Is This Worth It?
Author
Discussion

melv

Original Poster:

4,708 posts

296 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
OK -need advice -this is my PH ad:

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/749163.htm

This is my website page that I asked the guy to use info from the PH ad.

http://www.flyingbluedog.co.uk/

Frankly, I was dissappointed, and said so....

"Er, I don't know what I was expecting but a straight lift from my PH
ad was not it -frankly, for £350 I'm disappointed, to say the least!!

Tried a google and it doesn't come up.

Look forward to your feedback....

Rgds
Mel"

Here is his reply...comments??? Am I being unfair??

"Mel,
It is not a straight lift – it is similar – we have created a top
layout and created the logo from scratch so we can now use it
elsewhere if you need for advertising. Normally this would be
£120-£150+Vat on its own (ask any web design company the cost of
creating a bespoke logo).

We have recreated the photo gallery using our photo gallery coding at
the top of the page which looks similar but is better quality than the
one on the original site.

I think it looks ok and better that the original site - what would you
like to change?

It takes 6-12 weeks to get into Google – if they accept your site as
there is no guarantees they will - and it needs to be submitted to
Google!

Your price also included the years hosting which is normally
£10/month+VAT = £120+VAT.

All in all I think you have a very good deal and done in very short
time as well!









Stevenj214

4,941 posts

259 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
I suppose it depends on the original brief, but for comparison:

http://www.onepagewebsitedesign.com/

http://www.gotlogos.com/

£120 + VAT for the logo + website

£10p/m seems like a lot for hosting?

However some UK design companies can charge £500+ for a logo.

Overall, probably not as cheap as you could have got it for, but also probably not a rip off if they met your brief.

-1-

12 posts

222 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
That site will have taken about 15 minutes to create and has not even been optimised for basic SEO. I would ask for a hosting refund, get a simple £19.99 a year hosting account and spend the rest on making the site work correctly

touching cloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
Wow, £350 for that... that's very poor tbh.

shadowninja

80,160 posts

313 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
I will try to be sensible. I do want to laugh, though. First of all, which is the PH ad and which is your website? biggrin

I think they are charging too much. They could at least do a rather-cheesey-for-2008 photomontage that allows you to click through.

The Moose

23,703 posts

240 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
sorry man - you've been had!!! I dont recon that was worth 35, let alone 350! and 120 a year on hosting... for that?!?!?!? yeah!

anyway, if you need a hand sorting it out - give me a PM. for example our hosting is 20 a year!!

look forward to hearing from you

cheers

The Moose

bishbash

2,447 posts

228 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
You would have thought that a logo for a company called flying blue dog would have prehaps used a blue dog!
Also linking directly to the pistonheads contact form is very lazy, what if pistonheads decide to move things around.
Sorry mate, you've been 'ad

944pi

84 posts

251 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
It's a shame that someone (or was it a Team;)) has been so lazy with this. It's quite blatant too.

From my basic knowledge and use of GIMP / Photoshop, I'd say there is about 20 minutes work in the logo.

It makes the pages and logos I put together look almost professional....

Hope you get it sorted out.

Phil



GuildfordPaul

467 posts

237 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
melv said:
OK -need advice -this is my PH ad:

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/749163.htm

This is my website page that I asked the guy to use info from the PH ad.

http://www.flyingbluedog.co.uk/

Frankly, I was dissappointed, and said so....

"Er, I don't know what I was expecting but a straight lift from my PH
ad was not it -frankly, for £350 I'm disappointed, to say the least!!

Tried a google and it doesn't come up.

Look forward to your feedback....

Rgds
Mel"

Here is his reply...comments??? Am I being unfair??

"Mel,
It is not a straight lift – it is similar – we have created a top
layout and created the logo from scratch so we can now use it
elsewhere if you need for advertising. Normally this would be
£120-£150+Vat on its own (ask any web design company the cost of
creating a bespoke logo).

We have recreated the photo gallery using our photo gallery coding at
the top of the page which looks similar but is better quality than the
one on the original site.

I think it looks ok and better that the original site - what would you
like to change?

It takes 6-12 weeks to get into Google – if they accept your site as
there is no guarantees they will - and it needs to be submitted to
Google!

Your price also included the years hosting which is normally
£10/month+VAT = £120+VAT.

All in all I think you have a very good deal and done in very short
time as well!



agreed, that website is pants, straight copy, the company you paid should be ashaimed!

jamesuk28

2,176 posts

284 months

Saturday 25th October 2008
quotequote all
No, p1ss poor/ and if he does not give you your money back let me know and we will collect it for you free of charge.

