R1100S vs VFR800Fi - discuss
R1100S vs VFR800Fi - discuss
Author
Discussion

junglie

Original Poster:

2,052 posts

248 months

Saturday 23rd August 2008
quotequote all
Hi all,

I want to buy a bike that will handle a 100 mile round trip on motorways, comfortable enough for 2 up cruising witht he wife, reliable and also be a bit of fun for those summer rides alone. I know that the VFR 800 is regarded by many as one of the best all round bikes produced but I have also read that the R1100S is, in many situations, equal if not better. Has anyone run both of these bikes and what are your thoughts? Looking to spend around 3000 pounds.

RizzoTheRat

29,143 posts

223 months

Saturday 23rd August 2008
quotequote all
Just to confuse you further...

The Sprint ST is supposed to be the main rival for the VFR, and with the new 1050 version it's quite a bit more power. Other good options for comfort and pillion ability are the taller bikes like the Varadero/Vstrom/TDM/GS/etc.

I took VFR for a test ride when the VTEC first came out. Interesting feeling and change in exhaust note when the extra cams come in at 7000rpm, and pretty quick but not as comfy as my TDM.

xspencex

1,534 posts

267 months

Saturday 23rd August 2008
quotequote all
Isn't the R1100S an outright sports bike... I don't think it's comparible to the VFR which is far more Tour than Sport, What about a K1200RS or an older K1200S.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Saturday 23rd August 2008
quotequote all
VFR every day !!!

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Saturday 23rd August 2008
quotequote all
my R1 handles 200 miles a day impeccably.

Go for one of those, brilliant.

oh you said R1100s...

getmecoat

G Man

4,053 posts

291 months

Saturday 23rd August 2008
quotequote all
junglie said:
Hi all,

I want to buy a bike that will handle a 100 mile round trip on motorways, comfortable enough for 2 up cruising witht he wife, reliable and also be a bit of fun for those summer rides alone. I know that the VFR 800 is regarded by many as one of the best all round bikes produced but I have also read that the R1100S is, in many situations, equal if not better. Has anyone run both of these bikes and what are your thoughts? Looking to spend around 3000 pounds.
On the BMW front the K1200S is your best friend, I do 200 miles a day on mine including 130 miles of motorway
I average 49mph and cruise at 90 leptons

Beemer-5

7,897 posts

245 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
R1100S every time.

fredd1e

783 posts

251 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
If you've never ridden a telelever Bmw flat twin I strongly recommend you do b4 making a decision. Most main bmw dealers have test rides (unlike other brands I could think of) . It may be a revelation or a complete horror but they ain't the same as Japs and only you can make that call.

Eiger120

159 posts

252 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
I bought a VFR at towards the beginning of the year having a very similar requirement! I do a 100 mile commute several times a week and the VFR seemed to tick all the right boxes.

Thoughts so far (imho);
The bike has proved to be utterly reliable, perhaps this should not be a huge surprise as it only had 7000 miles on the clock when purchased. Now up to 12000 miles.

Being a Honda means eveything seems to last. I am not the sort to clean and polish my bike but what little I do does seem to keep her in amazing condition!

It is comfy, however the single seat does seem to push my seating position down towards the tank which means I have to keep pressure on my knees to stop my b&5**ks from being squeezed under heavy braking. Not too major an issue though I have to say though I have not had the 'opportunity' to brake excessively yet. Never triggered the abs!

The screen I have (although an aftermarket item) does seem to direct the airflow straight into my face which makes for noisy motorway cruising even with earplugs. A proper double bubbble screen would no doubt cure this.

I have not had an issue with the linked brakes and I have to say I prefer them on a bike such as this. They do make for very stable braking at motorway speed.

The vtec step at 7000rpm is curious, On most of my commute (M2,M25) I never rev that high, 80mph is approx 5500 rpm which gives me over 50mpg. However approaching three figure speeds brings you closer to the vtec cut in - cruising at 7k rpm is not the smoothest of experiences. Again not an everyday occurence so not really an issue. I will be getting this checked at the next service though - due shortly.

She is not a lightweight! Does not feel a big bike once on the move and yet feels very stable and solid.

I am finding the sense of feel through the front wheel is lacking horribly, I am finding it very difficult to trust the front end grip however I think the tyres may have a part to play in this. They still have plenty of tread but not sure how long they have been on the bike.

They do sound lovely.

They look gorgeous. (Personal taste!)

The bike came with factory fitted heated grips - amazing. The grips can get too hot especialy with summer gloves. However with the mounted radiators on the side it can turn into a rather warm experience during the summer.

Would I buy one again? If my budget were to stay the same (£5k) then yes. Nothing else in the area seemed to be able to compete at that price. However if I had a little more to spend I would definitely look at the BMW's.

Just reread my post and although it seems a little negative it is only because I have concentrated on the negatives! It really is a fantastic commuter bike, just not as much fun for me when pushing on past 7/10ths. My profile has been kept up to date as far as mpg figures go if you are interested.

Felters

618 posts

230 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
fredd1e said:
If you've never ridden a telelever Bmw flat twin I strongly recommend you do b4 making a decision. Most main bmw dealers have test rides (unlike other brands I could think of) . It may be a revelation or a complete horror but they ain't the same as Japs and only you can make that call.
Wot he said. Plus take your pillion passenger with you. The various types of fairings used on BMW's makes a huge difference to pillion comfort. Most BMW franchises will let you try a range of bikes if there a sniff of a deal.

r1100rt

10 posts

221 months

Tuesday 26th August 2008
quotequote all
The BMW is an aquired taste. A short test ride may leave you feeling that it is not the bike for you.

I had a VFR 800 for a very short while and thought that it was reasonably comfy and would do 100 miles easily.
But!
I borrowed a friend's R1100RT when I needed to do a 200 mile trip. The first 30-40 miles I thought it was a tractor and definitly not for me. I had no choice but to plod on as I needed to go to the place I was heading for.
However by the time I got back, I was of a totally different opinion. The bike is superb at everything. I bought one and have now owned it for 4 years. (longer than any other bike ever) I have tried other bikes but I really cannot see anything that could even get close to it.
Ask other BMW owners and I bet the statements will be the same.

The VFR is a great bike. But the BM IS the best bike.

camgear

6,941 posts

225 months

Wednesday 27th August 2008
quotequote all
Do you mean a VFR800 Vtec or the older VFR800Fi?

I have the older version and I love it, it's a fantastic bike, they're not as reliable as everyone says but there's very little that will leave you stranded at the side of the road, (For example, in the early early VFRs, the downpipes corrode, the rear shock goes off, the head bearings damage easily).

black-k1

12,812 posts

260 months

Sunday 31st August 2008
quotequote all
Some good advice her but most important is to try before you buy, especially with the BMWs. The R1100S is a great bike but, like most BMWs, is different to your average Jap 4. It will take a bit of getting used to.

If it were me, then it would be the R1100S every time.