Banking penalty charges the new game?
Banking penalty charges the new game?
Author
Discussion

jimmyb

Original Poster:

12,254 posts

247 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
Right everyone has been banging on about how terrible penatly charges are and banks are being investigated with a view to reducing them.

Well barclays have just changed the game. I have recieved a new letter from the bank telling me that i can opt in or out of a new system as of 1/8 whereby i will have an extended emergency overdraft over and above my normal overdraft limit which if i use i will be charged £22 per 5 day period.

Brilliant.

Nickyboy

6,826 posts

265 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
Cheaper to go over unauthorised as they only charge £30 per day and can only charge 3 times in a month

jimmyb

Original Poster:

12,254 posts

247 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
Nickyboy said:
Cheaper to go over unauthorised as they only charge £30 per day and can only charge 3 times in a month
If i understand it they are scrapping that.

Vipers

33,525 posts

259 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
On the topic of banks, how irresponsible is this.

My wife, bless her was 62 yesterday, doesn't work, and receives a state pension.

She has no savings of her own, I take care of that, but she has just been given a credit card with a limit of £9000 by Lloyds bank.

She made it clear to the nice man on the phone from Lloyds she didnt work, didnt have any savings, but he insisted in offering her a card.

Now me, I work, luckly in these taxing times have a good job, and a reasonable income, (I am with the same bank I might add), and my current limit is a damm sight less than her's...............

frown

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
Vipers said:
On the topic of banks, how irresponsible is this.

My wife, bless her was 62 yesterday, doesn't work, and receives a state pension.

She has no savings of her own, I take care of that, but she has just been given a credit card with a limit of £9000 by Lloyds bank.

She made it clear to the nice man on the phone from Lloyds she didnt work, didnt have any savings, but he insisted in offering her a card.

Now me, I work, luckly in these taxing times have a good job, and a reasonable income, (I am with the same bank I might add), and my current limit is a damm sight less than her's...............

frown
I feel your pain. The bank are wholly responsible for the credit mess by offering ridiculously large credit limits and actively encouraging over spending, then they pull your eyebrows out when you have problems paying it back rolleyes

Vipers

33,525 posts

259 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Sorry, but dont agree with your thoughts, the banks should be more responsible, they obviously know it is easy to go into debt, they must know the consequences, we are all week to an extent, unless you can tell me why on earth the bank should offer a pensioner, with no income, a credit card with a £9000 limit on?, because I can't.

smile

A8VIP

10,862 posts

227 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
Nickyboy said:
Cheaper to go over unauthorised as they only charge £30 per day and can only charge 3 times in a month
There is no such thing as 'unauthorised' overdrawn anymore.

The Banks are replacing it with an 'emergency extended overdraft' to cover it, which they will automatically put in place if you go overdrawn.

Lloyds currently charge £16 per day for this 'service', up to 5 days per month

Sillybilly

231 posts

221 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
Can't we all get along and agree they're both at fault? The customers are complete fkwits with no foresight or financial nous at all and the banks are vultures preying upon and encouraging the crazy sense of entitlement belonging to these creatures.
Or put another way... Who were worse, the guys who designed the crematoria at Auschwitz or the guys who ordered them?

stemll

5,660 posts

231 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
A8VIP said:
Nickyboy said:
Cheaper to go over unauthorised as they only charge £30 per day and can only charge 3 times in a month
There is no such thing as 'unauthorised' overdrawn anymore.

The Banks are replacing it with an 'emergency extended overdraft' to cover it, which they will automatically put in place if you go overdrawn.

Lloyds currently charge £16 per day for this 'service', up to 5 days per month
If you don't spend money you don't have then this 'service' (as you call it) is free. Offering you unsecured and unagreed credit is a service. It is not a right you all have, they could by all rights just refuse the debit card or bounce the cheque.

I agree 100% with Tonker in this thread. Just because someone is prepared to lend you money does not mean you have to spend it.

Bear this in mind too. If the banks 'lose' the case on overdraft charges then rather than allowing you to go overdrawn without asking, they will simply revert to refusing payments if you don't have the money in your account. That will be somewhat embarassing in the checkout queue at Asda won't it.

Edited by stemll on Monday 21st July 00:01

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
Vipers said:
On the topic of banks, how irresponsible is this.

My wife, bless her was 62 yesterday, doesn't work, and receives a state pension.

