Gas BBQ Recomendations
Author
Discussion

Seight_Returns

Original Poster:

1,640 posts

232 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Following a series of complaints from my neighbour about smoke from my charcoal BBQ, I'm going to buy a gas barbecue.

I've had a quick look around John Lewis and I've narrowed the choice down to the Weber SpiritE210 or The John Lewis Equivalent.

The Weber obvilously has the reassurance of the brand name and the perceived ease of availability of spare parts and accessories and can be got for a good discount at various places on the Interweb.

The John Lewis seems much more substantial with heavier grill castinngs etc.

Anyone have any experience of these or able to remomend an alternative ?

Cheers

Roop

6,018 posts

315 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
I bought a Genesis E320 recently and it's ace. Other than that, the gas powered Char-Broil I got from B&Q 10 years ago for 1/12th the price of the Weber is still going strong back in the UK...

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Flaming BBQs sale ends today

I don't work for them - just a happy customer!

Sharief

6,551 posts

247 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
WTF? Your neighbours complained about smoke from a BBQ? Jesus. Sorry can't help with finding your BBQ but that's ridiculous! Love the smell of a BBQ in the summer. lick

Hereward

5,166 posts

261 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
I have that exact John Lewis one.

Materials are of a good quality but the gas connection pipe is on full display, and not hidden round the back, which is a shame.

Also it doesn't have a warming rack, but I think you can get an add-on one.

NDA

25,830 posts

256 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Puggit said:
Flaming BBQs sale ends today

I don't work for them - just a happy customer!
Thanks for the link, I've just ordered a gas BBQ from them. I'm not sure how it will compare to my normal Webber thing with charcoal, but worth a play at such low, low prices!

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Sharief said:
WTF? Your neighbours complained about smoke from a BBQ? Jesus. Sorry can't help with finding your BBQ but that's ridiculous! Love the smell of a BBQ in the summer. lick
yes I'd be buying a bigger charcoal one.

dougc

8,241 posts

296 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
Sharief said:
WTF? Your neighbours complained about smoke from a BBQ? Jesus. Sorry can't help with finding your BBQ but that's ridiculous! Love the smell of a BBQ in the summer. lick
yes I'd be buying a bigger charcoal one.
And adding woodchips.

308mate

13,758 posts

253 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
You want a hood and a warming rack. Side burners are overrated unless youre Gordon Ramsay. They take up valuable space where you could put beer/meat/plates etc and theyre a pain to work over if theres a shelf the other side.

Outback make gooduns. Weber are good but not the best value for money.

Any man worth his salt has a wooden trolley by the way. And make sure you build it yourself.


215cu

2,956 posts

241 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
dougc said:
fatboy b said:
Sharief said:
WTF? Your neighbours complained about smoke from a BBQ? Jesus. Sorry can't help with finding your BBQ but that's ridiculous! Love the smell of a BBQ in the summer. lick
yes I'd be buying a bigger charcoal one.
And adding woodchips.
Sod woodchips.... I'd add coal thumbup Not to cook on, just to fk them right off.

In all seriousness, what is the point of a gas barbecue? Might as well just fry the stuff on a gas hob.

Where's the skill in fire lighting and cooking using burning materials? Also, a good charcoal really adds flavour especially with some hickory chips mixed in.

Edited by 215cu on Wednesday 30th July 12:20

furtive

4,503 posts

310 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
I've got one of these:

http://www.wyevale.co.uk/Antony%20Worrall%20Thomps...

Works great despite having that loathsome mans name plastered on it

BoXtaPete

36 posts

225 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Having had several gas barbeques, including some 'so called' premium brands, I have to say I'm quite disappointed with them all as far as the build quality is concerned. I have found that after 2 years - of quite extensive use - they are falling apart. Whatever the brand, I find it is not easy to get replacement parts, so eventually I get so p**sed off, I go and buy another, and so the whole roundabout starts again.

I would really like to buy something that will last for many years, that can live outside all the year and be used every week of the year. I have been told that Napoleon are very good, Canadian, and totally made in Canada, whereas the majority are Far East made. Do any PHers have any experience of these, or any recommendations?

