advocating but I thought it might be interesting to examine how society would be different so any sensible comments would be appreciated.

Suppose baby girls were sold to the highest single male bidder, just after their birth, who would then raise them as their child until they reached around 18, at which point they would have an option (and it would be the usual thing to do) to marry each other. Obviously then the couple have children, selling the girls and raising the boys.

Here are a few advantages:

  • Marriages likely to be very stable and genuine love felt between participants
  • Stability about people's lives
  • Babies most likely to turn out well go to highest bidders - thus society's elite will concentrate but at the same time there ought to be greater genetic mixing; for example poorer parts of the country will have more babies to sell to the richer parts - this will also aid wealth distribution
  • Men will be older when married and thus better equipped to provide for a larger family
  • Paternity leave at the same scale as maternity leave thus helping gender equality

A few disadvantages:

  • Fathers/Husbands-to-be not looking after their daughter/wife-to-be as well as they should as she is not genetically related
  • Potentially social pressure on wommen to get married against their wishes
  • Maybe close to incest
During your brainstorm did an tornado lift you up and drop you in the Intellectual Land of Oz !? hehe

raf_gti

4,258 posts

237 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
[quote=Hillbilly]This is not a position that I am advocating but I thought it might be interesting to examine how society would be different so any sensible comments would be appreciated.

Suppose baby girls were sold to the highest single male bidder, just after their birth, who would then raise them as their child until they reached around 18, at which point they would have an option (and it would be the usual thing to do) to marry each other. Obviously then the couple have children, selling the girls and raising the boys.

Here are a few advantages:

  • Marriages likely to be very stable and genuine love felt between participants
  • Stability about people's lives
  • Babies most likely to turn out well go to highest bidders - thus society's elite will concentrate but at the same time there ought to be greater genetic mixing; for example poorer parts of the country will have more babies to sell to the richer parts - this will also aid wealth distribution
  • Men will be older when married and thus better equipped to provide for a larger family
  • Paternity leave at the same scale as maternity leave thus helping gender equality

A few disadvantages:

  • Fathers/Husbands-to-be not looking after their daughter/wife-to-be as well as they should as she is not genetically related
  • Potentially social pressure on wommen to get married against their wishes
  • Maybe close to incest
[/quote]

Incest - The Game For All The Family

granada28

102 posts

223 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Wow..............Stop smokin that stuff.

escargot

17,123 posts

248 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Sillybilly said:
Suppose we thought it normal. What will the differences between such a society and ours?
I don't know, I haven't and never will contemplate it on the level that you seem to want us to.

BlueCello

6,225 posts

238 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Stay away from me. Please.

Sillybilly

Original Poster:

231 posts

221 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
escargot said:
Sillybilly said:
Suppose we thought it normal. What will the differences between such a society and ours?
I don't know, I haven't and never will contemplate it on the level that you seem to want us to.
I can understand that. I just like to think of strange things because you can often discover genuinely useful stuff from the unlikeliest of places.

For example, I found out today about the Wilhelm scream. Fascinating to think a scream recorded in the 50s, by a now dead actor, is in the latest Indiana Jones movie (as well as over a 100 more).

If this scenario is explored more who knows what one may discover?

Edited by Sillybilly on Saturday 19th July 17:37

john_p

7,073 posts

281 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
This is the scariest thread I have ever read on PH.

escargot

17,123 posts

248 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Sillybilly said:
If this scenario is explored more who knows what one may discover?
To be honest, I suspect the best place to brainstorm this would be your friendly local paedophile ring. They'd probably be more receptive to the idea.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
That is wrong on so many levels, it would be like boning your step daughter. You'd have to change your name to Tod Lerfondler.



This is the mental image I have of you...[shakes head and walks away from computer].

Sillybilly

Original Poster:

231 posts

221 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
escargot said:
Sillybilly said:
If this scenario is explored more who knows what one may discover?
To be honest, I suspect the best place to brainstorm this would be your friendly local paedophile ring. They'd probably be more receptive to the idea.
That was another disadvantage I thought of, but then I figured this would have no impact one way or the other on paedos given they seem to molest their own family the most so the daughter not being related shouldn't make any difference.

DrTre

12,957 posts

263 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Sillybilly said:
Suppose baby girls were sold to the highest single male bidder,
While I want no part in your venture you should grab www.ebaby.com now while you can....

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Seriously, WTFF? What a completely fked up thread/idea.

Sillybilly

Original Poster:

231 posts

221 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Seriously, WTFF? What a completely fked up thread/idea.
I don't understand why everyone's saying it's fked up.

That's obvious

The thing that interests me is what the consequences will be. Because if you can think them through then you can sometimes come up with good ideas for non fked up schemes.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Sillybilly said:
This is not a position that I am advocating but I thought it might be interesting to examine how society would be different so any sensible comments would be appreciated.

Suppose baby girls were sold to the highest single male bidder, just after their birth, who would then raise them as their child until they reached around 18, at which point they would have an option (and it would be the usual thing to do) to marry each other. Obviously then the couple have children, selling the girls and raising the boys.

Here are a few advantages:

  • Marriages likely to be very stable and genuine love felt between participants
  • Stability about people's lives
  • Babies most likely to turn out well go to highest bidders - thus society's elite will concentrate but at the same time there ought to be greater genetic mixing; for example poorer parts of the country will have more babies to sell to the richer parts - this will also aid wealth distribution
  • Men will be older when married and thus better equipped to provide for a larger family
  • Paternity leave at the same scale as maternity leave thus helping gender equality

A few disadvantages:

  • Fathers/Husbands-to-be not looking after their daughter/wife-to-be as well as they should as she is not genetically related
  • Potentially social pressure on wommen to get married against their wishes
  • Maybe close to incest
total nonce sense