She has no savings of her own, I take care of that, but she has just been given a credit card with a limit of £9000 by Lloyds bank.

She made it clear to the nice man on the phone from Lloyds she didnt work, didnt have any savings, but he insisted in offering her a card.

Now me, I work, luckly in these taxing times have a good job, and a reasonable income, (I am with the same bank I might add), and my current limit is a damm sight less than her's...............

frown
My wife was given one by Mint: student, non worker, non British citizen, no previous credit history, had only lived in the UK a year, and they gave her a card with £3200 limit.

The nice man on the phone then sold her loss-of-income protection insurance, assured her she HAD to have it, even though she didn't have a job to lose. I eventually took care of that, with a short sharp phone call.

But of course, it is up to her to make a decision as to what card she has, so no responsibility rests with the bank, none at all.....

scratchchin



jimmyb

Original Poster:

12,254 posts

247 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Tonker if you were to lend money to someone who on the face of it didnt really have the means to pay it back who would be the more foolish the the lender (who stands to lose cold hard cash) or the borrower (who potentially doesnt stand to lose much at all)?

The present credit problems worldwide are due to banks being overambitious/greedy. Yes the borrowers are idiots for borrowing money they probably/definitely cant afford but the banks are the bigger idiots for lending it to them in the vein hope they will make that little bit more money off the borrower. In the US and Uk etc its now come back and bitten the banks in the arse as living costs have rocketed meaning hundreds of thousands of people are struggling to pay their debts meaning banks are having to write off billions all for the sake of a few quid more.

Emeye

9,781 posts

254 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Just because you buy a gun doesn't mean you have to go and shoot someone.

Who is to blame, the gun maker of the person that pulls the trigger?

Well, they never put the gun maker in the dock do they?

I have no sympathy for anyone who now finds them self in trouble because they were greedy during the boom.

Pigeon

18,535 posts

277 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Surely by any assessment it is at the least bloody silly that the same bank offer such generous facilities to Mrs Vipers who does not have the means to repay it, but refuse them to Vipers who does.
stemll said:
If the banks 'lose' the case on overdraft charges then rather than allowing you to go overdrawn without asking, they will simply revert to refusing payments if you don't have the money in your account.
THAT'S WHAT I WANT THEM TO DO. If the money isn't in it doesn't come out. I don't want them to make it appear anyway and then find some weaselly way of charging me a fortune for a service I don't want but can't refuse, any more than I want them to have some weaselly way of charging me a fortune after refusing the payment for having no money in the first place. I just want a straightforward payments are made if the money's there without any charges and if the money's not there payments are refused without any charges thing.

Swilly

9,699 posts

305 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Natwest have a scheme whereby they write to you informing you that, if you should go over your limit, you are impliedly requesting an overdraft which they will provide at a charge of £xx.

dreamer75

1,462 posts

259 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
jimmyb said:
Right everyone has been banging on about how terrible penatly charges are and banks are being investigated with a view to reducing them.

Well barclays have just changed the game. I have recieved a new letter from the bank telling me that i can opt in or out of a new system as of 1/8 whereby i will have an extended emergency overdraft over and above my normal overdraft limit which if i use i will be charged £22 per 5 day period.

Brilliant.
I just got that letter too - I keep meaning to phone them up and ask them what the charges are if I opt out of the system. I would prefer it just didn't give me any money if I go over my overdraft limit !!!

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
fine, the problem is that for people outside of the PH higher tax no mortgage brigade there are a lot of people who are one delayed wage payment or unexpected bill away from hitting their overdraft limit.

stemll

5,660 posts

231 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Pigeon said:
Surely by any assessment it is at the least bloody silly that the same bank offer such generous facilities to Mrs Vipers who does not have the means to repay it, but refuse them to Vipers who does.
Credit scoring is dumb and has all sorts of holes. You will also get this while banks pay comission on sales. If you knew how much banks pay branch and sales staff, you'd understand why they chase comission. Again though, just because it's offered doesn't mean you have to take it.

Pigeon said:
THAT'S WHAT I WANT THEM TO DO. If the money isn't in it doesn't come out. I don't want them to make it appear anyway and then find some weaselly way of charging me a fortune for a service I don't want but can't refuse, any more than I want them to have some weaselly way of charging me a fortune after refusing the payment for having no money in the first place. I just want a straightforward payments are made if the money's there without any charges and if the money's not there payments are refused without any charges thing.
So you want the bank to process your payment request, find you have no money and refuse the payment, and you want all this for free? Maybe if you knew how much you had you wouldn't need this free service.

