Hacker loses extradition appeal
Hacker loses extradition appeal
Author
Discussion

beanbag

Original Poster:

7,346 posts

272 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/7532713.stm

I've been following this story a little as and when articles appear in BBC News.

Frankly I think it serves him right. He seems like an arrogant tosser who probably thought he above everyone else and he got caught.

I wonder what the Americans will do to him...??? scratchchin

scotal

8,751 posts

310 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
beanbag said:
I wonder what the Americans will do to him...??? scratchchin
If he refuses to co-operate they'll do him on terrorism charges and could lock him up until he's 102.
If he co-operates, he gets a lesser charge, max sentence of 46 months..... I'd go with that if I were him.

If he's any good then m,aybe they'll offer him a job working on secuuirty systems for NASA..... that being said they did catch him.

Nic Jones

7,190 posts

251 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
I read an article about him a few years back in FHM about what he used to do and how he was caught.

It was very interesting, but he knew the risks when he did it so I think it's a fair cop guv'.

Eric Mc

125,920 posts

296 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Did he know the risks though?

Especially as the law was changed in more recent yeras allowing the US to extradite UK citizens to the US without having to preesent much in the way of evidence to UK courts. The UK CPS looked at his case here and decided that he hadn't broken any UK laws.

Whether he did anything wrong or not is not the issue in this case. What's more important is the ease with which the UK legal system is prepared to hand individuals over to the US to answer charges which would not be enforceable in the UK.
I bet that a US citizen would not be handed over to the UK in the same circumstances.

philthy

4,697 posts

271 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Sounds like the usual American sledgehammer nutcracker.
I would have thought that they would be better off working with him. Better to be on the inside pissing out, than on the outside pissing in?
Bear in mind of course that American officialdom never "stretches" the truth, he is obviously a very dangerous man rolleyes

Gingerbread Man

9,173 posts

244 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
They did catch him, but he did leave notes on their computers saying how crap their security is!!


He's committed a crime so he should go to jail, but I can't see it being for very long. They should use him. He's obviously very good at what he does this trate should be used.

They should offer him less jail time if he comes to work with them.


I don't see why he should be put away for tens of years like it has been suggested. He's not that dangerous. He didn't kill anyone and it seems there is talk of him going to jail for as long a stretch as a murder.

If he was indeed looking for UFO's, then as odd an obsession as it is, it's pretty harmless. But if he was routing around doing other non-UFO things, then I'm sure he could have found out many secrets that he shouldn't have.

Was there not talk of him deleting some files?


Duke Thrust

1,680 posts

270 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Given their well published lack of sense of humour, I'd think twice about messing about with the American government/military/NASA computers.

He's clearly a bright chap, he must have realised the consequences if he got caught - bang to rights I think.

If you can't do the time...



Cara Van Man

29,977 posts

282 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Why don't the idiots offer him a job if he is the best in the world?

FFS, people just can't see an opportunity in front of them.

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Artice said:
The US government claims he committed a malicious crime - the biggest military computer hack ever.


They shouldn't arrest him, they should give him a job.


spikeyhead

20,639 posts

228 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Serves the septics right for having computers with sensitive stuff on connected to the interweb.

Eric Mc

125,920 posts

296 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Duke Thrust said:
Given their well published lack of sense of humour, I'd think twice about messing about with the American government/military/NASA computers.

He's clearly a bright chap, he must have realised the consequences if he got caught - bang to rights I think.

If you can't do the time...
I don't think the current laws were in place at the time the offences were alleged to have happened. The offences date back over 8 years.

So, you cannot claim that he "realised the consequences" because those particular consequences weren't part of Federal Law at the time the "crime" was committed.

At what point does a UK citizen become chargeable to US law for a crime that didn't exist at the time the "crime" was alleged to have been committed?

(If I was Gerry Adams I'd be very worried).

Edited by Eric Mc on Wednesday 30th July 14:25

MK4 Slowride

10,028 posts

239 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
mickken said:
$150k a year job (an a Corvette ZR1 for his punisment)
Exactly, I mean what better car and pay packet to have when your young and want to experiment with mind altering drugs and impress the ladies.wink

sniff petrol

13,128 posts

243 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Like Frank Abignale they should have employed him.

Blue Meanie

73,668 posts

286 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Did he know the risks though?

Especially as the law was changed in more recent yeras allowing the US to extradite UK citizens to the US without having to preesent much in the way of evidence to UK courts. The UK CPS looked at his case here and decided that he hadn't broken any UK laws.
If the UK CPS thought he hadn't broken any laws, why are they extraditing him? I hope this extradition deal is a two way street.

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Blue Meanie said:
I hope this extradition deal is a two way street.
rofl

No it's not.

Blue Meanie

73,668 posts

286 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Marf said:
Blue Meanie said:
I hope this extradition deal is a two way street.
rofl

No it's not.
By that, I mean they can extradite from us, and vice versa

big_rob_sydney

3,671 posts

225 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
He may be a bright spark when it comes to certain facets of IT, but he's really an idiot in other areas.

Why he didnt spoof his IP address, I dont know. Why he didnt use a proxy server, I dont know. Why he didnt just do some wardriving, I dont know.

In the end, he got caught (stupid burke). Now he's going to get squeezed till he rolls over. Dont you worry. The UK sold him out to their masters, he'll be a very lucky boy if he gets out any time soon.

clonmult

10,529 posts

240 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
spikeyhead said:
Serves the septics right for having computers with sensitive stuff on connected to the interweb.
And in half of the cases (at least), without any passwords, or just default/system passwords.

They had chronic security problems, and if that had been addressed at the outset, he would have had a much harder time of getting in there.

I thought he was just looking for proof of aliens and Area 51 type stuff though?

Eric Mc

125,920 posts

296 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Blue Meanie said:
Eric Mc said:
Did he know the risks though?

Especially as the law was changed in more recent yeras allowing the US to extradite UK citizens to the US without having to preesent much in the way of evidence to UK courts. The UK CPS looked at his case here and decided that he hadn't broken any UK laws.
If the UK CPS thought he hadn't broken any laws, why are they extraditing him? I hope this extradition deal is a two way street.
Beacuse he doesn't need to have broken any laws for this extradition to be successful.

The CPS only has jursidiction in regards to UK law.

This extradition treaty allows the US to essentially demand that ANY UK citizen they want to interview and/or charge can be sent to the US even if they have not broken any UK laws and are not wanted or are not even a suspect in the UK. The US authorities are under no obligation to provide any of their evidence against the individual to the UK courts who, in effect, now have no authority to refuse US extradition requests.

It is a dreadful piece of legislation and my interpretation is that the Law Lords today found that their hands were tied when it came to this appeal.

And it is a fact that a US citizen wanted to face charges in the UK will NOT be extradited to the UK UNLESS the UK CPS can present a valid case to a US judge.

Edited by Eric Mc on Wednesday 30th July 14:58

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Blue Meanie said:
Marf said:
Blue Meanie said:
I hope this extradition deal is a two way street.
rofl

No it's not.
By that, I mean they can extradite from us, and vice versa
No, the agreement through which he is being extradited is wholly one sided in favour of the septics. The one sided nature of the agreement formed a part of his initial appeal.

edit: just saw erics post, that explains it all

Edited by Marf on Wednesday 30th July 14:57