Hi viz Jackets. A waste of time?
Hi viz Jackets. A waste of time?
Author
Discussion

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Am i alone in thinking that all these hi-viz jackets are a complete waste of time?

Human beings are programmed to spot other human beings, and to watch out for other people when we are doing something that could put others in danger. Does being able to see a person one mile away, make any difference to your driving or would it be just as safe if you could see them from 300 yards away in normal clothing?

I had to go into a warehouse recently and everyone has to wear hi viz, even the fork lift drivers scratchchin

The only time you will get hit by a forklift truck in a warehouse is if the driver is looking the other way to the direction he is going, and so are you. No amount of Hi - Viz will help if you are not looking where you are going.

Has anyone here ever come close to running someone over and thought to themselves "Put a high -Viz jacket on FFS!"

Is it just me??






carrotchomper

18,334 posts

235 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Yeah, but, it's Elf an Safety, innit?

G C

491 posts

227 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
I think it makes sense on motorways at night / when its dark etc, as it reflects light doesnt it, and at the speed your going at..

I don't really see the point in warehouses etc, but building sites should be a yes, cause if the building collapses or similar, it would be easier to see a bit of bright yellow / reflectant amungst all the rubble!

Police Officers / PCSO's also a yes cause then its more of a visable presence smile

Theres my 10 pence..

beer

Edited by G C on Monday 21st July 11:45

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Our brains are wired to pick up on things that stand out.
One high-viz vest in a warehouse will be spotted by everyone all the time.
One in a sea of other high-viz vests will just blend in.

It's like the argument about DRLs and motorbikes etc. Yes, DRLs make you stand out but as soon as they become mandatory for everyone they won't...

Tony*T3

20,911 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Depends on circumstanc I suppose. On a motorway at 90mph a Hi Viz could save lives.

In a storeroom as mentioned above, very unlikely.

Wigeon Incognito

3,274 posts

249 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
I'm definitely not with you on this one. High vis makes sense.

Think of cyclists in the dark, I'll bet there have been plenty of times you would have seen one a lot sooner if they were wearing high vis.

Having worked in construction environments, I'd say if you're using machinery and concentrating on the task in hand then you won't necessarily spot someone lurking nearby. High vis can make the all important difference, it catches your eye.

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
A lot of fork lift trucks now have personel warning devices fitted which can sense human presence using IR and bleep accordingly.

I'm in favour of High Vis jackets as they cut down on the paperwork as there are less "Sorry mate didnt see you" accidents.

Heskey

4,048 posts

224 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
I see bikers easier with hi vis on that without, when they're trying to be cool on their black bikes in their black gear with a black helmet, when the clouds above and the shadows below are black as well.

I wore a hi vis vest when I had my bike.

speedy_thrills

7,979 posts

274 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Comming to British soldiers fighting in Iraq soon... (Are we calling it a war still? I think we technically recinded our declaration of war but it's actually a propper warzone now...confusing!)

Perhaps in future it will be Electroluminescent wire, LEDs and hardhats with flashing lights attached rather than just reflective materials.

Edited by speedy_thrills on Monday 21st July 11:52

crofty1984

17,064 posts

235 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Various health and safety laws, I see your point. I was once asked if a digital camera I had on site was "intrinsically safe"!

But I do think Hi-viz is a good thing. It hardly interrupts your working day to sling a vest on, and there's a lot of activity about on site, so it can be very distracting. Your eye actually responds more to movement that the human form, do you might get distracted by a crane off to your left, then not notice a stationary person. In Italy, when people break down on the hard shoulder they have a hi-vis vest in the toolkit and put it on. You can REALLY tell the difference.

Aubrey

1,157 posts

227 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
I remember seeing something on tv a while ago about safety on railways, it was just after a big crash. They showed footage from inside a train going along of workers on a track. The ones without any high-vis could hardly be seen at all, even when close, the workers with high-vis were clearly visible. IMHO yes we need high-vis.

Dark condition, person in dark clothing you won't see them, put a high-vis bib you will.

Surely that's the point of high-vis, to increase visibility??

Edited by Aubrey on Monday 21st July 11:51

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
G C said:
I think it makes sense on motorways at night / when its dark etc, as it reflects light doesnt it, and at the speed your going at..

I don't really see the point in warehouses etc, but building sites should be a yes, cause if the building collapses or similar, it would be easier to see a bit of bright yellow / reflectant amungst all the rubble!

Police Officers / PCSO's also a yes cause then its more of a visable presence smile

Theres my 10 pence..

beer

Edited by G C on Monday 21st July 11:45
RE: the building collapsing scenario. Shouldn't we all wear them indoors then, just incase?

As far as coppers go, i agree that at night they are a good thing, but why do they need to be a more visible presence when walking down the street? A police hat was always easy to spot!


crofty1984

17,064 posts

235 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Hedders said:
G C said:
I think it makes sense on motorways at night / when its dark etc, as it reflects light doesnt it, and at the speed your going at..

I don't really see the point in warehouses etc, but building sites should be a yes, cause if the building collapses or similar, it would be easier to see a bit of bright yellow / reflectant amungst all the rubble!

Police Officers / PCSO's also a yes cause then its more of a visable presence smile

Theres my 10 pence..

beer

Edited by G C on Monday 21st July 11:45
RE: the building collapsing scenario. Shouldn't we all wear them indoors then, just incase?

