Excess Baggage & charges
Excess Baggage & charges
Author
Discussion

Patrick's Dad

Original Poster:

220 posts

307 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Myself, Patrick's mum and young Patrick who is 6 1/2 flew out to Brisbane via Hong Kong and Sydney late last month. We were migrating to Oz and booked three economy seats with an airline with a big red letter on the tail of their planes.
We arrived at Heathrow check in and were told by the check in girls that we were 14kg beyond our baggage allowance and there would be an excess charge.
At this stage I did'nt have a clue on the charge, so I pled my case - emigrating, 2 months survival stuff in the case etc. The response was pretty much a blank stare and a request for £37.20 per kilo of excess baggage for a grand total of £500 odd quid.
I asked to speak to a manager and was taken to the customer services desk where we were told we could either pay the money or leave some baggage behind. Due to fuel surcharges we had no other choice.
Now I can understand the economics of fuel charges etc, but the one thing I cannot get my head around, and I did mention this to the manageress at the time, is that the plane has a maximum take off weight which it cannot exceed. I suspect they work on about 90% of this weight to leave a safety margin. If we were 3 fully grown male adults with 23 kg each, we would weigh, combined about 370kg. Combined the three of us weighed 300kg, with Patrick coming in at a lightweight 27kg. By my thinking they are in a weight credit here of 70kilos and they wanted £500 also!
I have contacted Richards Airline and have had the usual brush off.
Beware fliers - customer service and human kindness are in short supply.
We are well rid of Britain.

Dave

insurance_jon

4,099 posts

277 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
been thinking about this tonight strangely enough, as I about to travel again and remebere when i last flew with the leeds based budget airline. I remebered that the scales didn't match the ones at home by a long shot and suddenly remebered the weights and measures act. Are airlines subject to this? If so can we demand to see any calibration records? Could this be a bargaining tool at the check in desk?

mouk786

1,263 posts

228 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Some people I know got it with another airlien and also had to pay a huge sum as well as abandon stuff at the airport

personally when i went on holdiay i was always paranoid of my 20kg luggage allowance as i knewi owuld have to bin stuff if it went over.

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Firstly, there is no 10% margin. Max take-off weight is calculated according to the prevailing conditions and adhered to. No reason to undercut by any percentage.

Standard passenger weights are used so for a given aircraft the manifest will show (say) 200 male adults, 50 female adults, 50 children and 5 infants. The standard weights will be mutiplied by these numbers to arrive at a total so they're not really 'in credit' because your son is smaller than you although he won't weigh as much as a 12 year old. Then again not all the males will be under the (sometimes standard) 77kg either.

All this is very well but no good to you when you're the 'wrong' side of the counter trying to get your bags checked in. From the staff point of view they dare not exceed allowances. If they do it for one they'll be expected to do it for all 405 passengers so that's a potential 6075kg or over 2% of maximum zero fuel weight on a 747-400. That might not sound like much but in terms of fuel that would have to be left behind it could represent the difference between hving to make a fuel stop or not without even looking at the implications on take-off distance required. In truth 2% might not be a big deal but hands up those who would be happy to climb aboard and find out how it goes?

For what it's worth you have my sympathy. You won't want to hear this but I emigrated to Australia with Cathay and baggage weight wise we got away with absolute liberties. The 'excuse' of migration went a long way with them and they levied no extra charges whatsoever.

Hope it goes well dununda. Head for Qld or the NT. Great place to raise a family.

SwissCamel

352 posts

223 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I think about this every time I fly. I weigh 80kg and am allowed 20kg. The missus is 50kg and is allowed 20kg. The fat bd behind us in the queue could be 110kg, and is allowed the same. I can see why the airline don't weigh you AND your luggage together, but it certainly ain't fair.

Patrick's Dad

Original Poster:

220 posts

307 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Thanks Flintstone, If the lady at Customer Services had explained that I would have accepted it, but at the time my wife was in tears over the sum and having left her family 6 hours before. We had absolutely no sympathy from the airline and it got my goat.
You eplain it very well and now I understand, but I cannot understand why the same airline let us on with no problem in Hong Kong and out of Sydney Virgin Blue just smiled and said 'No Worries'.
Insurance Jon, you're up late, Dave Brennand from D-Comm here.