944pi

84 posts

251 months

Sunday 26th October 2008
quotequote all
This is unsolicited, but I wanted to see if I could do anything with the flying blue dog. The dog is a bit rough - but you get the idea.



Phil

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Sunday 26th October 2008
quotequote all
Jesus.

How do people have the cheek to do it?

I'd guess he's on about £700ph because there is NO way, that took more than 30 minutes.

Maybe even 15.

gopher

5,160 posts

290 months

Sunday 26th October 2008
quotequote all
I think it's OTT for what's been done, I don't do much front end stuff (it's a means to an end for me rather than an end in it's self) but I even noticed the link to your Pistonheads ad doesn't even work, a 2 second check.

Without wishing to hijack the thread - the gallery they've used I've seen on a number of sites now I assume it's javascript\css driven? Either way is there an explanation on the net of how it works?

melv

Original Poster:

4,708 posts

296 months

Sunday 26th October 2008
quotequote all
Guys

Many, many thanks for your time and trouble and PM's!!

Fortunately, I have not handed over a bean!

I will be copying your comments to him.....banghead

Basically, at the end of the day I want a website that will sell the company!!

And the logo?



A straight lift from my camera phone pic of the signwriting on my 4x4, so hardly any work there!!! It took my guy five minutes with an off the shelf jpeg and a bit of bending of the writing and then straight onto the vinyl laser cutter!!

Thanks again for your feedback and offers -will keep you posted.

Rgds
Mel

jgmadkit

553 posts

280 months

Sunday 26th October 2008
quotequote all
That makes it even worse - the fact that you've given them the logo to use...they havn't created anything unique just made an electronic version of it. I know people in business have got to make money but that is taking the wee. No effort whatsoever on their part and they expect you to hand over £350. Tell them to shove it.

John

Stevenj214

4,941 posts

259 months

Sunday 26th October 2008
quotequote all
melv said:
And the logo?

A straight lift from my camera phone pic of the signwriting on my 4x4, so hardly any work there!!! It took my guy five minutes with an off the shelf jpeg and a bit of bending of the writing and then straight onto the vinyl laser cutter!!
Ah. In that case, as others have said, you've been done. I'm sure many people would have knocked you up a page like that for free in the hope of future work.

heyuk

2,512 posts

221 months

Sunday 26th October 2008
quotequote all
melv said:
It is not a straight lift – it is similar – we have created a top
layout and created the logo from scratch so we can now use it
elsewhere if you need for advertising. Normally this would be
£120-£150+Vat on its own (ask any web design company the cost of
creating a bespoke logo).


It takes 6-12 weeks to get into Google – if they accept your site as
there is no guarantees they will - and it needs to be submitted to
Google!

Your price also included the years hosting which is normally
£10/month+VAT = £120+VAT.
- I pay £150+vat for logo design and that includes two or three inital versions then a couple of refinements.
- £10 a month hosting is not crazy at all, you can get hosting for pennies a year, but usually that is resold reseller stuff with a 13yo as 'tech support'.
- Sites can be submitted to google, what is better is to link to it from already spidered sites. The time lag he quotes is about right.

It does seem expensive for what it is, I would suggest going back asking for:
- Say you wish to have the original files (ie. png's NOT gif/JPGs) for the logo so you can use them for letterheads and the like.
- Ask for full information on your hosting package ie. how many email addresses you are allowed etc
- Further to that, ask for FTP info so you can ammend the site direct.

A plus point is the domain has been registered in your name smile

It is one of those things, people have to make money, but this is at the lower end of the quality scale for what you should get for £350 IMHO.


jamesuk28

2,176 posts

284 months

Sunday 26th October 2008
quotequote all
Mel, thanks for your email, I have replied.

Like I said I will offer you every assistance in this matter, as I am sure most of your fellow PH'ers will as well.


Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Sunday 26th October 2008
quotequote all
Oh and another thing.

To get your site on Google doesnt require it to be submitted, Google will find it.

Submissions are a largely pointless idea and some say submission actively works against you.

jacobyte

4,768 posts

273 months

Monday 27th October 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Oh and another thing.

To get your site on Google doesnt require it to be submitted, Google will find it.

Submissions are a largely pointless idea and some say submission actively works against you.
Agreed. But Google will only find your site if another site links to it, so be sure that the site that links to yours is already indexed by Google.