category d ducati 748R - thoughts please
category d ducati 748R - thoughts please
Author
Discussion

rossb

Original Poster:

634 posts

252 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
hi all

went to see a 748R yesterday - with a mate who had one new and knows them well.

bike was just lovely - great condition 50mm termis and spare subframe/pillion seat/pegs/standard exhaust paddock stand

this new year - new belts/uprated rocker arms fitted - full history/paperwork MOT etc

anyway - checked bike over looked great - left a £250 deposit - just done an rac/vehicle/hpi check - it was a category D 5 years ago

on the one hand i am annoyed the guy did not mention this - although he only bought the bike a year ago and on my deposit receipt put "to the best of my knowledge there is no outstanding finance on this bike" - he seemed a straightforward bloke - and in all honesty - it is quite possible he is unaware of this - and it's going to be a painful surprise - he bought the bike a year ago

anyway the bike really seems a nice thing - really great condition - my first reaction is to walk away and get my deposit back - on the other hand it is a nice bike - do i make him a lower offer? is category D a big deal on an 8 year old bike i am probably gonna keep for a couple of years at least

your thoughts please - at the moment i am 90% leaning towards walking away - i want my first ducati experience to be special - comments please...i am really gutted at the moment - was gonna skive off work this afternoon and collect.

my mate said - at the price 3700 - the bike is in great condition - forks looked new - wheels are great - engine great - cosmetics great etc - he reckoned that if i was going to take it - probably want to chip the price to £3k - but in reality it's condition is so good - because it has been rebuilt after a prang.

what would you do?

thanks

ross

Jetl3on

1,409 posts

227 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
rossb said:
hi all

went to see a 748R yesterday - with a mate who had one new and knows them well.

bike was just lovely - great condition 50mm termis and spare subframe/pillion seat/pegs/standard exhaust paddock stand

this new year - new belts/uprated rocker arms fitted - full history/paperwork MOT etc

anyway - checked bike over looked great - left a £250 deposit - just done an rac/vehicle/hpi check - it was a category D 5 years ago

on the one hand i am annoyed the guy did not mention this - although he only bought the bike a year ago and on my deposit receipt put "to the best of my knowledge there is no outstanding finance on this bike" - he seemed a straightforward bloke - and in all honesty - it is quite possible he is unaware of this - and it's going to be a painful surprise - he bought the bike a year ago

anyway the bike really seems a nice thing - really great condition - my first reaction is to walk away and get my deposit back - on the other hand it is a nice bike - do i make him a lower offer? is category D a big deal on an 8 year old bike i am probably gonna keep for a couple of years at least

your thoughts please - at the moment i am 90% leaning towards walking away - i want my first ducati experience to be special - comments please...i am really gutted at the moment - was gonna skive off work this afternoon and collect.

my mate said - at the price 3700 - the bike is in great condition - forks looked new - wheels are great - engine great - cosmetics great etc - he reckoned that if i was going to take it - probably want to chip the price to £3k - but in reality it's condition is so good - because it has been rebuilt after a prang.

what would you do?

thanks

ross
Not an issue on an 8 year old bike, but it usually is on a Ducati as buyers tend to be real fussy and pedantic buggers. Is it Ohlins Spec?
5 years ago, the 748R was worth twice that much and as Cat D is for relatively minor damage, why wasnt it repaired?

I would say if it is your first Ducati, buy one with an unblemished record, there is no telling what all the nice paintwork is hiding when you ride it hard round a bend. £3K is cheap, but dont let all the extras sway your decision.

Im my experience anyway.

Busamav

2,954 posts

239 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
any bike that shows a hit on the insurance database , be it C or D needs to be extremely cheap imho.

Very difficult to sell a blighted bike when there are so many around at this time of year

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
I wouldn't buy it - ducati buyers generally have ocd in my experience and twitch at the slightest mark so cat d will have them having a fit in the middle of your drive way wink.

