Looks like even the bad guys' data isn't safe
Looks like even the bad guys' data isn't safe
Author
Discussion

esselte

Original Poster:

14,626 posts

297 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
More data lost

Do those people that are in favour of ID cards still think "If you've nothing to hide you've nothing to fear"?

Edited by esselte on Thursday 21st August 22:17

spikeyhead

20,558 posts

227 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
I'm amazed that this information is ever held anywhere without being encrypted.

There's enough encryption methods out there that would defeat all but the most determined. It should never be on a memory stick in an unencrypted form.

And the government still says that data for an ID card system will be perfectly safe with them, Yeah right. Twunts, the lot of them

Zeek

882 posts

234 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
I was just telling Mrs Z, how many people who are against ID cards have stuffed their entire pathetic lives on facebook or one of the other privately owned databases sitting out there for everyone to see!

Not to mention those who refuse an ID card, but are happy to carry a card telling the owners of supermarkets everything they buy, where they buy it from, how much they spend on it, and how often!

esselte

Original Poster:

14,626 posts

297 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
Zeek said:
I was just telling Mrs Z, how many people who are against ID cards have stuffed their entire pathetic lives on facebook or one of the other privately owned databases sitting out there for everyone to see!

Not to mention those who refuse an ID card, but are happy to carry a card telling the owners of supermarkets everything they buy, where they buy it from, how much they spend on it, and how often!
The difference is choice I suppose....

Zeek

882 posts

234 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
Zeek said:
I was just telling Mrs Z, how many people who are against ID cards have stuffed their entire pathetic lives on facebook or one of the other privately owned databases sitting out there for everyone to see!

Not to mention those who refuse an ID card, but are happy to carry a card telling the owners of supermarkets everything they buy, where they buy it from, how much they spend on it, and how often!
The difference is choice I suppose....
I agree. I'm not condoning them, but it makes the argument against an ID card from someone who tells the world what they had for breakfast and with whom a bit pointless.

DRIFT KING

172 posts

219 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
Yes but the supermarkets will give you coupons based on the products you buy often. And they don't lose things like the govt do. It seems like it is fashionable in the Home Office to lose things...

Zeek

882 posts

234 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
DRIFT KING said:
...And they don't lose things like the govt do.
You think?!smile

esselte

Original Poster:

14,626 posts

297 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
Zeek said:
DRIFT KING said:
...And they don't lose things like the govt do.
You think?!smile
To be honest I'm not bothered if someone finds out that I like a bacon buttie for my Saturday morning brekkie......

DRIFT KING

172 posts

219 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
lol smile

Zeek

882 posts

234 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
Zeek said:
DRIFT KING said:
...And they don't lose things like the govt do.
You think?!smile
To be honest I'm not bothered if someone finds out that I like a bacon buttie for my Saturday morning brekkie......
Or how much you spent on it? Or where you were when you bought it? Where you've travelled in the UK? What you ate with it? How much you spent on petrol to get there? How much your car insurance was?

It isn't just what items you bought. There are hundreds of places that accept these same loyalty cards these days, and some people even link them to their bank accounts and credit cards! I've had a good look at the Tesco Clubcard database, and it is a entrance into an awesome collection of data about a large proportion of people in the country. Very clever, and very useful!

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

239 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
Why TF do these Gov't offices need to put data on memory sticks and laptops etc anyway?

Secure data should not be allowed to be copied to a medium where it could be lost or misused.


esselte

Original Poster:

14,626 posts

297 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
Zeek said:
esselte said:
Zeek said:
DRIFT KING said:
...And they don't lose things like the govt do.
You think?!smile
To be honest I'm not bothered if someone finds out that I like a bacon buttie for my Saturday morning brekkie......
Or how much you spent on it? Or where you were when you bought it? Where you've travelled in the UK? What you ate with it? How much you spent on petrol to get there? How much your car insurance was?

It isn't just what items you bought. There are hundreds of places that accept these same loyalty cards these days, and some people even link them to their bank accounts and credit cards! I've had a good look at the Tesco Clubcard database, and it is a entrance into an awesome collection of data about a large proportion of people in the country. Very clever, and very useful!
The price of bacon isn't a secret. I only use a loyalty card at one branch of the supermarket...local one so no travel details...no proof where else I shopped so no data as to what I ate with it (even if they did find out I don't think HP sauce is a major problem...smile.supermarket petrol..pah! Don't do supermarket insurance..I have no issue with loyalty cards because they are optional...a National ID card however.....

