Concrete question
Author
Discussion

Shaolin

Original Poster:

2,955 posts

220 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
My garage floor is made of particularly friable concrete. If I brush it vigorously with a hard broom it starts to fall to bits, not like loose gravel, but each sweep loosens another bit, I'm sure if I brushed long enough and energetically enough, I'd be down to earth.

So what do I do about it? (I think it dates back to the age of the house, about 60 years). Can I overlay it with proper concrete? I think it would be starightforwards to do this to a depth of about 3-4" making a slope on the way in. Or do I need to break it all up and shift it out before re-laying as a couple of mates have said? Or is there some other magical solution that I don't know about?

Morpeth

666 posts

226 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
If you lay on top of the existing you will form a raft, that could be subject to movement. Best do what your mates suggest and break the existing, stick in some dolomite and pour a new floor.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
scabble it down and relay it with a minimum thickness of 30mm

there are additives you can add which will harden it, worth sealing it too once it's cured (give it a few months) to keep the dust down

AndrewTait

1,849 posts

225 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Concrete takes tens of years to set (I seem to remember its about 20 years), and then starts to breakdown, and disintegrate. This is what happens with motorway bridges and the old concrete carriageways, and why they need repairing/replacing. I would suspect this is what is happening in your garage.

I would personally break it up, and re-lay it. However, it can be covered over, and used as a foundation for the new floor. However, eventually, your new floor will collapse, as the degrading of the old concrete continues.

slow_poke

1,855 posts

265 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Tile it.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
AndrewTait said:
Concrete takes tens of years to set (I seem to remember its about 20 years), and then starts to breakdown, and disintegrate. This is what happens with motorway bridges and the old concrete carriageways, and why they need repairing/replacing. I would suspect this is what is happening in your garage.

I would personally break it up, and re-lay it. However, it can be covered over, and used as a foundation for the new floor. However, eventually, your new floor will collapse, as the degrading of the old concrete continues.
there are concrete structure hundreds of years old that are still standing...

allegro

1,344 posts

235 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Morpeth said:
stick in some dolomite
i didnt realise triumphs made good hardcore smile

Darkslider

3,084 posts

220 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
allegro said:
Morpeth said:
stick in some dolomite
i didnt realise triumphs made good hardcore smile
Not good for much else really are they? laugh

[/canofworms]

AndrewTait

1,849 posts

225 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
AndrewTait said:
Concrete takes tens of years to set (I seem to remember its about 20 years), and then starts to breakdown, and disintegrate. This is what happens with motorway bridges and the old concrete carriageways, and why they need repairing/replacing. I would suspect this is what is happening in your garage.

I would personally break it up, and re-lay it. However, it can be covered over, and used as a foundation for the new floor. However, eventually, your new floor will collapse, as the degrading of the old concrete continues.
there are concrete structure hundreds of years old that are still standing...
I agree, but they take some considerable looking after.

hugoagogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
AndrewTait said:
Concrete takes tens of years to set (I seem to remember its about 20 years), and then starts to breakdown, and disintegrate. This is what happens with motorway bridges and the old concrete carriageways, and why they need repairing/replacing. I would suspect this is what is happening in your garage.

I would personally break it up, and re-lay it. However, it can be covered over, and used as a foundation for the new floor. However, eventually, your new floor will collapse, as the degrading of the old concrete continues.
there are concrete structure hundreds of years old that are still standing...
thousands
the romans made loads of stuff with it

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
hugoagogo said:
sleep envy said:
AndrewTait said:
Concrete takes tens of years to set (I seem to remember its about 20 years), and then starts to breakdown, and disintegrate. This is what happens with motorway bridges and the old concrete carriageways, and why they need repairing/replacing. I would suspect this is what is happening in your garage.

I would personally break it up, and re-lay it. However, it can be covered over, and used as a foundation for the new floor. However, eventually, your new floor will collapse, as the degrading of the old concrete continues.
there are concrete structure hundreds of years old that are still standing...
thousands
the romans made loads of stuff with it
that's who I was thinking of, worlds biggest single span concrete roof is over 2k years old

Edited by sleep envy on Wednesday 30th July 22:56

Shaolin

Original Poster:

2,955 posts

220 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
I think the longevity depends on the recipe used, the Romans must have used lots of cement and relatively little sand and gravel, whereas my garage floor was was the economy version I suspect.

Slow Poke - was that a serious suggestion? If so, any details of what kind of tiles? I have considered using large paving slabs, the cheap but strong compressed concrete type.

hemibum

833 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Me'n the lads are down your way next week. Through a Council oversight we've got 3 tons of asphalt that'll do nicely. Cash only, no reciepts.cool

Shaolin

Original Poster:

2,955 posts

220 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Throw in a dozen pegs and the job's a good 'un.

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
There are resin repair/screed systems that will give a very tough, high-quality surface. Not especially cheap, but they'll solve the problem once and for all.

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Assuming the depth won't cause a problem Id give it a sweep, a coat of PVA (mix 30% PVA/70% water) lay down some chicken wire and pour a new 4" concrete floor. Just because the surface is crumbly doesnt mean it is not a well compacted and solid base for a new floor.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Sam_68 said:
There are resin repair/screed systems that will give a very tough, high-quality surface. Not especially cheap, but they'll solve the problem once and for all.
have you used that system on spalling concrete?

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
Sam_68 said:
There are resin repair/screed systems that will give a very tough, high-quality surface. Not especially cheap, but they'll solve the problem once and for all.
have you used that system on spalling concrete?
Wot no mention of PVA?

You're slipping...

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
You're slipping...
much like your bonding and renderingwink

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
have you used that system on spalling concrete?
Not that particular system, but I've used resin repair systems on my garage floor in the past, yes.

They're expensive, but if used correctly the finish is superb (the main reason I went for one was to give a perfectly level floor for setting up race car suspension on); no more annoying dust and spills are easy to clean up, too.

Edited by Sam_68 on Wednesday 30th July 23:15