Plumbers / Bathroom Installers - Am I being unreasonable?
Plumbers / Bathroom Installers - Am I being unreasonable?
Author
Discussion

S7Paul

Original Poster:

2,103 posts

265 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
We’ve wanted to get our bathroom re-fitted (new suite, tiles, etc) for a while now, and decided that it would be ideal for it to be done while we’re on holiday next month. We found someone who seemed reasonable and could do it while we’re away. He had given us a quote which gave a fair description of the scope of the job, and a total price. I phoned him the other night to arrange for him to come round so that we could discuss the finer detail, and I had been expecting to give him a cheque at that time so that he could start buying the materials. During that phone call, I asked him if he could also break the price down into labour & materials. I wasn’t asking for a fully itemised list, just, for example, £2K materials + £3K labour = £5K total. He immediately got agitated and suggested that I didn’t trust him. I simply explained that I thought it was standard practice to get that level of visibility, it’s a large sum of money (so I’m interested to see how it’s apportioned), and that there was no implied lack of trust. He said that he may take a while to do this as he’s busy, so I just said that it would be nice if he could have the information by Friday (when he had arranged to come round). He phoned me last night to withdraw his quote on the grounds that I appear not to trust him, and that he felt the working relationship would be poor. I explained my position again, but he had clearly made his mind up. He went on to say that he had never been asked for this before, and had spoken to some of his colleagues who allegedly had also never been asked for any sort of cost breakdown. I was initially very annoyed, as I now don’t have time to arrange for someone else to do the job while we’re away, but the more I think about it, the more I begin to suspect that there may be other reasons for him being unwilling to give me the details, e.g. astronomical labour costs. What is other people’s experience? Was I being unreasonable? Have I had a lucky escape?

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Nope cant read it.

Paragraphs please

Glassman

25,105 posts

246 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
rich1231 said:
Nope cant read it.

Paragraphs please
hehe

I gave up after the first line.

Mike400

1,026 posts

262 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
I did manage to read it, and I think its fair enough to request a break down in costs. You are handing over a large amount of money and its only fair to see where it is being spent.

Lack of trust works both ways, and he is evidently reluctant to trust you with the details you asked for.

It also makes me think he is reluctant to reveal his labour rates as he knows they are on the high side.

On the other hand I have to ask why you need said details, if you think its a fair price for the end result you require, why worry about how he gets there?

maxrider

2,481 posts

267 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
S7Paul said:
We’ve wanted to get our bathroom re-fitted (new suite, tiles, etc) for a while now, and decided that it would be ideal for it to be done while we’re on holiday next month.

We found someone who seemed reasonable and could do it while we’re away. He had given us a quote which gave a fair description of the scope of the job, and a total price.

I phoned him the other night to arrange for him to come round so that we could discuss the finer detail, and I had been expecting to give him a cheque at that time so that he could start buying the materials. During that phone call, I asked him if he could also break the price down into labour & materials. I wasn’t asking for a fully itemised list, just, for example, £2K materials + £3K labour = £5K total.

He immediately got agitated and suggested that I didn’t trust him. I simply explained that I thought it was standard practice to get that level of visibility, it’s a large sum of money (so I’m interested to see how it’s apportioned), and that there was no implied lack of trust.

He said that he may take a while to do this as he’s busy, so I just said that it would be nice if he could have the information by Friday (when he had arranged to come round).

He phoned me last night to withdraw his quote on the grounds that I appear not to trust him, and that he felt the working relationship would be poor. I explained my position again, but he had clearly made his mind up. He went on to say that he had never been asked for this before, and had spoken to some of his colleagues who allegedly had also never been asked for any sort of cost breakdown.

I was initially very annoyed, as I now don’t have time to arrange for someone else to do the job while we’re away, but the more I think about it, the more I begin to suspect that there may be other reasons for him being unwilling to give me the details, e.g. astronomical labour costs.

What is other people’s experience? Was I being unreasonable? Have I had a lucky escape?
Better?
FFS it's not rocket science... Is it?

speedy_thrills

7,979 posts

274 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Seems reasonable to me.

E36GUY

5,907 posts

249 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Sod the builder.

