Belt drive on Sports/Sports tourers
Belt drive on Sports/Sports tourers
Author
Discussion

Silver993tt

Original Poster:

9,064 posts

270 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
I like the idea of belt drive (as on Harleys, Buells etc). Basically maintenance free compared to a chain but without the complexity/weight of a shaft drive. I don't know why it's not been made available for sports or sport tourer bikes like my ZZR1400. Belt drive can clearly handle the torque, since cruisers that use them put out alot of this anyway. Anyone have any ideas why not?

xspencex

1,534 posts

267 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
My BMW F800S has belt drive, seems like a pretty good system, smooth and quiet. Ive done 14,000 miles and I haven't had to do a thing with it...should be ok upto 25,000 miles..and by then I'll have something else.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
sportsbikes have chains thats the way buyers think. look at all the comments about BMW sports bikes being too heavy due to a shaft. its just not the done thing.
would the belt streach as you snapped the throttle open & ruin the throttle response? ive not tried a belt bike to experiment.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
Someone on here a while back stated that a properly tensioned and lubricated chain was the most efficient way of transmitting drive over a distance like from a gearbox sprocket to the rear wheel. If this true, perhaps the only benefit of a belt vs. a chain (clean, quiet operation) is outweighed by efficiency losses (presumably deformation in the rubber / fabric of the belt as it rotates around the 'sprockets' converts some power to heat, wasting some of the output).

I can't see the losses being *that* significant myself, Harley and Buell don't seem to be worried. And belt drive is used to drive superchargers on top fuel dragsters that themselves need 1000 bhp to run them, so torque capacity shouldn't be an issue...

Perhaps it's a width thing - as the torque capacity increases, the belt has to increase in width (check out the width of the toothed belts used on dragster superchargers!), whereas a strong chain can be only a centimetre in width, and this puts constraints on the transmission design on a sportsbike (namely, the 'sprockets' extending further outside the engine width, potentially being possible to ground out on heavy cornering?)...

Phil C

436 posts

306 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
I think there's one simple reason. Fashion. ie most of us don't particularly like the look of the seemingly huge rear wheel 'cog' that seems to be necessary for belt drives. No disrepect to BMW 800S owners - but somehow it just looks odd on a mid size sports / tourer. Personally I'd happily stop the faffing around with lube and cleaner and adjusting when chains stretch....if a manufacturer could make belt drive's look a bit more 'normal'.......

Beemer-5

7,897 posts

245 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
Probably down to frictional losses, as was suggested, where sports bikes go.

Silver993tt

Original Poster:

9,064 posts

270 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
At least manufacturers could enclose the chain on sports/tourers/or whatever. That way, there would be far less maintenance, would last much, much longer and would look a whole lot better than the current crude chain and sprockets that really make a mess (looks wise) of the rear of any bike.

3doorPete

9,991 posts

265 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
Beemer-5 said:
Probably down to frictional losses, as was suggested, where sports bikes go.
Would be interesting to see the figures as cam belts are more efficient than cam chains in engines. Don't know if longevity is an issue as cam chains in engines are generally a non-service, life of the engine item (generally it's the tensioner that causes problems), whereas cam belts have a service life (3-5 years generally).

Personally, I'm not bothered about fashion. I hate messy chains and adjusting them and would much prefer a belt if they put them on proper sports bikes.

outlaw biker

2,458 posts

227 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
3doorPete said:
Would be interesting to see the figures as cam belts are more efficient than cam chains in engines. Don't know if longevity is an issue as cam chains in engines are generally a non-service, life of the engine item (generally it's the tensioner that causes problems), whereas cam belts have a service life (3-5 years generally).
Are you sure you've worded this correctly? "cam belts are more efficient than cam chains in engines" Surely thats the other way around? I'd certainly opt for a chain rather than a belt wherever possible (in a car engine). Not sure about on a bike....whats the likely outcomeof a high speed chain failure vs belt failure on a bike? I imagine one involves a cruise to standstill and the other a cheap one way flight.

Beemer-5

7,897 posts

245 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
I can't see why they can't put a modern belt-drive on say an R1.

catso

16,587 posts

298 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
Beemer-5 said:
I can't see why they can't put a modern belt-drive on say an R1.
Probably (at least in part) due to the necessary width of the belt meaning the rear end being wide/ugly/bad geometry?, those Harley/Buell belts are wide plus the pulleys are so huge.

Also a belt would need to be tight under all suspension positions (or jump teeth), whereas a chain can loosen/tighten under suspension compression but still stay on, don't know how HD/Buell get away with that? maybe by having short suspension travel?

