A Levels - worthless
Discussion
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/2445617/Bri...
So it would appear that the education system, under the auspices of New Labour, has finally got to the stage where the universities view A levels as worthless. Everything suspected about the dumbing-down of A levels would appear to be true.
Cambridge University has simply gone around them.
How soon before all state-owned qualifications are viewed with disdain and only recognised private-sector certificates will do?
Sad day.
So it would appear that the education system, under the auspices of New Labour, has finally got to the stage where the universities view A levels as worthless. Everything suspected about the dumbing-down of A levels would appear to be true.
Cambridge University has simply gone around them.
How soon before all state-owned qualifications are viewed with disdain and only recognised private-sector certificates will do?
Sad day.
Article said:
It comes amid fears from head teachers that students can now complete entire A-level courses without writing a single essay.
Yep it confuses the hell out of University Lecturers when you turn up and they say "write an essay" and you trun around and go "A what?... " WTF is a bibliography etc.Either Unis need to fit the students or the students need to fit the Unis, but for the sake of Lecturers blood pressure something needs to be changed.
(For the record I did a BTEC not A-Levels but the effect was the same...Essay? A town in Holland?)
I was quite suspicious that this may be the case ever since they introduced the stupid half A-levels with exams at the end of the Lower 6th (or whatever it's called now). And the kids complain they have too much to do. Blimey, spoon fed from what used to be a syllabus and is now a glorified marking scheme, and they only have to remember it for a maximum of a year.
A-levels are, and always have been, merely a kind of glorified entrance exam for getting onto a degree course (apart from for those people who choose to cease formal education after their A-levels, obviously).
If they are now ceasing to fulfil even that role then they really are worthless.
If they are now ceasing to fulfil even that role then they really are worthless.
I think A-levels have been getting easier since they were first introduced. When I took my A-levels they were far easier than those that my parents took and, looking at the current papers, they've got easier still since.
To be fair, getting a degree is also absurdly easy now though, too.
To be fair, getting a degree is also absurdly easy now though, too.
Edited by kambites on Wednesday 23 July 10:17
JonRB said:
A-levels are, and always have been, merely a kind of glorified entrance exam for getting onto a degree course (apart from for those people who choose to cease formal education after their A-levels, obviously).
If they are now ceasing to fulfil even that role then they really are worthless.
But there are still 2 ways to solve that problem. Universities adjust their courses to match the students skills from their A-Levels. Or the A-Levels match the skills required by the Universities.If they are now ceasing to fulfil even that role then they really are worthless.
Universities being what they are are refusing to budge to match the students and would sooner create their own entrance exams. Thats fine. It solves the problem.... Except that GCSE's wont match the skills required for the Uni entrance exams and it'll have to filter down the next level.
I think it's worth keeping in mind it's not the students fault though. They just say "I want to go to the next level" and do as they are told.
I'm going to outline my personal experience and see what you lot think.
I was in the first cohort to do the new-ish style AS-levels in year 12 (2001) and A2-levels in year 13 (2002). I did Maths, Physics, History and German. Due to a bit of adolescent stupidity I screwed up the AS-levels and got extremely sub-par grades in all but History. I then woke up and realised that I wanted to go to university to do Computer Science so I needed an A in maths.
After my AS-level failure I worked harder than I've ever done due to the fear of God at ending up somewhere I didn't want to be. I think I got 80% plus in all of my maths exams, including the resits, and in some of the later pure exams I got pretty close to 100%.
The A-levels I did weren't "easy"; in my gap year I later did some A-level maths tuition and the people I taught probably wouldn't have been capable of getting 80% or 90% across the board but they were bright enough and got Bs or Cs. I think a more accurate opinion is that they're not challenging enough for the very top performers, the most intelligent and most talented pupils. I'm not stupid, but neither am I a maths genius. In my opinion, I shouldn't really have been able to get 90%+ on some maths papers but I could and I did.
Would it be too contrite to suggest that A-levels aren't too easy for all, but they're not hard enough for some?
