Monarchy or Republic - the poll
Monarchy or Republic - the poll

Poll: Monarchy or Republic - the poll

Total Members Polled: 169

Monarchy: 76%
Republic: 17%
Don't know: 1%
Don't care: 5%
Don't live in UK or dominions: 1%
Author
Discussion

tubbystu

Original Poster:

3,846 posts

291 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
As mooted in the "should we pay for banquets" thread a poll on monarchy against a republic.

edited for typothumbup



Edited by tubbystu on Friday 25th July 16:33

Rod Rammage

2,557 posts

231 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Mooted.



Thanks.

chris_w666

22,655 posts

230 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Where is the option for CoUNTry? Just with the way its being ran we are doing a good job.

Tony*T3

20,911 posts

278 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
i dont like the monarchy but its better than haveing 'President Blair' or similar, even if you can vote them out.

Monarchy: Inbred idiots out of touch with reality

Republic: Self important ego maniacs with hige wealth and no morales.



Both such really. I suggest we give anarchy a try.

randomman

2,215 posts

220 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Am I right in assuming that a president has far more power than a PM?

If so can anyone imagine what poo poo we would be in if Bliar was Pres?


Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
chris_w666 said:
Where is the option for CoUNTry? Just with the way its being ran we are doing a good job.
"Hello there. I'm your local candidate for the Gibberish Party" rolleyes

claypigeon60

840 posts

249 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
My appallingly socialist view: at least cut her down by one palace.

Chuck her out to Windsor; take Buck House off her and convert it to luxury flats and sell at an outrageous price; use resulting cash to build both affordable (joint-ownership) housing for 'key workers' (AKA those we depend on but don't pay enough to) and a load of hostels for the homeless.

mrmaggit

10,146 posts

279 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
TBH, I wish her Maj. would pull the plug on this lot. Surely a government lossing a by-election by such an amount that it would have (if transposed to the previous General Election) have won less than 10% of the seats it currently has has lost the support of the population?

collateral

7,238 posts

249 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
I went with don't know.

In spite of the presidency, I prefer the more localized approach of the US tbh

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
claypigeon60 said:
... a load of hostels for the homeless.
Then who will sell the Big Issue? The magazine will go bust putting people out of work and on the streets because the hostels are all full of the homeless YOU put there.

That's the trouble with you lot. Never think things through.








;)

escargot

17,123 posts

248 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Monarchy for sure.

Despite the (minimal) cost for the tax payer, it's part of our heritage and that in itself is worth preserving. From a financial point of view, the revenue they bring in to the economy from tourism alone probably eclipses any cost to us.

Fetchez la vache

5,913 posts

245 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
escargot said:
Monarchy for sure.

Despite the (minimal) cost for the tax payer, it's part of our heritage and that in itself is worth preserving. From a financial point of view, the revenue they bring in to the economy from tourism alone probably eclipses any cost to us.
What e said.

keep good old Queenie (and no I'm not talking about Mr. Barrowman, Slikk).

Finlandia

7,818 posts

262 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
As a cultural/historical thing it may have its place and admirers.
On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?

claypigeon60

840 posts

249 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
escargot said:
Monarchy for sure.

Despite the (minimal) cost for the tax payer, it's part of our heritage and that in itself is worth preserving. From a financial point of view, the revenue they bring in to the economy from tourism alone probably eclipses any cost to us.
Well it's the common argument from Royalists; but the common counter-argument is that no-one has stopped visiting France because they got rid of their royalty.

Let's be honest, we're talking about Americans here - for the most part they think we all live in castles. It makes me cringe how some US films portray the UK (seen Three Men and a Little Lady?)

jeff m

4,066 posts

289 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
I've lived in two Monarchies and two Republics
I ticked Monarchy.

Republics are expensive to run and encourage corruption.

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
I am pleasantly surprised at the poll results. I often get the feeling I am in a minority, happy to be proved wrong.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Finlandia said:
As a cultural/historical thing it may have its place and admirers.
On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
Its the institution rather than the family. Forget the personalities for a moment, the monarch is merely the personification of the crown.

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Damn I was trying to vote for Monarch of the Glen smile

Swilly

9,699 posts

305 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Finlandia said:
As a cultural/historical thing it may have its place and admirers.
On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
I am all for the Monarchy.

They are probably more relevant today than yesteryear, simply by the fact that they occupy a position that otherwise a politician would occupy. They uphold a very successful limbo.

Who worships the royal family !? I dont, i think most are planks. I have no idea, on a personal level, who the Queen is and neither do i care, so long as she acts in the impeccable public manner that she has done for the last near-60 years on the throne.

Who says they are worth any more !? I dont.

Finlandia

7,818 posts

262 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
Finlandia said:
As a cultural/historical thing it may have its place and admirers.
On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
Its the institution rather than the family. Forget the personalities for a moment, the monarch is merely the personification of the crown.
Then why not have the crown and the palace as the institution and reminder of the glory and monarchy. There need not be any kings or queens, but a symbol that can be worshipped and looked up to.