Work For The Dole/Benefits
Discussion
Shurely shome mishtake?
The government have announced their intention to force those capable of doing so to carry out some form of work if they wish to continue to receive handouts. Anyone with a drug 'problem' will be expected to undergo therapy. The Conservatives back the scheme with the only voices of dissent coming from the Labour back benches.
Will it go through or will Labour bottle it and back down? Alternatively will they introduce a flawed and toothless system that changes nothing?
The government have announced their intention to force those capable of doing so to carry out some form of work if they wish to continue to receive handouts. Anyone with a drug 'problem' will be expected to undergo therapy. The Conservatives back the scheme with the only voices of dissent coming from the Labour back benches.
Will it go through or will Labour bottle it and back down? Alternatively will they introduce a flawed and toothless system that changes nothing?
I think this is a great idea at first glance but the only way it can possibly work is if we are prepared to let some people starve to death.
Or another more interesting objection: suppose the only jobs avaliable are prostitute or labour party canvassar.
I'm not a great fan of this idea when taken to its logical extreme - and if you can't take an idea to its extreme it's s
t.
Or another more interesting objection: suppose the only jobs avaliable are prostitute or labour party canvassar.
I'm not a great fan of this idea when taken to its logical extreme - and if you can't take an idea to its extreme it's s
t.I dont see anytihng wrong with the able, working... I also dont mind my anti socialist attitudes being slightly misguided/or manipulated by creating government jobs. And im not talking non-sensual jobs being made up for the sake of it and im not refering to any jobs inparticular, ahem.... However, Jobs that would improve and contribute to the economy or state should be then implimented. I dont see a problem with the Armed forces. If they dont want to be enlisted, then they should get a job that they apply for!!!
This isnt a rant about 'chuck them in armed forces if they dont work'.. This is there is a choice for all those inbred dole dossing layabout who say there are not any jobs out there. They either get a job they do want/realistically could get, or they have to join the armed forces (preferably front line + cannon fodder)
I bet you any amount of money that there will be a 'sudden' amount of job applications for the non existant jobs.
And instead of the gov giving these bums money every week, they could pay the employer to train them in new skills.... Not such a far fetched idea is it!!! Would this upset the little pram pushing work shy bums....
This isnt a rant about 'chuck them in armed forces if they dont work'.. This is there is a choice for all those inbred dole dossing layabout who say there are not any jobs out there. They either get a job they do want/realistically could get, or they have to join the armed forces (preferably front line + cannon fodder)
I bet you any amount of money that there will be a 'sudden' amount of job applications for the non existant jobs.
And instead of the gov giving these bums money every week, they could pay the employer to train them in new skills.... Not such a far fetched idea is it!!! Would this upset the little pram pushing work shy bums....
Fittster said:
Sillybilly said:
I think this is a great idea at first glance but the only way it can possibly work is if we are prepared to let some people starve to death.
.
You really think that people in the UK would starve if there were no dole?.
tty individual. That's why I oppose the welfare state.But if one agrees with the idea of a welfare state then one has to start with giving welfare to the worst.
Same reason you defend freedom of expression with child pornographers and neo nazis and defend human rights starting with those of serial killers and terrorists.
Although there's a very convincing case that ninety nine percent of people don't agree with rights at all and the almost universal British political position is a communitarian one.
If a job available then no dole..........
Harsh....
I pay 40% in direct tax
17.5% VAT on most purchases
more on fuel, new car tax etc.....
It works out that something like 60% of my pay goes back to the government.
Then when you consider the DSS budget is greater than the NHS.
For F sake get people to do something for the money.
No effort no cash
If you can afford fags and beer, to much cash.
For luxuries......work.
Harsh....
I pay 40% in direct tax
17.5% VAT on most purchases
more on fuel, new car tax etc.....
It works out that something like 60% of my pay goes back to the government.
Then when you consider the DSS budget is greater than the NHS.
For F sake get people to do something for the money.
No effort no cash
If you can afford fags and beer, to much cash.
For luxuries......work.
There are also moves afoot to put people 'on the dole' into training courses at local colleges, plans that the number of adults in 'adult education' will double from 500,000.
As per the Times Ed of a few weeks ago.
Not like in the 1920s and 1930s where there were 'labour exchanges' and the unemployed, for example, worked on civic schemes like building dams and sewers for the greater good. What goes around comes around *cough* ?
As per the Times Ed of a few weeks ago.
Not like in the 1920s and 1930s where there were 'labour exchanges' and the unemployed, for example, worked on civic schemes like building dams and sewers for the greater good. What goes around comes around *cough* ?
Whether it will work or not is debatable, but I think it's definately good in theory.
My initial thought was "Feel sorry for the regular joes who've been made redundant or are actually job hunting" (Folk like me, who have claimed in the past)
But reading on to see it's applicable to only 1+ year claimants, it seems good. I imagine people like myself (Probably sadly in the minority) only fall back on JSA when we need to.
The only problem is, a lot of JSA claiments are long-term as a result of their "in-ability to work", so how will they end up clearing litter? Or will they just get let off the hook again due to T&C loopholes?
Eitherway, I think it's a great scheme to have long-term unemployed people working for the good of the community. I know my local area could do with a bit of a cleanup!
My initial thought was "Feel sorry for the regular joes who've been made redundant or are actually job hunting" (Folk like me, who have claimed in the past)
But reading on to see it's applicable to only 1+ year claimants, it seems good. I imagine people like myself (Probably sadly in the minority) only fall back on JSA when we need to.
The only problem is, a lot of JSA claiments are long-term as a result of their "in-ability to work", so how will they end up clearing litter? Or will they just get let off the hook again due to T&C loopholes?
Eitherway, I think it's a great scheme to have long-term unemployed people working for the good of the community. I know my local area could do with a bit of a cleanup!
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



from the house. 

