2 Sat Nav Questions
Author
Discussion

Buster Bakdorzin

Original Poster:

16,277 posts

296 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
There was a cover story on the front of a newspaper within the last few weeks, which reported that a certain number of accidents and one way wrong turns were attributable to sat nav systems, some incorrect instructions, others due to not enough attention given to the road ahead. Does anyone remember which paper, or have a link?

Another question - have any of the companies who provide the map data (Navtec and Teleatlas?) or sat nav brand owners (tom tom etc) yet been prosecuted for any accidents or deaths caused by wrong turns, and whatnot.

Thanks in advance bow

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
every SATNAV has a disclaimer saying obey the law this is a driver aid etc basically absolving themselves of blame when a genius turns left onto the railway line head on with a train.

Doobs

736 posts

281 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
Well I was in a seaside location (visiting family) on Sunday and the traffic was appaling. I missed a turn I needed so went to the next roundabout and came back the other way. Only problem was from that direction it was no left turn mad
I checked for traffic and thought "There's no way I'm going to queue for another half hour just so I can turn down this side road from the other direction, so I nipped round hoping no rozzers were on the prowl (Tony Soprano look and learn - I could write a rap song about it). If I had been stopped you can bet your grandma's winter fuel payments that I would have blamed it on the sat nav. Just because it gets blamed doesn't mean it's true!

Gad-Westy

16,658 posts

244 months

Rags

3,676 posts

267 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
Sat Nav is just a guide, if you are retarded enough to drive into a wall because it says so or into oncoming traffic, then its your own stupidity.

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
Rags said:
Sat Nav is just a guide, if you are retarded enough to drive into a wall because it says so or into oncoming traffic, then its your own stupidity.
Bingo.

Wall, River, too small a road etc.. or even under a bridge.

Sat Nav does not replace eyeballs and common sense.

Leccy

481 posts

222 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
Buster Bakdorzin said:
There was a cover story on the front of a newspaper within the last few weeks, which reported that a certain number of accidents and one way wrong turns were attributable to sat nav systems, some incorrect instructions, others due to not enough attention given to the road ahead. Does anyone remember which paper, or have a link?

Another question - have any of the companies who provide the map data (Navtec and Teleatlas?) or sat nav brand owners (tom tom etc) yet been prosecuted for any accidents or deaths caused by wrong turns, and whatnot.

Thanks in advance bow
I sent a reply before but it doesn't seem to have come through.

Why on Earth should a mapping or satnav company be prosecuted for some fkwit turning into a no entry road? Anyone who does such a thing and uses the 'satnav made me do it' excuse, should be prosecuted for driving without due care and attention.

randomman

2,215 posts

220 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
I think sat navs are great, I really do. But I dont think anything else should be invented that takes responsibilty off the driver, every time something is more and more retards take to the road with the inevitable effects

Buster Bakdorzin

Original Poster:

16,277 posts

296 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
Thats the one!
Cheers, many thanks.

Jasandjules said:
Rags said:
Sat Nav is just a guide, if you are retarded enough to drive into a wall because it says so or into oncoming traffic, then its your own stupidity.
Bingo.

Wall, River, too small a road etc.. or even under a bridge.

Sat Nav does not replace eyeballs and common sense.
Absolutely. Although it wouldn't surprise me if someone tried it on.

Uncle Fester

3,114 posts

239 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
The problem comes when sat nav gives last minute instructions or confusing instructions.

I got CoPilot sat nav free with my mobile phone. So I didn’t sign anything to say I accepted liability and even if I had then what if my wife was driving?

It gives instructions like “in 500 yards take the left exit” the trouble is that it’s measuring to the give way line at the bottom of a motorway slip road.

If the slip road is 500 yards long this can cause people to make last minute manoeuvres. In some cases you have missed the slip altogether.

I had TomTom on the last PDA. That gave stupid directions. It would come up with a route taking me onto a motorway via an emergency vehicles only slip. Then it would disagree with itself. The map would show taking the second exit; the voice would say the take the third exit. It sometimes counts on-ramps as exits. I gave up sending TomTom feedback. Their website solicits feedback that they ignore and don't update the maps.

We have also have Garmin, the navigation is the best of the bunch, but the interface is often harder to get what you want than the TomTom.


Simpo Two

93,078 posts

296 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
More than that, if you're fiddling with the satnav and have an accident, it's driving without due care etc. Like any in-car gadget you have to use it intelligently.

Leccy

481 posts

222 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
Uncle Fester said:
The problem comes when sat nav gives last minute instructions or confusing instructions.

I got CoPilot sat nav free with my mobile phone. So I didn’t sign anything to say I accepted liability and even if I had then what if my wife was driving?
You accepted liability, as did your wife, for your driving as soon as you turned the engine on.
If you go the wrong way up a street are go onto a motorway through an emergency vehicles only road, you are liable. Not the satnav, not Garmin, not TomTom, nor anyone else.