'The bank' is trying to make me bankrupt, again.
'The bank' is trying to make me bankrupt, again.
Author
Discussion

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Ok, i have a fairly bad credit history (as discussed on here before) and am paying back old debts at the rate of £400 a month through a debt management co.

Apparently the bank have changed collection agencies yet again and the new collection agency is moving the goalposts and will take me to bankruptcy court if i don't increase the payment by £50 a month!!

I have told them to go back to the agent and discuss it some more, because thats YOUR job.

If i called their bluff, A judge would tell them to bugger off wouldn't he?

















GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
I'm not so sure. They've got a right to demand you pay it off as quickly as you can. If your circumstances have changed since the original ruling and you can afford to pay more now, it's reasonable of them to ask you to. I don't know how the debt management company is involved or what their role is in this debt, but it doesn't seem unreasonable for the people you owe money to to approach you and ask you to pay it. I'm sure though that they have no right to demand you to pay more than you are able, and if they do take you to court I wouldn't expect the judge to set a repayment rate higher than you can realistically manage.

thehawk

9,335 posts

238 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
No, if they wanted they could pretty much present a creditors petition to have you made bankrupt regardless of any payment history or what your financial situation is.

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Sweet!

So a financial agreement is not worth the paper its written on. Good to know.

This is not the first time they have done this, they agree to take money and then you get a letter from a different company saying you owe THEM the money now!"

Much hilarity ensues as everyone figures out who has been paid what, and what extra charges need to be put on for the new company etc.

its all very fair.




smartie

2,630 posts

304 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Would it be in their interests to make you bankrupt? Would your assets, less secured loans leave a decent amount and would they get anything? Do they know this?

Debt collection agencies are very big on bluff and hope the individuals they go after are a little ignorant - scare tactics!

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
oh yes, my equity is five times greater than my debt. This month.

But i just don't believe they would fk someones life over for the difference of £50 a month.

I obviously still have too much faith, which is hard to believe..


J111

3,354 posts

246 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Do you have an informal agreement or an IVA ?

MURRAY007

530 posts

226 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
as long as your financial breakdown on outgoings stay the same the creditors dont have a leg to stand on.


MURRAY007

530 posts

226 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Best thing i ever did was go bankrupt, (had 35k debt) and 6 months later all gone.

was paying roughly same as you a month on debt, and had poor credit rating at the time, thought can't get no worse.

now 2-3 years later credit rating is getting back to normal.

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
I thought it was a formal agreement, but not an IVA.

I have paid (or will have paid) £4k to a debt management company to come to an agreement with my debtors (the bank's collection people) and act as go between because i am sick to death of them trying to screw me over.

One company accepted the debt management companies offer in writing and now they have done the same thing again and confused my debt company who don't know which account or which company they are dealing with, again.
At this point, all debts were supposed to be frozen but they make up for this by constantly bumping up the figure in different bankruptcy requests/threats when they employ new companies to scare me.

I will no doubt have direct debits going to the wrong people, more charges being made by my new bank when i go unexpectedly overdrawn trying to stay out of court again.

I have not had any credit for five years FFS, just let me pay it back and i won't ask for any more!






buggalugs

9,297 posts

268 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Hedders said:
Ok, i have a fairly bad credit history (as discussed on here before) and am paying back old debts at the rate of £400 a month through a debt management co.

Apparently the bank have changed collection agencies yet again and the new collection agency is moving the goalposts and will take me to bankruptcy court if i don't increase the payment by £50 a month!!

I have told them to go back to the agent and discuss it some more, because thats YOUR job.

If i called their bluff, A judge would tell them to bugger off wouldn't he?
They're not going to do fk all, it's just some soulless faceless devil spawn desk jockey trying it on because it's their job to try it on, and they've got a quota of 30 people a day to condescend to.

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
That is my feeling too.

It explains why so many people are choosing bankruptcy rather than repaying their debts though.




thehawk

9,335 posts

238 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought debt management plans weren't worth the paper they were written on, the industry is full of parasites.

J111

3,354 posts

246 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Having been a creditor with accounts in recovery, I wouldn't count on it being an idle threat.

I'm not aware of a structure that would provide a binding agreement to avoid bankruptcy outside of an IVA, and £4k for an informal agreement is ludicrous - in fact the latter can be done for free. Did you apply to a court in the course of making the agreement ?

Were it an IVA, the terms of repayment are set and cannot be altered providing you comply with those agreed. An informal agreement, on the other hand, can be altered, although a judge is unlikely to take a positive view of that alteration unless your circumstances have dramatically changed or, again, you have failed to comply with the agreement.

Internet legal advice being not worth the electrons it's written on (and IANAL) - My feeling, from what you've described, is that you need the urgent advice of a solicitor who's experienced in insolvency.

BTW: I am assuming you are in England or Wales

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
TBH I am getting that impression now.

When i signed up they told me they could put a halt to the games and get it sorted. They are now saying "We never said we could stop them making you bankrupt".

What good are they, they don't appear to have any more power than i do! ATleast i don't have to deal with the constant phone calls anymore, apart from the ones from the management company of course..

I should just bung my house on the market for 10k under value and go on holiday for a few years and then declare bankruptcy on my return..

scratchchinhehe







J111

3,354 posts

246 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
thehawk said:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought debt management plans weren't worth the paper they were written on
Informal agreements are not worthless, if you keep to the terms it's reasonable to assume you'll avoid county court or bankruptcy action, but they're sold as a cure-all requiring a manager when they are little more than a negotiation that can be handled by the debtor with free, or at least inexpensive, advice.

thehawk said:
the industry is full [entirely composed] of parasites.
EFA

Hedders

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
I was faced with a choice of getting a loan to pay everyone off, which would also be secured on my property or using these people.

The costs worked out the same so i went with the option that meant i could still cut and run if i need too :P


speedchick

5,291 posts

253 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
If you can, it may be worth ditching the debt management company, as the money you are paying them (in their fees) could be being paid off the debts, go to the CCCS and there is another one but I can't remember the name, they do all this for free and are better recognised by most of the financial institutions. They help you come up with a payable budget and will correspond with your creditors for you. (www.legalbeagles.info has a link for the various free services and other information)

In the meantime, depending on what the debt is, each time a new company get in touch about it, if it is a credit agreement, then write back to them asking them for the signed credit agreement, this tends to tie them up in knots and they usually pass it back to the original creditor.

J111

3,354 posts

246 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
speedchick said:
If you can, it may be worth ditching the debt management company, as the money you are paying them (in their fees) could be being paid off the debts, go to the CCCS and there is another one but I can't remember the name, they do all this for free and are better recognised by most of the financial institutions. They help you come up with a payable budget and will correspond with your creditors for you. (www.legalbeagles.info has a link for the various free services and other information)
yes The CAB is also hot on credit issues. The least ethical debt management companies like, presumably with a cry of 'ta da !', to tie their victims customers into a credit agreement for their fees irked, but there is no reasonable excuse for anyone to charge £4k for a non binding agreement !

speedchick said:
In the meantime, depending on what the debt is, each time a new company get in touch about it, if it is a credit agreement, then write back to them asking them for the signed credit agreement, this tends to tie them up in knots and they usually pass it back to the original creditor.
Unfortunately the agreement negates the get out of jail free card that can afford.

speedchick

5,291 posts

253 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
If the debt collection agency cannot produce the agreement, then they do not have the legal right to collect the money. They would need the agreement to take any further action, and would look rather stupid if they turned up in court wihtout it.