Work out the square meterage of the tiles etc that you need and go buy them yourself. Then go to Bathstore and order the units you want. Then get a builder to quote for the labour and a few fixtures and fittings that'll be required. Then you know where you are.

maxrider

2,481 posts

267 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
maxrider said:
S7Paul said:
We’ve wanted to get our bathroom re-fitted (new suite, tiles, etc) for a while now, and decided that it would be ideal for it to be done while we’re on holiday next month.

We found someone who seemed reasonable and could do it while we’re away. He had given us a quote which gave a fair description of the scope of the job, and a total price.

I phoned him the other night to arrange for him to come round so that we could discuss the finer detail, and I had been expecting to give him a cheque at that time so that he could start buying the materials. During that phone call, I asked him if he could also break the price down into labour & materials. I wasn’t asking for a fully itemised list, just, for example, £2K materials + £3K labour = £5K total.

He immediately got agitated and suggested that I didn’t trust him. I simply explained that I thought it was standard practice to get that level of visibility, it’s a large sum of money (so I’m interested to see how it’s apportioned), and that there was no implied lack of trust.

He said that he may take a while to do this as he’s busy, so I just said that it would be nice if he could have the information by Friday (when he had arranged to come round).

He phoned me last night to withdraw his quote on the grounds that I appear not to trust him, and that he felt the working relationship would be poor. I explained my position again, but he had clearly made his mind up. He went on to say that he had never been asked for this before, and had spoken to some of his colleagues who allegedly had also never been asked for any sort of cost breakdown.

I was initially very annoyed, as I now don’t have time to arrange for someone else to do the job while we’re away, but the more I think about it, the more I begin to suspect that there may be other reasons for him being unwilling to give me the details, e.g. astronomical labour costs.

What is other people’s experience? Was I being unreasonable? Have I had a lucky escape?
Better?
FFS it's not rocket science... Is it?

fk! buggered up by a sodding advert irked

..and my inability to differentiate between the quote and edit paperbag
Edited by maxrider on Wednesday 23 July 13:41

Landlord

12,689 posts

288 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
S7Paul said:
He immediately got agitated and suggested that I didn’t trust him.
Too fking right - you've never met him so why should you trust him? Walk away.

Mike400

1,026 posts

262 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
E36GUY said:
Sod the builder.

Work out the square meterage of the tiles etc that you need and go buy them yourself. Then go to Bathstore and order the units you want. Then get a builder to quote for the labour and a few fixtures and fittings that'll be required. Then you know where you are.
+1, probably the best advice and whilst maybe a bit more hassle you will know exactly where you stand

Nobby Diesel

2,120 posts

282 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
If you've already accepted the price, presumably, you were happy with it?
Why do you need the breakdown? He may well have a high labour rate; so what, you've accepted the figure offered.
He may well be hoping to use up materials stocked up from previous jobs, that he wishes to conceal.

However, I do think he has over reacted somewhat.

Glassman

25,105 posts

246 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
maxrider said:
Better?
FFS it's not rocket science... Is it?
No, Miss.

tongue out

ln1234

848 posts

229 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
You're lucky you've worked out what kind of person he is BEFORE you've handed over any of your money. From my experience with builders / workmen, i've realised that you have to be clear as to what you want - preferably having things drawn out / listed on paper, and then going through these in detail with the workmen so there is no ambiguity. I've had workmen who have been too busy to give me detailed quotes or won't sit down and go through whats required, but my point is that if they have done the sums themselves and have worked out what needs to get done, including costs, then surely they can share that... Unless they have just pulled out a ballpark figure off the top of their head, and will add on 'extras' during the job.

Oh, and be careful of extras you'll get charged for. We had a quote for a loft conversion, and the builder tried to charge us £1000 for moving the water tank. It wasn't in the contract we'd signed with him as I assumed that was included. Big mistake!

phillvr6

3,785 posts

291 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
I went through a similar exercise earlier this year and sent the foillowing email to each contractor I asked to quote:

Hello,
We have a small one bed house on ?????????. We would like to replace the bathroom. I expect the scope of works will include:

Remove existing tiles and make good where necessary.
Remove existing bath, sink and toilet.
Strip existing vinyl flooring.
Supply and install bath, sink and toilet to match existing
Supply and install taps etc.
Supply and install new vinyl flooring
Retile previously tiled areas / possible retile all walls (cost dependant)
Repaint areas not tiled, including ceiling with bathroom specific paint.
Supply and install shower and associated pump.
Supply and install electric heated towel rail.

