Is Undertaking illegal
Is Undertaking illegal
Author
Discussion

RemaL

Original Poster:

25,103 posts

265 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
yes I do it when you got a tt in the middle lane doing 60 on a motorway.

I ask as I have hear its not illegal but frowned upon by the police if theres a accident.

others say and I heard this on TV last night its illegal.

so anyone shed any light? and do you do it. and if illegal should it be made legal? like in the US?

f13ldy

1,432 posts

232 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
It is illegal.

Unless the lanes(s) to your right are moving slower than the lane you are currently travelling in, i.e. traffic.

However, I don't think this counts for a 75 year old in a yaris doing 40mph on the motorway.

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
Do a search in the SP&TL forum for a definitive answer but I think that there is no such thing as undertaking, thus it is not illegal BUT you can be done for Driving Without Due Care And Attention, which can be pretty serious/expensive!


ETA - Found a post on SP&TL. See the post from Derek Smith about half way down.

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...

Edited by black-k1 on Tuesday 2nd September 14:04

trumpet600

3,527 posts

262 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
i have been told it is illegal to undertake.

However, until feckwits stop using the outside lane/fast lane to do 55mph on a motorway, I shall continue to break the law.

ATTAK Z

19,574 posts

220 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
Do a search in the SP&TL forum for a definitive answer but I think that there is no such thing as undertaking, thus it is not illegal BUT you can be done for Driving Without Due Care And Attention, which can be pretty serious/expensive!
Surely it's the guys holding up traffic that are driving without due care and attention

trumpet600

3,527 posts

262 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
ATTAK Z said:
black-k1 said:
Do a search in the SP&TL forum for a definitive answer but I think that there is no such thing as undertaking, thus it is not illegal BUT you can be done for Driving Without Due Care And Attention, which can be pretty serious/expensive!
Surely it's the guys holding up traffic that are driving without due care and attention
yes, but who's going to arrest them? A Gatso camera?

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
ATTAK Z said:
black-k1 said:
Do a search in the SP&TL forum for a definitive answer but I think that there is no such thing as undertaking, thus it is not illegal BUT you can be done for Driving Without Due Care And Attention, which can be pretty serious/expensive!
Surely it's the guys holding up traffic that are driving without due care and attention
I agree with you but I think that if you then 'undertake' it's you that plod would stop, not the guy holding up the traffic!

StevRS

443 posts

240 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
It doesn't exist as a specific offence, but you will be done for it without under undue care or dangerour driving, depending on circumstances. You can do it in traffic jams etc but passing on the left in front of a copper will see you getting done without fail. frown

RemaL

Original Poster:

25,103 posts

265 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
thought DD was going to be what people said. think the main thing is to keep a eye out for the cops before doing it

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
RemaL said:
thought DD was going to be what people said. think the main thing is to keep a eye out for the cops before doing it
Only Dangerous Driving if you are breaking the speed limit at the same time! wink

RemaL

Original Poster:

25,103 posts

265 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
RemaL said:
thought DD was going to be what people said. think the main thing is to keep a eye out for the cops before doing it
Only Dangerous Driving if you are breaking the speed limit at the same time! wink
ahh I never do that

Johnny

9,652 posts

315 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
I got stopped a few weeks ago (number plate issue wink) and had been 'filtering' at about 80 ish when i saw the blue lights...

After a chat about my plate, and a £30FPN, I asked if that was all they had stopped me (us) for....

He replied 'what, are you referring to the filtering? I saw nothing wrong at all... you were going for undertakes that I personally wouldn't maybe make (between trucks etc.) but you were riding defensively and weighing up the gaps before making a move, and they were clean, safe moves.'

He (and his colleague) then both stated that there is no such offence as undertaking, but you can be done for driving without due care & attention /dangerous driving etc. if you are riding as such.

These were TrafPol in an unmarked Volvo. They also stated that other TrafPol may have viewed my riding differently... So make of that what you will!

Was also VERY pleased i had not passed them about 2 mins earlier... undertaking a yoof laden Cossie at about 1.55 leptons... hehe

trumpet600

3,527 posts

262 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
I do wish they would sing from the same songsheet.

I was told undertaking was an offence by a female trafpol.

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
f13ldy said:
It is illegal.

Unless the lanes(s) to your right are moving slower than the lane you are currently travelling in, i.e. traffic.
- Which is always the case!

smack

9,777 posts

222 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
Oh, good news about undertaking smile Well, as long as you are doing legal speeds....

I find the weekend drivers are the worst, a half empty motorway, and jammed with idiots who don't want to make use of the lanes.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
trumpet600 said:
I do wish they would sing from the same songsheet.

I was told undertaking was an offence by a female trafpol.
yeah but what do women know? hehe

if vonhooosseeeen says its not a specific offense in SP&L its good enough for me, he does go on about the DD option if seen doing it though.

im with you though, when the fktard morons learn to drive on the left i'll overtake on the right.

Not now Kato

1,169 posts

230 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
After a particularly bad period of endorsements I, and another rider, followed a driver in the right hand lane of the M3 for about 8 miles doing 65 - 70mph, there was very little traffic in the other lanes and he could have happily sat in one of them instead. We then indicated left, undertook and carried on . Within 500yds we were pulled over by a plain car and done for driving without due care and attention (or whatever the term is now).
Apparently they had been following us for some time and 'knew we would do something wrong'.

RemaL

Original Poster:

25,103 posts

265 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Not now Kato said:
they had been following us for some time and 'knew we would do something wrong'.
tipical. beacuse your on a bike "you will do something wrong"!

KennV6

59 posts

235 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Not now Kato said:
After a particularly bad period of endorsements I, and another rider, followed a driver in the right hand lane of the M3 for about 8 miles doing 65 - 70mph, there was very little traffic in the other lanes and he could have happily sat in one of them instead. We then indicated left, undertook and carried on . Within 500yds we were pulled over by a plain car and done for driving without due care and attention (or whatever the term is now).
Apparently they had been following us for some time and 'knew we would do something wrong'.
Absolutely stupid the police.... What has gone wrong.

They dont seem to be able, or have the option to, just hand out warnings for something that isn't actually dangerous. where has their option for discretion gone.

Unfortunately in this case if the driver was already doing the legal limit, then you would have had to exceed that to overtake. This sort of gives the police the option to do what they want.

The T Boy

924 posts

271 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Not now Kato said:
After a particularly bad period of endorsements I, and another rider, followed a driver in the right hand lane of the M3 for about 8 miles doing 65 - 70mph, there was very little traffic in the other lanes and he could have happily sat in one of them instead. We then indicated left, undertook and carried on . Within 500yds we were pulled over by a plain car and done for driving without due care and attention (or whatever the term is now).
Apparently they had been following us for some time and 'knew we would do something wrong'.
Do the police not have to prove "due care and attention"? Surely if you checked, indicated and passed without carving anyone up then you have exercised sufficient care and attention?

Has anyone ever got caught on this and challenged it?