Coal Power, nuclear power, and Quentin Willson!
Discussion
Well not sure if this has come up before, though I wouldnt be supprised if it had been mentioned..
Right...
Quentin Willson reported that
75% of Co2 is produced by Coal Power Stations http://uk.cars.yahoo.com/06112007/62/quentin-wilso... ,
So why on earth would the UK consider opening a new one? albeit, closing an old one down and opening a 'supposed' cleaner version..."E.ON says it would demolish an existing power station at the Kingsnorth site and replace it with one that is 20% cleaner." Erm wont it be more expensive to make the coal burn cleaner??? I do hope that a certain government is NOT helping to fund this venture in any way... Surely the cost of this would be put straight back onto the consumer... and no doubt it would be made all better by suggesting to us its a 'green' price rise...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/7169105.stm
And what are the issues about replacing it with a Nuclear power station? safety, disposal??? its true that nuclear waste is one of the hardest to get rid of, but not impossible. And Im almost certain that the benifits completely out way the negatives. France has THE cleanest air in all of the European industrious countries, it has the cheapest electricity in Europe (im not certain as to whether or not our French counterparts have a subsidised/nationalised electricity industry, which makes their bills cheaper). The French also re use their Nuclear waste to make the end waste smaller so the problem of storing and disposing the waste as minimal as possible... Im generally not a Fan of the French (due to British Steroetypes
) but they seem to have this Nuclear lark off to a tee!!!
Another problem Im guessing is the safety of it all.. Nuclear has got a very low accident record and only 2 major incidents of core meltdown. Chernobyl was the worst, with a complete core meltdown, which resulted in many many lives lost imediatly and many lives ireversably effected even today... The other was Three Mile Island which was a partial core meltdown which was contained and is understood that no civilians were affected.
However in the Coal industry, several thousand workers die in the mines throughout the world every year which just is not comparable to small amount of Nuclear disasters...
The Economist in June 2008 stated that "nuclear reactors are the one proven way to make carbon-dioxide-free electricity in large and reliable quantities that does not depend (as hydroelectric and geothermal energy do) on the luck of the geographical draw.
I guess my rant is WHY oh WHY is the government not taxing these power companies for seriously pollouting the environment. It shows absaloute hypocracy, and defines why there is no respect left for the Labour party and its non leading leader...
The Government takes £44 billion off the motorist every single year, only 5% goes on roads (im happy to be proven worng on this(im assuming the rest goes towards second homes and paying family members for redecorating them curtosy of the John Lewis list.) Why cant a generous slice of this money go towards funding something sensible like helping to subsidise the expensive cost of building Nuclear power plants, or at least go towards research and development of hydrogen cars ( i guess the problem is that there are not too many UK owned car manufacturers anymore)
Id love to hear your comments on this!
Right...
Quentin Willson reported that
75% of Co2 is produced by Coal Power Stations http://uk.cars.yahoo.com/06112007/62/quentin-wilso... ,
So why on earth would the UK consider opening a new one? albeit, closing an old one down and opening a 'supposed' cleaner version..."E.ON says it would demolish an existing power station at the Kingsnorth site and replace it with one that is 20% cleaner." Erm wont it be more expensive to make the coal burn cleaner??? I do hope that a certain government is NOT helping to fund this venture in any way... Surely the cost of this would be put straight back onto the consumer... and no doubt it would be made all better by suggesting to us its a 'green' price rise...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/7169105.stm
And what are the issues about replacing it with a Nuclear power station? safety, disposal??? its true that nuclear waste is one of the hardest to get rid of, but not impossible. And Im almost certain that the benifits completely out way the negatives. France has THE cleanest air in all of the European industrious countries, it has the cheapest electricity in Europe (im not certain as to whether or not our French counterparts have a subsidised/nationalised electricity industry, which makes their bills cheaper). The French also re use their Nuclear waste to make the end waste smaller so the problem of storing and disposing the waste as minimal as possible... Im generally not a Fan of the French (due to British Steroetypes
) but they seem to have this Nuclear lark off to a tee!!! Another problem Im guessing is the safety of it all.. Nuclear has got a very low accident record and only 2 major incidents of core meltdown. Chernobyl was the worst, with a complete core meltdown, which resulted in many many lives lost imediatly and many lives ireversably effected even today... The other was Three Mile Island which was a partial core meltdown which was contained and is understood that no civilians were affected.
However in the Coal industry, several thousand workers die in the mines throughout the world every year which just is not comparable to small amount of Nuclear disasters...
The Economist in June 2008 stated that "nuclear reactors are the one proven way to make carbon-dioxide-free electricity in large and reliable quantities that does not depend (as hydroelectric and geothermal energy do) on the luck of the geographical draw.
I guess my rant is WHY oh WHY is the government not taxing these power companies for seriously pollouting the environment. It shows absaloute hypocracy, and defines why there is no respect left for the Labour party and its non leading leader...
The Government takes £44 billion off the motorist every single year, only 5% goes on roads (im happy to be proven worng on this(im assuming the rest goes towards second homes and paying family members for redecorating them curtosy of the John Lewis list.) Why cant a generous slice of this money go towards funding something sensible like helping to subsidise the expensive cost of building Nuclear power plants, or at least go towards research and development of hydrogen cars ( i guess the problem is that there are not too many UK owned car manufacturers anymore)
Id love to hear your comments on this!
The Ben said:
The Government takes £44 billion off the motorist every single year, only 5% goes on roads (im happy to be proven worng on this(im assuming the rest goes towards second homes and paying family members for redecorating them curtosy of the John Lewis list.)