996 sps

6,165 posts

247 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
Jetl3on said:
rossb said:
hi all

went to see a 748R yesterday - with a mate who had one new and knows them well.

bike was just lovely - great condition 50mm termis and spare subframe/pillion seat/pegs/standard exhaust paddock stand

this new year - new belts/uprated rocker arms fitted - full history/paperwork MOT etc

anyway - checked bike over looked great - left a £250 deposit - just done an rac/vehicle/hpi check - it was a category D 5 years ago

on the one hand i am annoyed the guy did not mention this - although he only bought the bike a year ago and on my deposit receipt put "to the best of my knowledge there is no outstanding finance on this bike" - he seemed a straightforward bloke - and in all honesty - it is quite possible he is unaware of this - and it's going to be a painful surprise - he bought the bike a year ago

anyway the bike really seems a nice thing - really great condition - my first reaction is to walk away and get my deposit back - on the other hand it is a nice bike - do i make him a lower offer? is category D a big deal on an 8 year old bike i am probably gonna keep for a couple of years at least

your thoughts please - at the moment i am 90% leaning towards walking away - i want my first ducati experience to be special - comments please...i am really gutted at the moment - was gonna skive off work this afternoon and collect.

my mate said - at the price 3700 - the bike is in great condition - forks looked new - wheels are great - engine great - cosmetics great etc - he reckoned that if i was going to take it - probably want to chip the price to £3k - but in reality it's condition is so good - because it has been rebuilt after a prang.

what would you do?

thanks

ross
Not an issue on an 8 year old bike, but it usually is on a Ducati as buyers tend to be real fussy and pedantic buggers. Is it Ohlins Spec?
5 years ago, the 748R was worth twice that much and as Cat D is for relatively minor damage, why wasnt it repaired?

I would say if it is your first Ducati, buy one with an unblemished record, there is no telling what all the nice paintwork is hiding when you ride it hard round a bend. £3K is cheap, but dont let all the extras sway your decision.

Im my experience anyway.
Avoid at all costs, do not buy this bike try your hardest to get your dosh back asap. As for Ducati owners being fussy I would have not brought any of my Jap bikes from someone who failed to mention the bike I was buying was a Cat D.

jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
Jetl3on said:
5 years ago, the 748R was worth twice that much and as Cat D is for relatively minor damage, why wasnt it repaired?
Good question.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
I would suggest that it depends on what you plan to do with it. If you want to keep it for a year then sell it on then, unless the purchase price is VERY attractive, it’s probably not a good idea.

If, on the other hand, you plan to keep it for the next 5 plus years then the difference in re-sale value of a Cat D vs a non-Cat D at that point will be minimal and in the mean time you’ve had use of a great bike at a cheap price. (Once you have re-negotiated!)

Sossige

3,176 posts

294 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
dern said:
I wouldn't buy it - ducati buyers generally have ocd in my experience and twitch at the slightest mark
Sounds like it's definitely a Ducati for me next year then biggrin

996 sps

6,165 posts

247 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
Do not buy this bike simple! Even if it was a 5 year old Gixer and you put a deposit down then found it was a Cat D its just not on.

748R is a lovely bike and there is plenty more out there which are not Cat D.

3doorPete

9,991 posts

265 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
Runaway, or if you really are still keen - extended test ride so you can really tell if handling is affected and forks, swing arm have no stictions etc. Ideally, you'd want to see pre-repair pictures to make a call on what might have been affected, but sounds like that is not on the cards...

Either way, it needs to be cheap as chips...

rossb

Original Poster:

634 posts

252 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
guys

thanks for your comments - i have been over to see the vendor today and collected the deposit - vendor was apologetic and appeared genuine in his ignorance of the bikes status

he bought the bike a year ago - this year has spent £1200 at a local Ducati dealer on belts and rocker arms - and further digging suggested the bike was ridden by the owner at the time for over a year after the repair work after CAT D incident (2003) - so it suggests that it was sound.

dealer has offered to do a full engineers report on the bike and the guy has said he'll re-advertise for £3400.

my thoughts are as follows:

1 - 748R's tend to range between £4-6k?

2 - however well repaired - even if it is in effect a new bike - prices on a CAT D are at least 20-40% down on a comparitive "clear" bike - and that is to the area of the market who will buy them - which appears to be a fair bit smaller than the main market when it comes to dukes

3 - The bike if broken up - got lots of nice bits is worth £2.5k in parts - albeit with a bit hassle

4 - how bad is CAT D in reality - it is not necessarily structural - conspiracy theory - occasionally CAT D may happen - when owner and repair business preparing quote "collude" - come up with a large repair bill - owner buys wreck for say a grand - owner gets paid out full book value - and repair garage - who get the "real" repair business also get a token of appreciation....