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I know, it's even more annoying when they show little consistency. Might it be that the HK-Oz leg was less full? They'll sometimes be a bit easier if that's the case. I doubt if the check-in chick would have a clue why these limits apply, some will just enjoy enforcing the rules rolleyes

Hope the rest of the move goes well. You'll know you're settling in when Patrick starts making every sentence sound like a question?wink

smack

9,777 posts

222 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Take the most heavy items out of your check in bagage, and stuff it in your pockets, carry on bags, duty free bags and the heavy winter jackets and boots on you. If they are going to get petty, play there game by there rules, as they can't do anything if you have 3 coats on at checkin with is worth 100 quid as excess in your bag.

Silent1

19,762 posts

266 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
The other problem is, airlines use all the free space for cargo, so when you go over your allowance they have to leave some cargo behind, which they then charge you at full rates.

Being pilchard class is always the worst as they give you sod all leeway, whereas business or first let you have a bit more, especially if you're a points card person.

Blue Meanie

73,668 posts

286 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I fly on a seaman's ticket.. 40kg allowance for me! Woohooo!

Fiddlemesticks

14,472 posts

247 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
To the OP, not much comfort now, but there are certain airlines that will give you a migration allowance which basically means you have 40kg limit.

Its on the provision that you inform them when you book your ticket, the ticket is one way and you can show your visa.

We used it when we moved to oz and were very thankful.


Patrick's Dad

Original Poster:

220 posts

307 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
All I was loking for on the day was a little sympathy and understanding from Virgin staff. My wife was in tears, my little boy was looking bewildered and as usual all I could get was rules,rules,rules.
The more I think about it the more I dislike that culture of attitudes changing when people put on their corporate face.
FFS. have a little understanding and try to see things from our point of view. But they would'nt cos' they have a personality bypas every time they begin work.

Rant done. I'll never fly with them again and I'll make damn sure that everyone who asks me for a reccomendation gets the knowledge.
The good thing is, now we're in Caloundra on the Sunshine Coast and it's fantastic. Bets thing I ever did - so far.
Dave

peterperkins

3,458 posts

273 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
This always amazes me, and I hate standing behind the person at checkin who has not bothered to read the instructions, or checked the weight of there luggage before they set off.

The baggage allowance/sizes is/are plainly available for all to see. Comply with the rules and you won't have any issues.

1) Book cheapo airline flight with meager baggage allowance, Check!

2) Put bags on bathroom scales before attending airport and ensure not over permitted weights, Check!

3) Stand behind idiot at checkin who could not follow instructions, Check!! rolleyes

So no sympathy from me.

Howitzer

2,865 posts

247 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I'm the same as ^.

I fly a lot with work and it really irritates when people expect a freebie, which is all it is. Baggage limits are all very easy to obtain and it's also very easy to stick to these limits. Then we have the hand luggage, people think big rucksacks, various other crap is definitely needed on the plane, which is rubbish.

You make it hard to find cabin space with your overly large bags, nou slow down check in, you are being selfish, plain and simple.

This is more a general soap box rant than anything directed at the OP.

The service is say 1 person, 1 20kg bag. If in a restuarant you order a 9oz steak, you don't expect 12oz one to be available if you smile nicely and ask for compassion do you.

1 or 2 kilos I can understand, 10 over though, should have planned ahead.

Dave!

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Patrick's Dad said:
........but at the time my wife was in tears over the sum and having left her family 6 hours before.
We'll probably see you back in the UK within the year then.wink

Edited by fatboy b on Tuesday 22 July 07:54

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Patrick's Dad said:
All I was loking for on the day was a little sympathy and understanding from Virgin staff. My wife was in tears, my little boy was looking bewildered and as usual all I could get was rules,rules,rules.
The more I think about it the more I dislike that culture of attitudes changing when people put on their corporate face.
FFS. have a little understanding and try to see things from our point of view. But they would'nt cos' they have a personality bypas every time they begin work.

