First bike - naked 600 - choices?
First bike - naked 600 - choices?
Author
Discussion

Pierscoe1

Original Poster:

2,458 posts

292 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
Hi all...

My DAS is approaching, and once it's out the way (hopefully as stress-free as possible), I'll be after a bike, obviously! biggrin

I'd like a naked 600, and so far this has led me to either:

'07 Hornet (1st choice but still very expensive ,~£4.5k)
'03+ FZ6 (some issues keep cropping up in reviews, ~£3k)
'06 GSR600 (dodgy fueling + forks?, ~£3k)
'05+ ER6-n (down on power compared to the inline-fours, ~£3k)

So... I'd love to hear from the magical PH'er who's owned and extensively ridden all of the above! :P
(or, more realistically, anyone who's ridden any of them, and has some comments to offer)

Ideally I'd go for the 07 Hornet, but I can't help thinking it's a bit unwise to spend so much cash on a first bike, that I'm likely to drop at some point!
Unfortunately, all the reviews I've found generally seem to say "Buy the hornet - it's miles better than all the others".. which is particularly frustrating!! biggrin

thanks in advance for ANY tips/info/suggestions/opinions etc etc... all greatfully recieved!

Nimbus

1,176 posts

259 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
Just my thoughts, but why are you looking for something so new / expensive ?

I'd be looking at naked bandit / sv650s, around the £1000-1500 mark.

Cheap insurance to get you going, resale wont be a killer, and you wont be gutted if you do drop it..

Best of all, if you wait a year, then get a nearly new Hornet, you'll save loads, someone will have done the boring running in bit, and you'll appreciate how much better it is than your bandit.. smile


Sossige

3,176 posts

294 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
I love my Hornet.

Sorry, I'm not helping am I? biggrin

Soss

Pierscoe1

Original Poster:

2,458 posts

292 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
because I really am not keen on the old-school looks of hte SV and bandit...

I know it may seem silly... but I want a bike I really want if you know what I mean... I'm doing the sensible thing by convincing myself out of spending £4.5k+ on an 07 Hornet, after allwink

thanks for the input though..

I do keep re-looking at the SV, just to see if I can persuade myself to realy like it.

Dudd

964 posts

223 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
What about a Ducati Monster? thats what I'd...

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
Dudd said:
What about a Ducati Monster? thats what I'd...
That's what I did... and unless you're going to ride it every day it'll be a temperamental bugger. And it's not the best first bike IMO... mine had a grabby clutch which, combined with V-twin torque and beginner-rider incompetence, resulted in accidental wheelies every so often. I was *very* lucky I didn't ride straight over the top of some poor bugger's car once hehe

Now my old CBR600, first sports bike... different story. Old as nails compared to the (brand new) Ducati, but smoother, easier to ride, easier to control, and a stload faster.

So if you definitely want naked, gotta be the Hornet. Sorry mate. Why not get an older one, they made Hornets ages ago remember...

Nimbus

1,176 posts

259 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
Pierscoe1 said:
because I really am not keen on the old-school looks of hte SV and bandit...

I know it may seem silly... but I want a bike I really want if you know what I mean... I'm doing the sensible thing by convincing myself out of spending £4.5k+ on an 07 Hornet, after allwink

thanks for the input though..

I do keep re-looking at the SV, just to see if I can persuade myself to realy like it.
No fair enough smile you need to 'want' your bike otherwise it's just another 'white good'...

I'm not massive on nakeds, but I do like the look of the FZ6s, mind last time I was in Abingdon Honda, the new hornets looked pretty good too....

oh...err. that's not helping is it...wink

Graham

16,381 posts

315 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
Dudd said:
What about a Ducati Monster? thats what I'd...
yes

Thats what I did... 695 monster... you can pick them up new for 4.5 the new model the 696 is about another 1k

1400 miles in and I think its a fantastic first bike.. plenty of poke if you want to give it some beans and loads of torque to pootle around with the rest of the time.. the later models have a light clutch action and a slipper clutch which takes the stress out of the odd clumsy down change... 07 on models have longer service intervals than older models and a much less tetchy reliability record..

on and imho they look cool and sound great...



Edited by Graham on Monday 11th August 21:51

Pierscoe1

Original Poster:

2,458 posts

292 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
cyberface said:
So if you definitely want naked, gotta be the Hornet. Sorry mate. Why not get an older one, they made Hornets ages ago remember...
'cos the older Hornets have the same retro (read OLD-looking) round headlight (that looks like it came off a Morris Minor), that's exactly why I'm not keen on the SV and Bandit... biggrin

I'm picky I know, but as you say.. no point shelling out £2k let alone £4k on something you don't WANT....

