Talk me in to it!!
Author
Discussion

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
My circumstances have changed, I can no longer catch the train to work.

The options are a) car or b) bike.

The chosen mode of transport will be 100% my only mode of transport (at least for a little while).

The commute is Newmarket to Stratford (approx 60mi each way, A14, M11 etc)

Option a = warm, dry and comfortable however, I am at the mercy of the traffic and the fuel costs will probably reduce me to tears.

Option b = possibly cold, damp and uncomfortable however, I will at least have half a chance of getting to and from work in a reasonable time should it get a bit busy, the fuel costs will probably make me cry less and at least I will have a bike!

I have posted something very similar recently but that was when it was a luxury with the option of the train if the weather should get too bad.
Now, the train is not an option, car or bike, 60mi each way, whatever the weather, come on people, talk me in to it!

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
Talk yourself into it. You should ride because you want to do it.

lawrence567

7,507 posts

221 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
Get a Pan.... its like driving a car!

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
Rawwr said:
Talk yourself into it. You should ride because you want to do it.
Don't get me wrong, I do want to do it and to be honest if it's as feasible as I'm trying to convince myself it is, then it's the only way I'm going to have a life in the week and not go insane with that daily commute!

I suppose my only real worry is frost / snow etc which, with 99% of the commute being on major dual carriageway / m-way, I'm convincing myself won't be an issue. :corssesfingers:

I just need a little shove / kick up the arse.....

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
lawrence567 said:
Get a Pan.... its like driving a car!
Maybe I should add, I only passed my test in August (IIRC) and am a short-arse!
I was thinking more along the lines of VFR800 or if it wasn't too tall R1100S...

Edited by roboxm3 on Tuesday 7th October 12:35

G Man

4,053 posts

291 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
Get a used BMW K1200GT SE with heated handle bars and heated seat if you want to be warm

lawrence567

7,507 posts

221 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
roboxm3 said:
lawrence567 said:
Get a Pan.... its like driving a car!
Maybe I should add, I only passed my test in August (IIRC) and am a short-arse!
I was thinking more along the lines of VFR800 or if it wasn't too tall R1100S...

Edited by roboxm3 on Tuesday 7th October 12:35
Grow some longer legs?

mitzy

13,858 posts

228 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
lawrence567 said:
roboxm3 said:
lawrence567 said:
Get a Pan.... its like driving a car!
Maybe I should add, I only passed my test in August (IIRC) and am a short-arse!
I was thinking more along the lines of VFR800 or if it wasn't too tall R1100S...

Edited by roboxm3 on Tuesday 7th October 12:35
Grow some longer legs?
Platform Shoes, cuban heels?

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
Shut it you two, this is serious!!! wink

lawrence567

7,507 posts

221 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
You could stand in horse st & if your vertically challenged...

RizzoTheRat

29,169 posts

223 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
I used to commute 60 miles each way on the M3/A3 and M25. I rarely used the bike as unless there was big traffic holdups it actually took me longer by bike due to the increased time getting ready (kit on, bike out of garage etc), and the fact that I had to fill the bike up with fuel every day compared to every 4 days with the car. I generally cruised about 75ish in the car or on the bike to be reasonably fuel efficient, so the bike was only really a better option on the 3 or 4 times a year when there was a really big accident on the M25. I did sometimes commute by bike but generally only when the weather was nice and I'd take a longer route home as motorways are very very dull.

On the otherhand I also spent some time working at Heathrow and commuting M3, M25, A3 was about 45 mins in the car and 20 on the bike. There's also a possibilty of some future work being in Portsmouth which would mean a single carriageway commute which I think would show a lot more benefit travelling by bike.

It does depend on your journey but the bike might not always be as good an option as it seems, and after 60 miles in a monsoon you might start to have second thoughts.

On the other hand you can buy a old diesel car that'll manage 50mpg on the motorway for well under a grand and use that when the weather's crap. I actually worked it out on my old ZX, it averaged 16p/mile over 100,000 miles including fuel, maintenance and depreciation. Nice little earner when I was getting paid a mileage allowance.

Seademon

1,170 posts

244 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
If you buy the right bike gear you wont be cold! Bike wins unless your gonna have a clear run in a car everyday which you wont ha ha

StevRS

443 posts

240 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
The A14 and the M11 are ropey roads, especially where they meet. I'd risk the bike and buy a four wheeled nail if it grinds you down... biggrin

BikeWithABeak

28 posts

218 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
roboxm3 said:
Rawwr said:
Talk yourself into it. You should ride because you want to do it.
Don't get me wrong, I do want to do it and to be honest if it's as feasible as I'm trying to convince myself it is, then it's the only way I'm going to have a life in the week and not go insane with that daily commute!