If there are significant savings to be made, some items may change to install only.

Could you please let me know when you would be able to call around to discuss.

Thanks,

PhillVR6.

When they visited, I asked them to provide a fully itemised quote so I could compare it with all other quotes.

It may have helped that my email address belongs to one of the largets building services companies in the UK.

So in a nutshell, no your being perfectly reasonable

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
I agree things should be broken down, but I don't think you should be parting with any money until he's done TBH.

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
It's not unreasonable to ask for it, but it does seem to cause issues quite frequently. Had this several times in the course of looking for builders for my place. Also had "agreed prices" which I wouldn't give the OK on till I had it in writing, only when the written quote with a break-down appeared, the price had jumped (by an increase of up to £13k in some cases!)

Paracetamol

4,267 posts

275 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
You are right to walk away. He could be using a very cheap bathroom suite and tiles and charging a fortune for labour. If I were you I would buy quality branded items from a bathroom specilaist (not B+Q etc and not Bathstore!) . Then find a quality builder to install. An average bathroom should cost around £2500 to srip, fix and tile.

Glassman

25,105 posts

246 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
We're in the middle of having a new bathroom fitted; I knew who I wanted to use, but as a guide, I got three quotes from randomly selected local firms.

Dave came in and quoted for the works. Likability is crucial for both parties. If there was something I wasn't sure about, Dave was (and still is) honest enough to tell me what the Bobby Moore is... I also respect that he is trying to earn his worth.

Before I gave him the go ahead, he'd quoted me for labour including materials. We then went about looking at the hardware (which he also supplied). We saved 30% on tiles after he told us to select the tiles and let him buy them with the trade discount he gets.

After a bit of squeezing and pushing, we ended up with a price that both parties were happy with.

It doesn't have to be difficult. Well, two weeks without proper bath/shower facilities can be...

215cu

2,956 posts

241 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
phillvr6 said:
I went through a similar exercise earlier this year and sent the foillowing email to each contractor I asked to quote:

Hello,
We have a small one bed house on ?????????. We would like to replace the bathroom. I expect the scope of works will include:

Remove existing tiles and make good where necessary.
Remove existing bath, sink and toilet.
Strip existing vinyl flooring.
Supply and install bath, sink and toilet to match existing
Supply and install taps etc.
Supply and install new vinyl flooring
Retile previously tiled areas / possible retile all walls (cost dependant)
Repaint areas not tiled, including ceiling with bathroom specific paint.
Supply and install shower and associated pump.
Supply and install electric heated towel rail.

If there are significant savings to be made, some items may change to install only.

Could you please let me know when you would be able to call around to discuss.

Thanks,

PhillVR6.

When they visited, I asked them to provide a fully itemised quote so I could compare it with all other quotes.

It may have helped that my email address belongs to one of the largets building services companies in the UK.

So in a nutshell, no your being perfectly reasonable
Phil, sweet list, am about to start on a new bathroom caper. thumbup

To the OP, you're not being unreasonable, simply put, that's bks and the builder is either trying it on or looking to get out of the work, or worse, pocket the cheque and turn up sometime near Christmas or never.

Another idea to source the lion's share of the stuff yourself isn't bad at all. It's not too difficult to obtain a bathroom suite, tiles, fixtures. There's plenty of offers on, Homebase are offering 12 months 0% if you spend £1000 or over. Just measure up plenty of times, make a plan out and take your time to avoid making any mistakes.

There are plenty of trade people who will look upon this as perfectly satisfactory and will also be glad of less hassle of having to source stuff for you.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
phillvr6 said:
It may have helped that my email address belongs to one of the largets building services companies in the UK.
Maybe that does make a difference - I'm astonished that anybody replied to your email.