Anybody have experience of the ER6-n ??
It's modern looking (and I know, slightly odd-looking too), and gets some great reviews.. especially is respect to it's rider-friendlyness for newbies. A bit down on power compared the the 4-cylinder bikes, but I think 70bhp would still be plenty for a year or two... I think they look pretty good in the all-black colour combo:

sprinter885

11,550 posts

258 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
Well I had to come on after that post above ! yep I have an ER6 (black/gold frame) and tho' I've had other, bigger more powerful stuff the ER6 has been the most rideable, fun bike.
Try one they really are a surprise. They commute, potter around town, not heavy & still sound nice when given the beans out on the open.
OK suspension is probably a bit more budget than maybe a Hornet & I'm sure not Honda build quality but it does me well. I'm 5'8" weigh (13.5 st)too much and have no trouble keeping with a pal on 07 Hornet (with VERY tasty sounding Akrapovic full system)
The power characteristics are different being parallel twin not IL4 but it means you can motor on with only top 2/3 gears.

If you intend using in all weathers and/or cannot dry store it probably go Honda-it'll weather better but as said loads of times on here TRY 'EM ALL & pick the one that's right for you.

Best of luck.
p.s. Piers-you should get a lot newer ER6 than '05 for your 3K -maybe '07

Edited by sprinter885 on Tuesday 12th August 09:27

phillvr6

3,785 posts

291 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
Have a look at a Kawasaki Z750, thats what I had for a 1st bike and it was great.

Nimbus

1,176 posts

259 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
phillvr6 said:
Have a look at a Kawasaki Z750, thats what I had for a 1st bike and it was great.
Indeed, I've just been at the local shop dropping my bandit off for its new exhaust system, and they had 2 very nice looking Z750s in, one in electric blue, that seemed to be an 'S' model, with a bigger fairing, and a full on proper naked Z750 in red... very nice, and tempting smile

Phil C

436 posts

306 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
I test rode FZ6, GSX650 and Bandit 650 (with fairing). Ended up with the Bandit (faired) due to value for money (4.2K brand new), ABS and the fuelling seemed less snatchy than the Yam..... but pays your money I guess..... I have heard nothing but good reviews of the Hornet tho'. Only downside seems to be fuel tank range. Whatever you do, don't 'talk yourself' into a particular bike - you only regret it and sell it sooner rather than later....

Good hunting.

John Laverick

2,002 posts

245 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
Trust me ... once you’ve passed your test and you’re hooning about, what the bike looks like will be the last of your concerns!!

If it were me I’d get an older Hornet, a mate just sold a nice one with about 10k on a ‘Y’ I think for about £1700. Bargain I reckon ... I rode it a few times and thought it was lovely!

StevRS

443 posts

240 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
Having very limited experience, I can't see the attraction of nakeds - they're hard work above 50mph!!!

You considered anything with a bit of wind protection so you don't have to hang on as tight?

Graham

16,381 posts

315 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
StevRS said:
Having very limited experience, I can't see the attraction of nakeds - they're hard work above xxmph!!!

You considered anything with a bit of wind protection so you don't have to hang on as tight?
I've not noticed it much of a problem on mine, although i do have the small front wind fairing..

even at double the quoted figure its been fine although the longest I've kept that up is probably 40 miles in one go.. The Monster has a more forward riding position than lots of nakeds so maybe that helps ?

Its only when there are cross winds that it gets a bit uncomfy, and not having ridden a fully faired bike, im not sure how it compares

John Laverick

2,002 posts

245 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
2
Graham said:
StevRS said:
Having very limited experience, I can't see the attraction of nakeds - they're hard work above xxmph!!!

You considered anything with a bit of wind protection so you don't have to hang on as tight?
I've not noticed it much of a problem on mine, although i do have the small front wind fairing..

even at double the quoted figure its been fine although the longest I've kept that up is probably 40 miles in one go.. The Monster has a more forward riding position than lots of nakeds so maybe that helps ?

Its only when there are cross winds that it gets a bit uncomfy, and not having ridden a fully faired bike, im not sure how it compares
Only ridden one naked [my mate's Hornet] and at anything above abuot 85mph it was very hard work due to buffeting. 100mph+ was not possible for more than about 30 seconds!!

Graham

16,381 posts

315 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
John Laverick said:
Only ridden one naked [my mate's Hornet] and at anything above abuot 85mph it was very hard work due to buffeting. 100mph+ was not possible for more than about 30 seconds!!
Thats what I was expecting, and quote surprised that it wasnt that bad. as I said though very different if there is a blustery crosswind...

robstvr

3,217 posts

299 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
You can get a 05/06 Hornet for about 3K, and they are just great, do everything bikes. Hassle free, perfect learner. I've done 20K on mine in 18 months. New tyres, servicing, that's it!

Rich_AR

1,998 posts

235 months

Tuesday 12th August 2008
quotequote all
Pick up an older Hornet 600. I've just got one up as my 2nd bike (had 12 months gap from riding). Ideally I wanted a sports 600 (CBR600RR), but with the weather been poop and winter looming! I opted for a easier riding postion and a bike I wasnt bothered about getting wet, plus get me used to riding again (didn't take long) Ok its not the best looking, but like mentioned above, I'm not fused when hooning around and trying to hang off like a chimp, its the last thing on my mind!

Anyway, I got a 02 plate, black, very tidy, 11k, loads of extras for £1700! Bargain tastic!



Edited by Rich_AR on Tuesday 12th August 15:38


Edited by Rich_AR on Tuesday 12th August 15:39