Edited by esselte on Thursday 21st August 22:51

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

292 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
Why TF do these Gov't offices need to put data on memory sticks and laptops etc anyway?

Secure data should not be allowed to be copied to a medium where it could be lost or misused.
Yes indeed the really BIG question is just where are the checks and restrictions to control "anybody" plugging their stick in and loading it up in the first place.

Zeek

882 posts

234 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
Zeek said:
esselte said:
Zeek said:
DRIFT KING said:
...And they don't lose things like the govt do.
You think?!smile
To be honest I'm not bothered if someone finds out that I like a bacon buttie for my Saturday morning brekkie......
Or how much you spent on it? Or where you were when you bought it? Where you've travelled in the UK? What you ate with it? How much you spent on petrol to get there? How much your car insurance was?

It isn't just what items you bought. There are hundreds of places that accept these same loyalty cards these days, and some people even link them to their bank accounts and credit cards! I've had a good look at the Tesco Clubcard database, and it is a entrance into an awesome collection of data about a large proportion of people in the country. Very clever, and very useful!
The price of bacon isn't a secret. I only use a loyalty card at one branch of the supermarket...local one so no travel details...no proof where else I shopped so no data as to what I ate with it (even if they did find out I don't think HP sauce is a major problem...smile.supermarket petrol..pah! Don't do supermarket insurance..I have no issue with loyalty cards because they are optional...a National ID card however.....

Edited by esselte on Thursday 21st August 22:51
I don't want an ID card either, but then I also choose not to have a facebook profile where I tell strangers who my family and friends are, when I see them, what I do, where I go, work etc etcsmile

In theory, huge databases of products you buy are no issue. Until you start appearing on the reports of customers who buy X number of units of alcohol a week, X number of cigarettes etcsmile



Edited by Zeek on Thursday 21st August 22:56

DRIFT KING

172 posts

219 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
I would advise against linking supermarket clubcards etc. with your bank accounts but I don't mind my shopping habits being monitored. In fact I have a Tesco clubcard and the advantage is that

YOU GET
COUPONS smile

It saves you money and clubcard is free.

National ID cards cost the tax payer money and you don't get coupons.

  • DISCLAIMER: I do not work for Tesco.

Gretchen

19,801 posts

246 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
I've had enough this week of 'security'. I needed a reference number from a Govt dept, after answering six or seven of their idiotic/bizarre security questions. divulging much personal information: full name, full d.o.b. full address, memorable persons name, memorable place, town of birth, favourite ice cream, colour of underwear... I was informed 'We can't give you that information over the phone for security reasons' ARGH!

So phoned another company who I knew would have the number, they can't give it out because sometimes the Government get it wrong(!?!), and they could give me someone elses in error!!

So it's being trusted to the post office, and will arrive in 7-10 days...

And today i've recieved yet another letter regarding someone who is intent on giving my address everytime he jumps the train...
He was due in court on the 6th for several offences, jumped the train again two days later (in fact in court the rep was told this person was actually in prison!) Was told not to worry as nothings been actioned against my address...yet.
Someone somewhere is using my address and various/false names to commit these offences. This has to be one of the plus' for ID cards imo.







sleep envy

62,260 posts

279 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
DRIFT KING said:
I would advise against linking supermarket clubcards etc. with your bank accounts but I don't mind my shopping habits being monitored. In fact I have a Tesco clubcard and the advantage is that

YOU GET
COUPONS smile

It saves you money and clubcard is free.

National ID cards cost the tax payer money and you don't get coupons.

  • DISCLAIMER: I do not work for Tesco.
I hope you pay for your shopping exclusively with cash

DRIFT KING

172 posts

219 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
You are correct

Cash always


DRIFT KING

172 posts

219 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
I don't trust using credit cards with all this card skimming stuff going on. Only use cards in emergencies or unavoidable situations, e.g. I can't pay cash over the phone for insurance or something like that.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

285 months

Thursday 21st August 2008
quotequote all
Good ol' PA Consulting....

Go, boys, go....rofl