Rant done. I'll never fly with them again and I'll make damn sure that everyone who asks me for a reccomendation gets the knowledge.
The good thing is, now we're in Caloundra on the Sunshine Coast and it's fantastic. Bets thing I ever did - so far.
Dave
hate to sound harsh but you knew the luggage limits and are emigrating so must have another means of transporting your possessions to OZ. If it had been a coffin with a dead relative or their personal effects then that's different but a knuckle head censored can't and won't get organised enough to avoid exceeding a posted luggage limit is completely different and somewhat sad when you come crying on here.

Targarama

14,792 posts

314 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I think the issue here is more the actual amount charged for excess baggage. This seems to change and it varies between airlines. Virgin are not alone, and you were obviously unlucky - perhaps the flight was full/cargo full too.

Many airlines seem to apply the baggage rules how they like. Fly from India on Emirates - no excess charge for all manner of 'odd shaped' packages. My other half's baggage is 6kg over and has to pay £60. They spent 30 minutes looking for a manual credit card machine to enable them to levy the charge. White, UK passport = obviously able to pay I guess. She wasn't impressed and they gave her an upgrade to business to shut her up in the end.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Engineer1 said:
Patrick's Dad said:
All I was loking for on the day was a little sympathy and understanding from Virgin staff. My wife was in tears, my little boy was looking bewildered and as usual all I could get was rules,rules,rules.
The more I think about it the more I dislike that culture of attitudes changing when people put on their corporate face.
FFS. have a little understanding and try to see things from our point of view. But they would'nt cos' they have a personality bypas every time they begin work.

Rant done. I'll never fly with them again and I'll make damn sure that everyone who asks me for a reccomendation gets the knowledge.
The good thing is, now we're in Caloundra on the Sunshine Coast and it's fantastic. Bets thing I ever did - so far.
Dave
hate to sound harsh but you knew the luggage limits and are emigrating so must have another means of transporting your possessions to OZ. If it had been a coffin with a dead relative or their personal effects then that's different but a knuckle head censored can't and won't get organised enough to avoid exceeding a posted luggage limit is completely different and somewhat sad when you come crying on here.
Jesus. That's a bit harsh.

Howitzer

2,865 posts

247 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Targarama said:
I think the issue here is more the actual amount charged for excess baggage. This seems to change and it varies between airlines. Virgin are not alone, and you were obviously unlucky - perhaps the flight was full/cargo full too.

Many airlines seem to apply the baggage rules how they like. Fly from India on Emirates - no excess charge for all manner of 'odd shaped' packages. My other half's baggage is 6kg over and has to pay £60. They spent 30 minutes looking for a manual credit card machine to enable them to levy the charge. White, UK passport = obviously able to pay I guess. She wasn't impressed and they gave her an upgrade to business to shut her up in the end.
I agree with the above aswell.

Dave!

jfr

190 posts

238 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Howitzer said:
I'm the same as ^.

I fly a lot with work and it really irritates when people expect a freebie, which is all it is. Baggage limits are all very easy to obtain and it's also very easy to stick to these limits. Then we have the hand luggage, people think big rucksacks, various other crap is definitely needed on the plane, which is rubbish.

You make it hard to find cabin space with your overly large bags, nou slow down check in, you are being selfish, plain and simple.

This is more a general soap box rant than anything directed at the OP.

The service is say 1 person, 1 20kg bag. If in a restuarant you order a 9oz steak, you don't expect 12oz one to be available if you smile nicely and ask for compassion do you.

1 or 2 kilos I can understand, 10 over though, should have planned ahead.

Dave!
Not everyone flying is on business hence not everybody will be able to travel light, some people may and I mean may just be travelling to see relatives which they havent seen for a year and may want to take some presents or may be travelling with children. A measly 15-20 kg of baggage allowance doesnt get you very far when going away for 2 weeks.