Boot recommendation - (no stick insect legs need read!)
Boot recommendation - (no stick insect legs need read!)
Author
Discussion

Fats25

Original Poster:

6,260 posts

260 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
Can someone recommend a pair of boots?

Boot history has gone like this :-

  • Sidi Rain - Have lasted about 4 years but the soles are getting thin, and they have never been fully waterproof, I was very wet this morning.
  • Oxtar TCS type - Lasted about 18 months in mainly summer riding - never been waterproof but never expected them to be. Worn a hole just above the sliders
  • AlpineStars GP's - bought very cheap at bike show, and zip busted within a couple of weeks - summer only boots - keep meaning to get fixed but they are not that comfy anyway.
I wear leathers whenever I can, but will also ride in all weathers in my GoreTex gear. The problem I have (hence the title) is I have huge calfs, from too much football as a kid (thats my excuse anyway!).

I have decided I have two choices.

1) Keep Sidis which are ok in (light) rain and can (just about) go over leathers for Summer, and when caught in showers. Sidis can also go under Goretex when cold and not too wet. Then buy a heavy duty pair of waterproof boots to go under Gore Tex on known really wet days.

2) Buy a new pair of Sidi Rains for both seasons

So two questions:-

Can someone recommend a really good strong pair of waterproof boots?

Can someone recommend a pair of "hybrid" boots that will keep waterproof in really bad weather, and go over leathers for a fat calfed biker?

Thanks

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
Altbergs.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
Hein Gerrick Rallye, utterly waterproof under textiles even in snow.
plus ideally in this thread they seem too wide for my normal legs/feet. even over leathers ive got them on the thinnest adjustment.

Twit

2,908 posts

295 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
dern said:
Altbergs.
No question!!! I have two pairs, both get hammered and they just shrug it off! Best boots on that market by a mile and they dont have all that plastic crap all over them!

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
Twit said:
dern said:
Altbergs.
No question!!! I have two pairs, both get hammered and they just shrug it off! Best boots on that market by a mile and they dont have all that plastic crap all over them!
Quite. They can also be custom cobblered... see website for details op.

dibblecorse

7,666 posts

223 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
I have the same issue, too much cycling, rugby and football growing up ...

Try the Alpinestar SMX4's I have two pairs, the summer ones and recently the Waterproof ones as I started commuting, I think you'll be pleasantly surprised, they are also a little wider in the foot so proper comfy smile

Speed addicted

6,336 posts

258 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
Daytonas.
Mine have been totally waterproof, they've got adjustable tops for the larger gent, and you don't look like a power ranger.


D1 MAD

383 posts

263 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Altbergs are very good, I have 2 pairs 8 years old still going strong, comfy and waterproof.
http://www.altberg.co.uk/Web/motorcycle1.jsp

Have been looking at Daytonas, very nice, very pricey, but they do have adjustable fit on the calves.
http://www.smart-riders.co.uk/index.php?page=1&amp...

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Speed addicted said:
Daytonas.
Mine have been totally waterproof, they've got adjustable tops for the larger gent, and you don't look like a power ranger.
+1 defo on the daytonas. I've had three pair of daytona roadstar GTX goretex, fully calf size adjustable. I certainly don't have skinner legs ;-) Also are totally comfortable from day 1 i.e. don't need any real sort of breaking in.

G Man

4,053 posts

291 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
sjtscott said:
Speed addicted said:
Daytonas.
Mine have been totally waterproof, they've got adjustable tops for the larger gent, and you don't look like a power ranger.
+1 defo on the daytonas. I've had three pair of daytona roadstar GTX goretex, fully calf size adjustable. I certainly don't have skinner legs ;-) Also are totally comfortable from day 1 i.e. don't need any real sort of breaking in.
+1 yes

Kinkyboots

291 posts

233 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
sjtscott said:
Speed addicted said:
Daytonas.
Mine have been totally waterproof, they've got adjustable tops for the larger gent, and you don't look like a power ranger.
+1 defo on the daytonas. I've had three pair of daytona roadstar GTX goretex, fully calf size adjustable. I certainly don't have skinner legs ;-) Also are totally comfortable from day 1 i.e. don't need any real sort of breaking in.
+3 Daytonas are great. My husband has had his for the last 2 years and they are still great, never leek and always keep his feet warm. Also his foot and boot were fine after a cab drove over his foot. I have now bought a pair and they are so comfortable. Ok they may be expensive but they are worth it.

Edited by Kinkyboots on Wednesday 3rd September 08:48


Edited by Kinkyboots on Wednesday 3rd September 08:49

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

221 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
I just bought some Sidi Rains last week, and they got thier first proper deluge yesterday morning. Heavy rain for over an hour, and I had to stop with my foot in a deep puddle for a bit too, and they were brilliant.

Fats25

Original Poster:

6,260 posts

260 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Interesting reading......

Daytonas (I have tried these on before - and they did fit over leathers - just!). Didn't feel too comfortable as they were tight, but sure they would give a bit. I'll be honest it was the price that put me off, when I weighed it up against the comfort. I expected more for the money.

Think I have tried the SMX4's unless they are very new - I tried AlpineStars SMX something a couple of years ago - and still too tight on calfs (sp?).

I hate the look of the Altbergs, but as I would only wear then under gore-tex, and would stick with the Sidis for the leathers, they are an option. I am past the point of caring what I look like. Question is where can I try them on? Would not want to order over internet without having a try on.