I suppose my only real worry is frost / snow etc which, with 99% of the commute being on major dual carriageway / m-way, I'm convincing myself won't be an issue. :corssesfingers:

I just need a little shove / kick up the arse.....
I tried something like this one day a week a few years ago. Frost wasn't a real problem but snow could have been life-threatening - road conditions but also from the risk of hypothermia whilst waiting for a snowplough. The other thing which was a real pain was fog not only from the general lack of visibility but also from it coating my visor.

If you can choose between a bike or car when the weather's crap before you set out and you have the right bike and kit then go for it but I'd not commit to a bike as my only transport through the winter, especially in my first year of riding.

Twit

2,908 posts

295 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
For the first year after I passed I had a bike as my only transport and used it in all weathers. Two key things come to mind; first make sure you ge the right bike, for me sports bikes are a right no no, you have to be comfortable and if possible have a bike that can keep the worse of the weather off. Second, kit - make sure you have kit that keeps you warm and dry, that is way more important than armour this and that. The risks are greater from the weather than any crash. Other than that, get the right head on and go for it, its dead easy just make sure you ride to conditions. Even snow and ice can be a laugh on the right bike!

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
Twit said:
For the first year after I passed I had a bike as my only transport and used it in all weathers. Two key things come to mind; first make sure you ge the right bike, for me sports bikes are a right no no, you have to be comfortable and if possible have a bike that can keep the worse of the weather off. Second, kit - make sure you have kit that keeps you warm and dry, that is way more important than armour this and that. The risks are greater from the weather than any crash. Other than that, get the right head on and go for it, its dead easy just make sure you ride to conditions. Even snow and ice can be a laugh on the right bike!
I like you!.....more like this please thumbup

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
Bump for the evening crew.....

I need more persuading, the boss just told me he did it for 2 winters and it can be a PITA.....I heard "it's doable, I did it for 2 winters" hehe

PolarExpress

6,796 posts

258 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
Twit said:
For the first year after I passed I had a bike as my only transport and used it in all weathers. Two key things come to mind; first make sure you ge the right bike, for me sports bikes are a right no no, you have to be comfortable and if possible have a bike that can keep the worse of the weather off. Second, kit - make sure you have kit that keeps you warm and dry, that is way more important than armour this and that. The risks are greater from the weather than any crash. Other than that, get the right head on and go for it, its dead easy just make sure you ride to conditions. Even snow and ice can be a laugh on the right bike!
Until you come off that is rolleyes

I'd rather be wet than go through two operations, a week+ in hospital, and 7 months physio when you come off. This was 2 years ago when I thought an uber-waterproof North Face jacket was a suitable replacement for proper biking gear with armour:



Just today, white van man put me into the railings on my normal everyday commute through town. It's only because of the armour I was wearing that I'm writing this from the comfort of home, and not a hospital. Don't be a Twit! laugh


Edited by PolarExpress on Tuesday 7th October 17:52

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
roboxm3 said:
Twit said:
For the first year after I passed I had a bike as my only transport and used it in all weathers. Two key things come to mind; first make sure you ge the right bike, for me sports bikes are a right no no, you have to be comfortable and if possible have a bike that can keep the worse of the weather off. Second, kit - make sure you have kit that keeps you warm and dry, that is way more important than armour this and that. The risks are greater from the weather than any crash. Other than that, get the right head on and go for it, its dead easy just make sure you ride to conditions. Even snow and ice can be a laugh on the right bike!
I like you!.....more like this please thumbup
agreed again, but get waterproof stuff with armour - most textiles do have armour nowdays. just the cheap stuff normally lacks back armour.
i run a bike as my only transport for a year & would still be that way but i picked up a cheap car for a couple of weeks moving stuff about & its too good to sell.
anyway any proper gear will do the job, my textiles are by 'lewis' was about £140 for jacket AND trousers, utterly waterproof & with a decent jumper underneath ive ridden in the snow ok. decent waterproof boots are a must (ive got HG rallyes, warm as toast) and heated grips so you can still brake at the end of the motorway.

steveo29

1,885 posts

220 months

Tuesday 7th October 2008
quotequote all
indeed, if its waterproofing you want, get a good textile bike jacket with armour, and then you can get some stuff that you spray on like a aerosole to the jacket to make it waterproof.

the right gear is VERY important, as so is the bike. but also the tires, it you get tires that give great grip for track use, will be pretty poor for road use as you wont be able to keep the heat in them and all the oil and water on the road will make you slip off.

saying that, i would rather use my bike to get to work than my car.
just more enjoyable other than getting tts trying to take you out.