Never going to happen. Not only will they start refusing payments, they will also dump free banking and everyone will pay a monthly charge to have a bank account. Again, everyone pays for the actions of the few. In this case, cretins who take the borrowed money they're offered and get all upset when someone asks for it back.

Swilly said:
Natwest have a scheme whereby they write to you informing you that, if you should go over your limit, you are impliedly requesting an overdraft which they will provide at a charge of £xx.
Which is exactly what you are doing.

Engineer1 said:
fine, the problem is that for people outside of the PH higher tax no mortgage brigade there are a lot of people who are one delayed wage payment or unexpected bill away from hitting their overdraft limit.
I have a >£100k mortgage and two kids in nursery costing me nearly £1400/month but I have never paid a bank fee for an overdraft.

It's called "living within your means".

Pigeon

18,535 posts

277 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Exactly, and when that happens I just want the bank to refuse the payment with no fuss and I'll pay it when I've got the money. I do not want them to make me pay through the nose for giving me a loan I don't want and I do not want them to make me pay through the nose for not giving me one.

jimmyb

Original Poster:

12,254 posts

247 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
stemll said:
Pigeon said:
Surely by any assessment it is at the least bloody silly that the same bank offer such generous facilities to Mrs Vipers who does not have the means to repay it, but refuse them to Vipers who does.
Credit scoring is dumb and has all sorts of holes. You will also get this while banks pay comission on sales. If you knew how much banks pay branch and sales staff, you'd understand why they chase comission. Again though, just because it's offered doesn't mean you have to take it.

Pigeon said:
THAT'S WHAT I WANT THEM TO DO. If the money isn't in it doesn't come out. I don't want them to make it appear anyway and then find some weaselly way of charging me a fortune for a service I don't want but can't refuse, any more than I want them to have some weaselly way of charging me a fortune after refusing the payment for having no money in the first place. I just want a straightforward payments are made if the money's there without any charges and if the money's not there payments are refused without any charges thing.
So you want the bank to process your payment request, find you have no money and refuse the payment, and you want all this for free? Maybe if you knew how much you had you wouldn't need this free service.

Never going to happen. Not only will they start refusing payments, they will also dump free banking and everyone will pay a monthly charge to have a bank account. Again, everyone pays for the actions of the few. In this case, cretins who take the borrowed money they're offered and get all upset when someone asks for it back.

Swilly said:
Natwest have a scheme whereby they write to you informing you that, if you should go over your limit, you are impliedly requesting an overdraft which they will provide at a charge of £xx.
Which is exactly what you are doing.

Engineer1 said:
fine, the problem is that for people outside of the PH higher tax no mortgage brigade there are a lot of people who are one delayed wage payment or unexpected bill away from hitting their overdraft limit.
I have a >£100k mortgage and two kids in nursery costing me nearly £1400/month but I have never paid a bank fee for an overdraft.

It's called "living within your means".
Swilli you and all those that post supporting the banks actions seem to completely miss the point. AN overdraft facility is generally an emergency facility in case you dont have enough funds every now and then and it has a limit. Now to me a limit is a dead end when you get there there is nowhere to go no funds available.However with banks a limit is not actually a limit its merely an advisory or imaginary point which if you go over they hammer you for.
Allowing someone to go ovedrawn over their overdraft just seems silly.

Its also very much about making money for the bank if it wasnt they would make it an optional facility yet my bank told me i would need to jump through various hoops and fight a lion before they would literally cap my overdraft so i couldnt go over.

As to your do you know how much they have to pay staff etc?. Nope and wouldnt mind paying for an account so long as i got provided with a decent honest service that i want rather than am forced to have.

zac510

5,546 posts

237 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
This is OT, but I am slightly worried about what might happen if they decide to introduce fees for Debit cards. We are moving heavily towards a cashless society and in some shops, train stations, car parking, you can hardly get anywhere without cash.
So we're almost ripe for them to go and introduce a 20p charge for transactions and before we know it we'll be forking out £100+ a year in fees.


Also - OT - is it true about the parking on Top Gear last night - that there was no option for cash payment in both of those circumstances?