Edited by catso on Wednesday 22 October 21:51

Roger McLittriss

493 posts

285 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
outlaw biker said:
3doorPete said:
Would be interesting to see the figures as cam belts are more efficient than cam chains in engines. Don't know if longevity is an issue as cam chains in engines are generally a non-service, life of the engine item (generally it's the tensioner that causes problems), whereas cam belts have a service life (3-5 years generally).
Are you sure you've worded this correctly? "cam belts are more efficient than cam chains in engines" Surely thats the other way around? I'd certainly opt for a chain rather than a belt wherever possible (in a car engine). Not sure about on a bike....whats the likely outcomeof a high speed chain failure vs belt failure on a bike? I imagine one involves a cruise to standstill and the other a cheap one way flight.
A camchain working inside an engine is running in a near-perfect environment for it: it's protected from the elements and foreign objects and runs in a permanent oil bath/ splash/mist.
The fact that cam belts deteriorate is more due to the perishable materials involved than the stresses imposed: after all, helicopters use belt drive - but they have very strict (and enforced, unlike your car cambelt) inspection & replacement regimes wink
On their V4s, Honda switched from belt to chain cam drive more as a space-saving exercise than anything else. The belt is supposed to be changed at 100,000 miles... but so is the chain!

RizzoTheRat

29,169 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd October 2008
quotequote all
catso said:
Also a belt would need to be tight under all suspension positions (or jump teeth), whereas a chain can loosen/tighten under suspension compression but still stay on, don't know how HD/Buell get away with that? maybe by having short suspension travel?
Hmmm, good point. Saw a belt drive conversion on a TDM a while back, and that's got around 6" of suspension travel. The reccomended chain slack is about 50mm so presumably that's to allow for it tightening as the suspension moves. I reckon the belt drive conversion might have had a tensioner in the lower guard. No wider than the sprocket carrier though, this was using a standard swingarm.
does the F800 have a tensioner?




Edited by RizzoTheRat on Wednesday 22 October 22:29

3doorPete

9,991 posts

265 months

Thursday 23rd October 2008
quotequote all
outlaw biker said:
3doorPete said:
Would be interesting to see the figures as cam belts are more efficient than cam chains in engines. Don't know if longevity is an issue as cam chains in engines are generally a non-service, life of the engine item (generally it's the tensioner that causes problems), whereas cam belts have a service life (3-5 years generally).
Are you sure you've worded this correctly? "cam belts are more efficient than cam chains in engines" Surely thats the other way around? I'd certainly opt for a chain rather than a belt wherever possible (in a car engine). Not sure about on a bike....whats the likely outcomeof a high speed chain failure vs belt failure on a bike? I imagine one involves a cruise to standstill and the other a cheap one way flight.
Yes - I did word that correctly. I would rather have a chain in an engine as failures are less common - but I believe the facts are that the friction losses, weight and simplicity of cam belts is better than cam-chains in engines.

I guess it's going off thread to debate the cambelt/camchain thing, but I just wondered whether cam belt longevity being shorter indicates as reason why belts are not being used on sports bikes? I don't have the answer - was just putting it out there.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Thursday 23rd October 2008
quotequote all
Phil C said:
I think there's one simple reason. Fashion. ie most of us don't particularly like the look of the seemingly huge rear wheel 'cog' that seems to be necessary for belt drives. No disrepect to BMW 800S owners - but somehow it just looks odd on a mid size sports / tourer. Personally I'd happily stop the faffing around with lube and cleaner and adjusting when chains stretch....if a manufacturer could make belt drive's look a bit more 'normal'.......
yes

I think you are absolutely spot on with the fashion thing. As I understand it, a good condition, well cleaned, well lubed chain is marginally more efficient than a belt at transmitting the power to the wheel but most bikes actually spend very little time with the chain in that condition. In all other circumstances, a belt is more efficient.

The problem with bikes, and sports bikes in particular, is that buyers are so anal about every last hp, every last kg of weight etc. that the fact that there are ‘some circumstances’ where the chain is more efficient means that fashion dictates that this is the only option that can be considered.

Beemer-5

7,897 posts

245 months

Thursday 23rd October 2008
quotequote all
As i've said before, better than worshipping every last quarter of one bhp, many riders could slim down the heaviest part of 'the bike'!

StevRS

443 posts

240 months

Thursday 23rd October 2008
quotequote all
rofl

And how many would be able to tell or exploit the difference either way?

Beemer-5

7,897 posts

245 months

Thursday 23rd October 2008
quotequote all
On the road, anything under 5% gain in power is rarely noticeable, ime.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Thursday 23rd October 2008
quotequote all
Beemer-5 said:
On the road, anything under 5% gain in power is rarely noticeable, ime.
I agree, but it doesn’t stop a large number of the buying public having to have the lightest, fastest, most powerful sports bike of any category, to then fit additional weight saving/power increasing bolt-ons. How else can you win bar room top trumps?

Beemer-5

7,897 posts

245 months

Thursday 23rd October 2008
quotequote all
Stop being silly!

It's great to pay a fortune for a carbon fibre, lightweight numberplate carrier, whilst carrying 3 stones of excess flab and booze!
biggrin

Anyhow, BOT, belt drive!