Given me some food (just what I need!) for thought. Could have Sunday to myself for a bit of a shop, so think I will go for a ride and a look.

Again - I know I will be able to find the AlpineStars, and Daytonas, but what about the Altbergs? Do they resell - or only direct selling?

sybaseian

1,826 posts

306 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Fats25 said:
Interesting reading......

Daytonas (I have tried these on before - and they did fit over leathers - just!). Didn't feel too comfortable as they were tight, but sure they would give a bit. I'll be honest it was the price that put me off, when I weighed it up against the comfort. I expected more for the money.

Think I have tried the SMX4's unless they are very new - I tried AlpineStars SMX something a couple of years ago - and still too tight on calfs (sp?).

I hate the look of the Altbergs, but as I would only wear then under gore-tex, and would stick with the Sidis for the leathers, they are an option. I am past the point of caring what I look like. Question is where can I try them on? Would not want to order over internet without having a try on.

Given me some food (just what I need!) for thought. Could have Sunday to myself for a bit of a shop, so think I will go for a ride and a look.

Again - I know I will be able to find the AlpineStars, and Daytonas, but what about the Altbergs? Do they resell - or only direct selling?
I have a pair of Daytona Gor-tex and they take some time to break-in, but once the have you can wear them all day without any problems. I wear them with my leathers (inside) or Gor-tex trousers (outside).

They are expensive, but they are worth every penny.

Fats25

Original Poster:

6,260 posts

260 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
D1 MAD said:
Altbergs are very good, I have 2 pairs 8 years old still going strong, comfy and waterproof.
http://www.altberg.co.uk/Web/motorcycle1.jsp

Have been looking at Daytonas, very nice, very pricey, but they do have adjustable fit on the calves.
http://www.smart-riders.co.uk/index.php?page=1&amp...
Just had a quick look at the Daytona link - and it was the £379 EVO Sports that I tried on before. Will try to see if I can find the RoadStar ones as they are nearer £250. Although a little concerned that SJScott has had three pairs!

How long would you expect a boot to last? I was thinking about 3 to 4 years. Am I expecting too much?

RizzoTheRat

29,153 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
My Sidi Black Rain started to leak after about 3 years, not like a sive but enough that I tend to wear boot covers if I know I'm going to get wet.

sybaseian

1,826 posts

306 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Fats25 said:
D1 MAD said:
Altbergs are very good, I have 2 pairs 8 years old still going strong, comfy and waterproof.
http://www.altberg.co.uk/Web/motorcycle1.jsp

Have been looking at Daytonas, very nice, very pricey, but they do have adjustable fit on the calves.
http://www.smart-riders.co.uk/index.php?page=1&amp...
Just had a quick look at the Daytona link - and it was the £379 EVO Sports that I tried on before. Will try to see if I can find the RoadStar ones as they are nearer £250. Although a little concerned that SJScott has had three pairs!

How long would you expect a boot to last? I was thinking about 3 to 4 years. Am I expecting too much?
Daytona stand out when it comes to aftersales, they offer a repair service if you damage your boots or wear them out; or if you damage one boot you can buy one boot, even if you just damage a patch of leather, send the boots back to the factory and they'll replace that bit of leather for you! A full re-furb on a pair of GoreTex boots includes new soles, zips, gear change pads, GoreTex lining and a complete re-build of the boot - something that as far as we know is not available from any other manufacturer. All of this costs anywhere between £100 and £120 including carriage to and from the factory and is a non-profitable service, there are less expensive options available. Please call or email us with any enquiries regarding this service.

Twit

2,908 posts

295 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
In terms of Altbergs I think there is a surplus shop in Mile End that sells them - Silvermans I think it is called. In terms of how long they will last - pretty much forever, Altberg will refurb them and they just go on and on...

Fats25

Original Poster:

6,260 posts

260 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
sybaseian said:
Daytona stand out when it comes to aftersales, they offer a repair service if you damage your boots or wear them out; or if you damage one boot you can buy one boot, even if you just damage a patch of leather, send the boots back to the factory and they'll replace that bit of leather for you! A full re-furb on a pair of GoreTex boots includes new soles, zips, gear change pads, GoreTex lining and a complete re-build of the boot - something that as far as we know is not available from any other manufacturer. All of this costs anywhere between £100 and £120 including carriage to and from the factory and is a non-profitable service, there are less expensive options available. Please call or email us with any enquiries regarding this service.
Do you own Daytona boots? Or are you quoting from the website?!

sybaseian

1,826 posts

306 months

Thursday 4th September 2008
quotequote all
Fats25 said:
sybaseian said:
Daytona stand out when it comes to aftersales, they offer a repair service if you damage your boots or wear them out; or if you damage one boot you can buy one boot, even if you just damage a patch of leather, send the boots back to the factory and they'll replace that bit of leather for you! A full re-furb on a pair of GoreTex boots includes new soles, zips, gear change pads, GoreTex lining and a complete re-build of the boot - something that as far as we know is not available from any other manufacturer. All of this costs anywhere between £100 and £120 including carriage to and from the factory and is a non-profitable service, there are less expensive options available. Please call or email us with any enquiries regarding this service.
Do you own Daytona boots? Or are you quoting from the website?!
from the same website link that you posted.

Regards,

Ian