5 - I think the guy will do well to get 3400 - i reckon it is more like a 2750-3000 - which sounds harsh - but it's where i value it with pound notes in my hand at this time of year. at that price as a toy for weekends and trackday use next year it is very tempting - and lets face it for this kind of toy if it rides well is cheap

6 - insurance cover was not an issue - but their valuation in the event of a claim would reflect cat d status - which if bought right is fair enough

thing is if i am patient i reckon i can find a nice genuine bike for 4-4.5k at this time of year - and *IF* i do get bored of it - i can sell it without hassle/px it in the trade etc - who universally seem leery about a CAT D at any price.

anyway thanks again - the real ****er is that i have SWMBO in agreement to buy one - gotta strike while the iron is hot - and i have spent a couple of days messing around - want one more than ever now - just keen to get one - and get on with some bloody work smile

ross

996 sps

6,165 posts

247 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
rossb said:
guys

thanks for your comments - i have been over to see the vendor today and collected the deposit - vendor was apologetic and appeared genuine in his ignorance of the bikes status

he bought the bike a year ago - this year has spent £1200 at a local Ducati dealer on belts and rocker arms - and further digging suggested the bike was ridden by the owner at the time for over a year after the repair work after CAT D incident (2003) - so it suggests that it was sound.

dealer has offered to do a full engineers report on the bike and the guy has said he'll re-advertise for £3400.

my thoughts are as follows:

1 - 748R's tend to range between £4-6k?

2 - however well repaired - even if it is in effect a new bike - prices on a CAT D are at least 20-40% down on a comparitive "clear" bike - and that is to the area of the market who will buy them - which appears to be a fair bit smaller than the main market when it comes to dukes

3 - The bike if broken up - got lots of nice bits is worth £2.5k in parts - albeit with a bit hassle

4 - how bad is CAT D in reality - it is not necessarily structural - conspiracy theory - occasionally CAT D may happen - when owner and repair business preparing quote "collude" - come up with a large repair bill - owner buys wreck for say a grand - owner gets paid out full book value - and repair garage - who get the "real" repair business also get a token of appreciation....

5 - I think the guy will do well to get 3400 - i reckon it is more like a 2750-3000 - which sounds harsh - but it's where i value it with pound notes in my hand at this time of year. at that price as a toy for weekends and trackday use next year it is very tempting - and lets face it for this kind of toy if it rides well is cheap

6 - insurance cover was not an issue - but their valuation in the event of a claim would reflect cat d status - which if bought right is fair enough

thing is if i am patient i reckon i can find a nice genuine bike for 4-4.5k at this time of year - and *IF* i do get bored of it - i can sell it without hassle/px it in the trade etc - who universally seem leery about a CAT D at any price.

anyway thanks again - the real ****er is that i have SWMBO in agreement to buy one - gotta strike while the iron is hot - and i have spent a couple of days messing around - want one more than ever now - just keen to get one - and get on with some bloody work smile

ross
Good sound decision there Ross, when I was trying to find my bike it was a mare, drove around the country looking at supposed mint SPS, one guy had his in his living room with 1200 miles yet tyres were bubbled and bottom of fairing was scuffed so tracked and more than likely speedo disconnected. Choose a Ducati with the mind and not the heart.

Have a look at the 748 S as well can always get a single seat unit and it will have Termis on more than likely. Least you can take someone on the back then if needs be.


3doorPete

9,991 posts

265 months

Monday 6th October 2008
quotequote all
Good sum up Ross - reckon you are thinking with your head rather than your heart which is always a good thing financially!

Just on point 4 - I've seen some bad cat D's and some very light cat D's of the type you mention (more in the car than the bike world) and there are bargains to be had - BUT - this is why you have to see detailed pictures of the pre-repair damage and insurance report. You'd also want to see full bills for what was replaced when it was rebuilt. A diligent owner who repaired a vehicle would take the photos and keep the bills as a matter of course, as they know this would help them preserve some value and instill some confidence when they came to sell it.

Without the above, it is just a gamble and a guy's word you don't know. If there is a mechanical nasty hidden, on 2 wheels, you are gambling with your life. Not worth it for a £1-2K really...

If it was back in 2003, the bike would have been worth quite a lot then, so I would guess there was a fair amount of damage.