Sharief

6,551 posts

247 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
BoXtaPete said:
Having had several gas barbeques, including some 'so called' premium brands, I have to say I'm quite disappointed with them all as far as the build quality is concerned. I have found that after 2 years - of quite extensive use - they are falling apart. Whatever the brand, I find it is not easy to get replacement parts, so eventually I get so p**sed off, I go and buy another, and so the whole roundabout starts again.

I would really like to buy something that will last for many years, that can live outside all the year and be used every week of the year. I have been told that Napoleon are very good, Canadian, and totally made in Canada, whereas the majority are Far East made. Do any PHers have any experience of these, or any recommendations?
I understand there's a Danish or Dutch brand that's very very good... Can't remember the name though. But they have Global knives in the adverts if that helps.

WhoreLex

3,030 posts

249 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
I use a three burner outback hunter, its about seven years old and the only thing I've had to do to it is replace the rusty cast iron grills with new porcelain coated ones smile

Its not the fanciest bbq in the world but it does the job admirably smile

Edited by weLex on Wednesday 30th July 13:59

juice

9,934 posts

313 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
BoXtaPete said:
Having had several gas barbeques, including some 'so called' premium brands, I have to say I'm quite disappointed with them all as far as the build quality is concerned. I have found that after 2 years - of quite extensive use - they are falling apart. Whatever the brand, I find it is not easy to get replacement parts, so eventually I get so p**sed off, I go and buy another, and so the whole roundabout starts again.

I would really like to buy something that will last for many years, that can live outside all the year and be used every week of the year. I have been told that Napoleon are very good, Canadian, and totally made in Canada, whereas the majority are Far East made. Do any PHers have any experience of these, or any recommendations?
I have a Brinkmann Stainless 4 burner, and its been exposed conditions that are ideal for inducing tin-rot - constant high humidity between 70-100% every day of the year. It's *just* showing signs of surface rust on the various bolts/screws but the frame and body are still perfect after a year sat outside, covered. Definitely recommend one.

Would get some CorrosionX and cover EVERYTHING with it, when you come to bolt it together though. It's about 8 quid for a can, but its absolutley superb as a rust inhibitor.

http://www.buycorrosionx.com/ccp1-prodshow/cx90102...

RVVUNM

1,913 posts

240 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
weLex said:
I use a three burner outback hunter, its about seven years old and the only thing I've had to do to it is replace the rusty cast iron grills with new porcelain coated ones smile

Its not the fanciest bbq in the world but it does the job admirably smile

Edited by weLex on Wednesday 30th July 13:59
I have an Outback and it's brillient.....It's all about the burner you know!

jesusbuiltmycar

5,142 posts

285 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
Sharief said:
WTF? Your neighbours complained about smoke from a BBQ? Jesus. Sorry can't help with finding your BBQ but that's ridiculous! Love the smell of a BBQ in the summer. lick
yes I'd be buying a bigger charcoal one.
What is the point in a gas BBQ? surely it is exactly the same as using a gas to fry the food???

One trick a chef friend of mine does is to place a frying pan containing olive oil, garlic and rosemary on the grill whilst the charcoal is heating up - it produces a lovely smell to encourage appetite (and make the neighbours jealous...)

TEKNOPUG

20,502 posts

236 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Agreed - does seem a little pointless to me. All you are doing is dragging you cooker out of the kitchen and plonking it in the garden, with an extended gas pipe. You can get smokeless charcoal you know?

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
TEKNOPUG said:
Agreed - does seem a little pointless to me. All you are doing is dragging you cooker out of the kitchen and plonking it in the garden, with an extended gas pipe. You can get smokeless charcoal you know?
I thought charcoal was smokeless? Maybe the OP burns his sausages? smile

Seight_Returns

Original Poster:

1,640 posts

232 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
TEKNOPUG said:
Agreed - does seem a little pointless to me. All you are doing is dragging you cooker out of the kitchen and plonking it in the garden, with an extended gas pipe. You can get smokeless charcoal you know?
Yeah I know. Giving up my beloved Brinkmann Smoke-n-pitt BBQ will be like giving up part of my soul. Here's the background.

Smokeless charcoal won't hack it. The problem is one of perception and has little to do with reality, in their weird little world grilling a couple of burgers trice a week equates to running a full on smokery on my patio.

Needs must.