helmets
Author
Discussion

steveo29

Original Poster:

1,885 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
with the new sharp rating i dont really know what helmet to get.

the shoei raid 2 looks good, but is a bit pricy
same goes for the aria rx7

with the new sharp rating, with the cheaper helmets will they stand up to the same sort of punishment as the 4 or 5 stars.

and would i be putting myself at risk with buying a 2 or 3 star helmet?

speed_monkey

3,503 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
steveo29 said:
with the new sharp rating i dont really know what helmet to get.

the shoei raid 2 looks good, but is a bit pricy
same goes for the aria rx7

with the new sharp rating, with the cheaper helmets will they stand up to the same sort of punishment as the 4 or 5 stars.

and would i be putting myself at risk with buying a 2 or 3 star helmet?
I wouldnt worry too much about the rating. Just get the one that fits the best

untruth

2,834 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
Lower cost helmets aren't necessarily less safe, they are usually often as good as the more pricey ones, just heavier, uglier and thicker to save costs. They also tend to break more, but not in the safety way.

I'd still prefer (and do own!) a Raid 2 but there's not much point if it doesn't fit you correctly!

Rach*

8,824 posts

247 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
I tried on a load of helmets on Friday, the raid 2 felt so comfortable and light! When you try a bunch on you'll find one that feels nice.
The Sharp tests are a bit of a sketchy issue, with manufacturers not agreeing on the testing methods.

speed_monkey

3,503 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
I have a shark RSI, all the typical Arai, Shoei and the sorts didnt fit as well as the shark smile

Rob_F

4,155 posts

295 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
I got a helmet for doing my DAS as i didn't want to wear a smelly rent-a-lid for 4 hours in a go. I looked around at plenty of lids, and tried plenty on - which i think is the key. The best helmet in the world will be fk all use if it doesn't fit properly.

There are a couple of good fitting guides on the internet - basically you want to make sure there are no pressure spots where it will cause a pain/ache after a long ride, but for it to be tight enough not to move around your head. Make sure when you wobble it side to side it takes your head with it, and also that you can't lift it off (with one hand behind the back of the helmet, pulling it forward) when the strap is fastened.

After trying on about 10 lids i found the Nitro N-820vx and an AGV (can't remember model name but it was £150) were the best fits. They both had the same SHARP rating (4*) but i found the Nitro for £40 online at Donny Moto Store. I went down, tried it on (just to make sure) and bought it - i didn't want to be replacing a £150 lid if i dropped it on the first day!

The Nitro has performed brilliantly through my DAS - good ventilation, very comfortable, moulded to an even better fit, good straps etc. I think what you pay for with the AGV - or another big brand - is it was significantly lighter, smaller and may have been a bit quieter (and it looked cooler!)

Good luck - i'm very pleased with my Nitro and wouldn't subscribe to the more cash = more protection theory. One of the funniest sayings other bikers come out with is "how much is your head worth?" - mine's worth a fair bit more than even the most expensive helmet so a bit of a stupid saying I think! biggrin

Rob.

Twit

2,908 posts

295 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
As everyone else says, just go with fit - that is the key! I'm not really sure that cost has any bearing on quality. I remember talking to a helmet engineer guy at one of the races and he was saying that Shark helmets and Arai are basically the same except for price...!

That said I wear an open face most the time which I much prefer to full face helmets and they are generally the same sort of price regardless of make.

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
untruth said:
I'd still prefer (and do own!) a Raid 2 but there's not much point if it doesn't fit you correctly!
I'm on my 2nd and they're great but yes, fit first.

shouldbworking

4,801 posts

243 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
I cant find the link right now but I read up about the sharp test and if what I read is accurate, I dont think its that good. Apparently the ratings are all about surviving multiple impacts in the same spot (extremely rare in the real world) and the compromises in design this causes means more g's transmitted to your noggin (always happens in the real world).