I was in the first cohort to do the new-ish style AS-levels in year 12 (2001) and A2-levels in year 13 (2002). I did Maths, Physics, History and German. Due to a bit of adolescent stupidity I screwed up the AS-levels and got extremely sub-par grades in all but History. I then woke up and realised that I wanted to go to university to do Computer Science so I needed an A in maths.
After my AS-level failure I worked harder than I've ever done due to the fear of God at ending up somewhere I didn't want to be. I think I got 80% plus in all of my maths exams, including the resits, and in some of the later pure exams I got pretty close to 100%.
The A-levels I did weren't "easy"; in my gap year I later did some A-level maths tuition and the people I taught probably wouldn't have been capable of getting 80% or 90% across the board but they were bright enough and got Bs or Cs. I think a more accurate opinion is that they're not challenging enough for the very top performers, the most intelligent and most talented pupils. I'm not stupid, but neither am I a maths genius. In my opinion, I shouldn't really have been able to get 90%+ on some maths papers but I could and I did.
Would it be too contrite to suggest that A-levels aren't too easy for all, but they're not hard enough for some?
Edited by Mutt on Wednesday 23 July 10:36
They are too easy if you cannot discern the exceptional from the bright.
I've often thought that rather than change the exam, why dont they give out grades on a proportionate basis.
So in 100K exam takers there are 1000 As, which go to the top 1000 marks. Rather than saying over 80% is an A
I've often thought that rather than change the exam, why dont they give out grades on a proportionate basis.
So in 100K exam takers there are 1000 As, which go to the top 1000 marks. Rather than saying over 80% is an A
Plotloss said:
They are too easy if you cannot discern the exceptional from the bright.
I've often thought that rather than change the exam, why dont they give out grades on a proportionate basis.
So in 100K exam takers there are 1000 As, which go to the top 1000 marks. Rather than saying over 80% is an A
But what do you do when 90% get the same mark? I've often thought that rather than change the exam, why dont they give out grades on a proportionate basis.
So in 100K exam takers there are 1000 As, which go to the top 1000 marks. Rather than saying over 80% is an A

Edited by Munter on Wednesday 23 July 10:46
My highly intelligent Niece, just completed GCSE's where she is predicted 11 A*'s. She wants to become a barrister. She'd dearly like to attend a TOP university (not crewe and alsager college or preston polytechnic)
Should she bother with A levels or an International Baquelarete (sp?). Or maybe she should leave school and do an apprenticeship in knife crime, as a law into Law ?
What would PH recommmmmmend ?
Should she bother with A levels or an International Baquelarete (sp?). Or maybe she should leave school and do an apprenticeship in knife crime, as a law into Law ?
What would PH recommmmmmend ?
Plotloss said:
They are too easy if you cannot discern the exceptional from the bright.
I've often thought that rather than change the exam, why dont they give out grades on a proportionate basis.
So in 100K exam takers there are 1000 As, which go to the top 1000 marks. Rather than saying over 80% is an A
Isn't that what is already done ?I've often thought that rather than change the exam, why dont they give out grades on a proportionate basis.
So in 100K exam takers there are 1000 As, which go to the top 1000 marks. Rather than saying over 80% is an A
lunarscope said:
Plotloss said:
They are too easy if you cannot discern the exceptional from the bright.
I've often thought that rather than change the exam, why dont they give out grades on a proportionate basis.
So in 100K exam takers there are 1000 As, which go to the top 1000 marks. Rather than saying over 80% is an A
Isn't that what is already done ?I've often thought that rather than change the exam, why dont they give out grades on a proportionate basis.
So in 100K exam takers there are 1000 As, which go to the top 1000 marks. Rather than saying over 80% is an A

Munter said:
Universities being what they are are refusing to budge to match the students and would sooner create their own entrance exams.
Quite right too, we should not be dumbing down universities, they should be places where intellectuals can flourish, not where academic mediocrity is celebrated.Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