I think they should spend it on adult literacy myself.unrepentant said:
The Ben said:
The Government takes £44 billion off the motorist every single year, only 5% goes on roads (im happy to be proven worng on this(im assuming the rest goes towards second homes and paying family members for redecorating them curtosy of the John Lewis list.)
I think they should spend it on adult literacy myself.
If it's 20% cleaner it will be producing 20% less power, wont it? After all, by far the largest emission from getting energy out of coal is CO2, no matter how it is processed! All they can do to make it burn cleaner is reduce the emmissions of incomplete combustion, carbonmonoxide, nitrousoxides, etc.
As far as nuclear power and it's risks are concerned. Both meltdown incidents, and especialy Chernobyl, were caused in very large part by very bad management of the reactors and outdated equipement that was unsuitable for the job.
As far as nuclear power and it's risks are concerned. Both meltdown incidents, and especialy Chernobyl, were caused in very large part by very bad management of the reactors and outdated equipement that was unsuitable for the job.
Well since good old Quentin is a motoring Journo, it's reasonable to assume he's not as hot at at heavy civil/industrial engineering, as he is at palming off "old smokers" on an unsuspecting public. In truth, without any word of a lie, and to be blatently obvious, it's not reasonable to trust his words on this subject.
Irrespective there are some details that you might want to consider.
CO2 is, in fact, not nearly as toxic as say radioactive polonium. It may not have any kind of effect on the environment. Either way, coal stocks are not infinite, and I think coal is a resource to be used rationally to provide for us, and our children.
Nuclear cannot provide all our energy needs. Coal is much more "turn on and offable". Nuclear reactor lifetimes are dramatically reduced if they are required to cycle. Given the highly toxic innards of a nuclear reactor, you really want to make them last as long as they can before they have to be dismantled, and coal can help to achieve this.
Cement manufacture is by far the greatest single producer of CO2, perhaps second only to breathing or cooking dinner.
Irrespective there are some details that you might want to consider.
CO2 is, in fact, not nearly as toxic as say radioactive polonium. It may not have any kind of effect on the environment. Either way, coal stocks are not infinite, and I think coal is a resource to be used rationally to provide for us, and our children.
Nuclear cannot provide all our energy needs. Coal is much more "turn on and offable". Nuclear reactor lifetimes are dramatically reduced if they are required to cycle. Given the highly toxic innards of a nuclear reactor, you really want to make them last as long as they can before they have to be dismantled, and coal can help to achieve this.
Cement manufacture is by far the greatest single producer of CO2, perhaps second only to breathing or cooking dinner.
Edited by dilbert on Sunday 20th July 16:14
Ravell said:
If it's 20% cleaner it will be producing 20% less power, wont it? After all, by far the largest emission from getting energy out of coal is CO2, no matter how it is processed! All they can do to make it burn cleaner is reduce the emmissions of incomplete combustion, carbonmonoxide, nitrousoxides, etc.
You have fallen into the trap of thinking that cleaner means less CO2CO2 is not a form of pollution never has been, never will be. But today when they say 20% less emissions we don't have a clue if they are talking about plant food or the real nastiness like NOXs and SOXs. So 20% drop could mean anything
CO2 is mostly a form of taxation but more useful is the fact it is a measurement of hydrocarbon consumption.
So while hugely grating the current obsession with CO2 and global warming it does actually serve what i consider to be a useful purpose as it is forcing us to look at our oil consumption.
Lower our oil consumption and we reduce our reliance on the middle east, extend the lifespan of our reserves, reduce the cost of oil and hopefully we can have a more efficient society as the wastage that we current have is terrible.
thinfourth2 said:
Lower our oil consumption and we reduce our reliance on the middle east, extend the lifespan of our reserves, reduce the cost of oil and hopefully we can have a more efficient society as the wastage that we current have is terrible.
Do you then think this is a subtle, or maybe not so subtle way of reducing our relience on the middle east so they have not got us my the short and curlys as the Russians would like the world to have with them!!! Possibly a way of standing on our own two feet as it were.The Ben said:
thinfourth2 said:
Lower our oil consumption and we reduce our reliance on the middle east, extend the lifespan of our reserves, reduce the cost of oil and hopefully we can have a more efficient society as the wastage that we current have is terrible.
Do you then think this is a subtle, or maybe not so subtle way of reducing our relience on the middle east so they have not got us my the short and curlys as the Russians would like the world to have with them!!! Possibly a way of standing on our own two feet as it were.
ks there is the noble idea of trying to reduce our oil consumption.Sadly i feel a greater driving force is the desire for control and taxation by short sighted people who have no place in running the country
I've been round a Chernobyl type (RBMK) reactor with work. Twas interesting. The highlight of my visit though was the very very attractive russian army girl with the ak47. In the UK we get fat policeman, in the old Eastern bloc countries they get foxy soldiers. If the UK adopted this practice, then I'm sure we'd have more support for nuclear.
"Nuclear Power - We may have no idea what we're going to do with the waste, but we're guarded by hot chicks with guns"
"Nuclear Power - We may have no idea what we're going to do with the waste, but we're guarded by hot chicks with guns"
Ravell said:
If it's 20% cleaner it will be producing 20% less power, wont it? After all, by far the largest emission from getting energy out of coal is CO2, no matter how it is processed! All they can do to make it burn cleaner is reduce the emmissions of incomplete combustion, carbonmonoxide, nitrousoxides, etc.
This 20% is mis-used. It's a 20% improvement in efficiency due to higher temperature and pressure. This sounds good but actually it's 20% of 30% which means the fuel and emissions saving is only 6%. It should be rejected because we need a 70% saving, not 6%.Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


