What sized breaker for my garage lights?
What sized breaker for my garage lights?
Author
Discussion

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
I just wired up the last two twin flouros, making it six five foot doubles in their now. All on one 6 amp breaker, but on three switches, two per switch.

I switched the new ones on and they worked great, but when I turned all lights on together the breaker popped after 30 seconds. It has worked perfectly for six months with four double units, but has adding the last two pushed the breaker over the edge?

They're 58 watt tubes. The breaker is currently a 6 amp. There is also a RCB for the whole garage, so I don't think I've codged the wiring up. All but these last two were inspected when my nephew signed off the Part P stuff a few months back, and I have just run wire to them from a terminal box that was already in there.

The two latest additions will run okay if just they are switched on.

Do I need a bigger breaker, or could there be something else wrong?


cjs

11,718 posts

282 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
So you have 12 x Tubes at 58w?? That's 696w total load which is just over 3 amps. So a 6 amp breaker should be okay. Looks like there is something wrong, I would disconnect the newer lights one at a time to see if that helps. Maybe you have a dodgy breaker, try changing that?

john_p

7,073 posts

281 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
Do those lights draw more current when they start up?

cjs

11,718 posts

282 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
john_p said:
Do those lights draw more current when they start up?
Could be the total load on switch on however the OP said the breaker trips after 30 seconds.

Edited by cjs on Thursday 31st July 08:50

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
cjs said:
john_p said:
Do those lights draw more current when they start up?
Could be the total load on switch on however the OP said the breaker trips after 30 seconds.
I just went out for another test run, and the main lights stayed on okay for 30 minutes, then I remembered there are three x double 24" 'bathroom' flouros in the garage loft as well, on the same circuit. I turned those on and it popped the breaker in 20 seconds or so.

I'm not sure what the wattage is on the 'bathroom' flouros, as they have a cover over them so I don't bust them when I bang my head on 'em. I'd guess about 18 to 24 watts per tube?


GnuBee

1,339 posts

246 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
amps = watts/volts

So add the wattage up of all the tubes, any other power drain on the circuit and divide by this by 220 and you'll end up with a figure for the current drain which is what your CB should be slightly above.

Given that the CB is tripping after a period of time it doesn't sound like it's startup current which is the issue.

If you do the calculation and find you're safely within the limits of the current CB then you've either got a fault in your wiring or fixtures or possible a dodgy CB.

Silverbullet767

11,373 posts

237 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
I would say a 15A should be fine.

I believe the capacity of 1.5mm cable is about 19-20A

PH5121

2,007 posts

244 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
1.5mm twin & earth cable will carry 20 amps if it is surface clipped.
When calculating load you have to make an allowance for the consumption of the control gear.6no 2x58w lamp fittings will take more than 700w. If the fittings have high frequency electronic ballasts the extra load will be lesser than if they are switch start fittings.

Before installing a 16 amp mcb try a 10 amp type c. You may have a 6 amp b, a type c is better suited to an inductive load like fluorescent lamps.


Edited by PH5121 on Thursday 31st July 11:52


Edited by PH5121 on Thursday 31st July 11:56

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
PH5121 said:
1.5mm twin & earth cable will carry 20 amps if it is surface clipped.
When calculating load you have to make an allowance for the consumption of the control gear.6no 2x58w lamp fittings will take more than 700w. If the fittings have high frequency electronic ballasts the extra load will be lesser than if they are switch start fittings.

Before installing a 16 amp mcb try a 10 amp type c. You may have a 6 amp b, a type c is better suited to an inductive load like fluorescent lamps.
Thanks for the info. I'll have a look and see exactly what I have in there, as there are about five spares that aren't in use I may be able to plunder.