As far as coppers go, i agree that at night they are a good thing, but why do they need to be a more visible presence when walking down the street? A police hat was always easy to spot!
Because it looks like a boobie!!!

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Aubrey said:
I remember seeing something on tv a while ago about safety on railways, it was just after a big crash. They showed footage from inside a train going along of workers on a track. The ones without any high-vis could hardly be seen at all, even when close, the workers with high-vis were clearly visible. IMHO yes we need high-viz.
In this scenario, the train can not avoid you not matter how far in advance it can see you. Hi-viz jackets on train tracks must be so that the workers can see each other?


G C

491 posts

227 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Hedders said:
G C said:
I think it makes sense on motorways at night / when its dark etc, as it reflects light doesnt it, and at the speed your going at..

I don't really see the point in warehouses etc, but building sites should be a yes, cause if the building collapses or similar, it would be easier to see a bit of bright yellow / reflectant amungst all the rubble!

Police Officers / PCSO's also a yes cause then its more of a visable presence smile

Theres my 10 pence..

beer

Edited by G C on Monday 21st July 11:45
RE: the building collapsing scenario. Shouldn't we all wear them indoors then, just incase?

As far as coppers go, i agree that at night they are a good thing, but why do they need to be a more visible presence when walking down the street? A police hat was always easy to spot!
Think about the vertically challenged people! And if there are people in the way you might see the high vis between them?

Im pretty sure buildings are more unsafe when being built, then they are when they are finished??

But point taken smile

ETA but im not an engineer / builder!

Edited by G C on Monday 21st July 11:53

Hyperion

16,952 posts

231 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
I wear a Hi-Viz on my Motorbike in winter...they make you stand out much better.

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
G C said:
Hedders said:
G C said:
I think it makes sense on motorways at night / when its dark etc, as it reflects light doesnt it, and at the speed your going at..

I don't really see the point in warehouses etc, but building sites should be a yes, cause if the building collapses or similar, it would be easier to see a bit of bright yellow / reflectant amungst all the rubble!

Police Officers / PCSO's also a yes cause then its more of a visable presence smile

Theres my 10 pence..

beer

Edited by G C on Monday 21st July 11:45
RE: the building collapsing scenario. Shouldn't we all wear them indoors then, just incase?

As far as coppers go, i agree that at night they are a good thing, but why do they need to be a more visible presence when walking down the street? A police hat was always easy to spot!
Think about the vertically challenged people! And if there are people in the way you might see the high vis between them?

Im pretty sure buildings are more unsafe when being built, then they are when they are finished??

But point taken smile

ETA but im not an engineer / builder!
I forgot about short arsed coppers, back in my day they stood out, especially with the tit on their head.




rlw

3,590 posts

268 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
I watched a brilliant piece on French breakfast time TV saying that hi-viz jackets must be carried in the car after July 1st so that you can put one on without getting out. And why was this? So that when you walk fifty metres down the motorway to put out your warning triangle - also compulsory - you will reduce the very high risk of your being killed. Me, I would just get out of the car and sit behind the barrier.....

Swilly

9,699 posts

305 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Hedders said:
Am i alone in thinking that all these hi-viz jackets are a complete waste of time?

Human beings are programmed to spot other human beings, and to watch out for other people when we are doing something that could put others in danger. Does being able to see a person one mile away, make any difference to your driving or would it be just as safe if you could see them from 300 yards away in normal clothing?

I had to go into a warehouse recently and everyone has to wear hi viz, even the fork lift drivers scratchchin

The only time you will get hit by a forklift truck in a warehouse is if the driver is looking the other way to the direction he is going, and so are you. No amount of Hi - Viz will help if you are not looking where you are going.

Has anyone here ever come close to running someone over and thought to themselves "Put a high -Viz jacket on FFS!"

Is it just me??
Buddy come onto a construction site with me sometime, one on which these drive about at 40mph....
http://users.bigpond.net.au/maximilian/Bike%20Stuf...

You'd be suprised how much your opinion about being visible would change.

Or maybe in the vicinity of a 70m tall tower crane swinging 2 tonne loads about.... from 70m you on the ground look like an ant. An ant wearing a hi-viz vest is much more visible !!


Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Swilly said:
Hedders said:
Am i alone in thinking that all these hi-viz jackets are a complete waste of time?

Human beings are programmed to spot other human beings, and to watch out for other people when we are doing something that could put others in danger. Does being able to see a person one mile away, make any difference to your driving or would it be just as safe if you could see them from 300 yards away in normal clothing?

I had to go into a warehouse recently and everyone has to wear hi viz, even the fork lift drivers scratchchin

The only time you will get hit by a forklift truck in a warehouse is if the driver is looking the other way to the direction he is going, and so are you. No amount of Hi - Viz will help if you are not looking where you are going.

Has anyone here ever come close to running someone over and thought to themselves "Put a high -Viz jacket on FFS!"

Is it just me??
Buddy come onto a construction site with me sometime, one on which these drive about at 40mph....
http://users.bigpond.net.au/maximilian/Bike%20Stuf...

You'd be suprised how much your opinion about being visible would change.

Or maybe in the vicinity of a 70m tall tower crane swinging 2 tonne loads about.... from 70m you on the ground look like an ant. An ant wearing a hi-viz vest is much more visible !!
I will give you that one! large construction sites are a different proposition entirely and you would not get my Hi-viz off me :P

The crane scenario you mention is possibly the best use of high viz i can think of!