Radiator flushing v replacement.
Radiator flushing v replacement.
Author
Discussion

cobra kid

Original Poster:

5,628 posts

271 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Two plumbers opinions..one stated it's best to replace radiators as the rotting process has started already. Other says it's not essential as flushing will give you years worth of usage.

Any thoughts? Cheers.

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
cobra kid said:
Two plumbers opinions..one stated it's best to replace radiators as the rotting process has started already. Other says it's not essential as flushing will give you years worth of usage.

Any thoughts? Cheers.
Need to put inhibitor in, that'll stop the rot. Could do with a flush though as well.

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
cobra kid said:
Two plumbers opinions..one stated it's best to replace radiators as the rotting process has started already. Other says it's not essential as flushing will give you years worth of usage.

Any thoughts? Cheers.
I'd guess the rot starts the day you put them in, unless new rads come with some sort of protective treatment on the inside? I was told that once all the oxygen has been used up in the water the ferrous oxide process comes to a halt. It is only when you keep adding more water that it continues.


grandmasterflash

248 posts

229 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
cobra kid said:
Two plumbers opinions..one stated it's best to replace radiators as the rotting process has started already. Other says it's not essential as flushing will give you years worth of usage.

Any thoughts? Cheers.
Need to put inhibitor in, that'll stop the rot. Could do with a flush though as well.
Try adding a MAGNACLEAN to your system as it'll help with managing the Iron oxide in your system, the plumber should be able to fit one for a good price.

Mighty Mini

46 posts

242 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
cobra kid said:
Two plumbers opinions..one stated it's best to replace radiators as the rotting process has started already. Other says it's not essential as flushing will give you years worth of usage.

Any thoughts? Cheers.
Need to put inhibitor in, that'll stop the rot. Could do with a flush though as well.
Get the system flushed, then add a product like 'Fernox' it's a central heating protector.
Sounds like the plumber who suggested replacing the rads was short of work and needed to make a bit of cash!

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Oh I will share my little mistake with you. I had a pump which was 'chugging' plumbers words not mine. Every now and then, more now than then, it would go slow - you could hear the pump slow down. I had an 'expert' in mad that told me that I had to have my system Powerflushed.. at a cost of about £800 I kid you not yikes

I visited my local boiler centre and asked for best advice. He told me to put in a cleaner, leave it for a week and then flush it out and refill it with inhibitor. The pump was very noisy at this point and I thought I would end up having to have a new one. Anyway, guess who forgot to take the cleaner out of the system... for 3 months boxedin I flsuhed it out and it came out brown to start with and then to my suprise it was clear very soon after. I rang the boiler clinic, he said I was lucky I had not damaged the seals of the pump or the boiler, so I had service done on the boiler and all was well.

Total cost for the flush stuff was about £28.
Powerflush would have been £800 - go figure!

The stuff was made by Furnox and called Heavy Duty Restorer and it does exactly what it says on the tin (bottle) biggrin

Ferg

15,242 posts

288 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
If you change the radiators you will still leave plenty of sludge in the system and may well get it on the carpets!!
Inhibitors are all very well, but as mentioned above 'free oxygen' is the killer. If the hydraulic pressures are OK the system will draw in no (or very, very little) fresh water and no rusting will occur. A very sludged system should be accurately diagnosed as to it's problems before throwing money at it. You need a decent heating engineer.
HTH

Chainguy

4,381 posts

231 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Just flush it yourself. HSS will hire the tool out for £60, get a big rubber hammer to hit the rads with and the chemicals, and a monkey could do it from there. I helped a mate do his. Easy peasy.

Ferg

15,242 posts

288 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
SS HSV said:
I rang the boiler clinic, he said I was lucky I had not damaged the seals of the pump or the boiler, so I had service done on the boiler and all was well.
That's so unlikely.
Even Fernox's Heavy Duty Restorer isn't that strong. I'd love to hear from anyone who has made a pump or boiler leak with proprietary cleaning chemicals.

Powerflushing is definately the only way you'll get a system clean and I'd put a magnetic collector on too.
Doing it yourself is fine and if you don't include your labour it's a cheap thing to do, but don't scrimp.
You should definately put in a decent cleaner and circulate it HOT for a period of weeks, then powerflush the primaries and each radiator seperately until completely clean. I've seen them run clean for 5 minutes then have a big slug come through.

But like I said, please find out WHY it's making sludge first......

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
SS HSV said:
Oh I will share my little mistake with you. I had a pump which was 'chugging' plumbers words not mine. Every now and then, more now than then, it would go slow - you could hear the pump slow down. I had an 'expert' in mad that told me that I had to have my system Powerflushed.. at a cost of about £800 I kid you not yikes

I visited my local boiler centre and asked for best advice. He told me to put in a cleaner, leave it for a week and then flush it out and refill it with inhibitor. The pump was very noisy at this point and I thought I would end up having to have a new one. Anyway, guess who forgot to take the cleaner out of the system... for 3 months boxedin I flsuhed it out and it came out brown to start with and then to my suprise it was clear very soon after. I rang the boiler clinic, he said I was lucky I had not damaged the seals of the pump or the boiler, so I had service done on the boiler and all was well.

Total cost for the flush stuff was about £28.
Powerflush would have been £800 - go figure!

The stuff was made by Furnox and called Heavy Duty Restorer and it does exactly what it says on the tin (bottle) biggrin
You are me!!!!!! yikes

Scary, but Brit Gas told me the same thing, noisy pump, and they won't replace it as the system NEEDS an £800 power flush. You know the rest, except my Furnox restorer is still in there, a year later, and the noisy rattly pump is silent now. biggrin

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
To give you an idea, we're charging £400 and still making a very very healthy profit on power flushing. Somebody charging £800 is taking the preverbial.

Ferg

15,242 posts

288 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
To give you an idea, we're charging £400 and still making a very very healthy profit on power flushing. Somebody charging £800 is taking the preverbial.
Interesting.
Most of the systems we have to powerflush require two blokes for 3/4 of a day plus chemicals to do effectively. Allowing for a consideration for the investment in the machine I can only deduce that your labour rates are FAR less than ours.....

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Ferg said:
10 Pence Short said:
To give you an idea, we're charging £400 and still making a very very healthy profit on power flushing. Somebody charging £800 is taking the preverbial.
Interesting.
Most of the systems we have to powerflush require two blokes for 3/4 of a day plus chemicals to do effectively. Allowing for a consideration for the investment in the machine I can only deduce that your labour rates are FAR less than ours.....
I would imagine the labour rates in Cumbria are less than those in Essex.