There is no hope
Author
Discussion

Nightmare

Original Poster:

5,276 posts

304 months

Friday 3rd October 2003
quotequote all
This morning I was astonished to be following a car which had a 4 or 5 (small version anyway) year old kid walking around on the back seat. The reason I was amazed was that this was a DRVING INSTRUCTORs car - one WAZI instructors in fact.

My g/f then texted me to say "we'll never get rid of middle lane numtpies...there was one doing about 57 mph in the middle lane of the M1 this morning....oh, and it was an AA advanced driving instrauctor". Apparently he was driving alone (so not person under instruction) and there was absolutey nothing in the inside lane for at least 1/2 mile.

If they can't do it, what can we really expect of everyone else?

li'l pugs

1,323 posts

279 months

Friday 3rd October 2003
quotequote all
No problem in either case as no speed limit was exceeded therefore no danger at all............

Derek Smith

48,375 posts

268 months

Friday 3rd October 2003
quotequote all
"There is no Hope"

I hope not.

Derek

Julian64

14,325 posts

274 months

Friday 3rd October 2003
quotequote all
why does that surprise you? Its patently not against the law to drive really slowly not matter how much distress you cause others.

All the worst driving I've ever seen has come from people who consider their driving skills are above average.

And I bet if you ask a driving instructor or even an advanced driving instructor how good they are compared to the population, they'll tell you their above average

Flat in Fifth

47,521 posts

271 months

Friday 3rd October 2003
quotequote all
Julian64 said:


snip 8< 8<

And I bet if you ask a driving instructor or even an advanced driving instructor how good they are compared to the population, they'll tell you their above average


the sad bit is they are almost certainly correct.

Nightmare

Original Poster:

5,276 posts

304 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
it did surprise me actually..the speed was irrelevant...it was the sitting in the middle lane with a clear inside lane for no good reason that got me.

Oh, and the other one was incredibly dangerous. Had he had to brake sharply, small brat would have sailed through the windscreen!

marvelharvey

1,869 posts

270 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
Slightly off the main topic...

yesterday I saw an AA driving instructor out by himself. He stalled the car twice when trying to turn out of a junction up a very steep hill. Once he'd pulled out of the junction he then sat behind a bus at a bus stop without bothering to overtake, the road was empty and perfectly safe.

I often wonder how these people became driving instructors.

ben

2,344 posts

267 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
"if you are no good at it 'Teach It'"

Julian64

14,325 posts

274 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
I often hear the, 'if he'd braked hard the child would have gone through the window'. I would respectfully suggest this is urban myth. Have you ever tried to brake as hard as you possibly could and see if anyone came out of their seats let alone sailed through the window.
I think the only g impact sufficent to do this would be a dead stop, eg plunge into a concrete wall.

TheLemming

4,319 posts

285 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
Julian64 said:
I often hear the, 'if he'd braked hard the child would have gone through the window'. I would respectfully suggest this is urban myth. Have you ever tried to brake as hard as you possibly could and see if anyone came out of their seats let alone sailed through the window.
I think the only g impact sufficent to do this would be a dead stop, eg plunge into a concrete wall.


Ive hit the anchors and had a front seat passenger come clear out of the seat. This was at less than 20 mph iirc.

Try pulling an emergency stop at about 40-50 with something reasonably heavy on the back seat (ie a couple of bags of shopping) and it will go flying forwards.

Simple physics, the car is slowing down, the passengers arent until they hit something (ie seatbelt they are wearing - if not then front seat passengers, driver, dashboard, windscreen)

I can only suggest that you havent tried an emergency stop for a considerable time, or you DESPERATELY need to get your cars brakes attended to.

Julian64

14,325 posts

274 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
Probably brakes then. When I hit the brakes in the TVR is grinds to a halt pretty quick but it wasn't enough to even move my wife out of her passenger seat, and she wasn't even wearing her seat belt.

Can a road car pull 1G in braking? I suppose my simple physics should be able to work it out from stopping distances etc. I would be surprised if it could.

rude girl

6,937 posts

279 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
[quote=TheLemming]

Ive hit the anchors and had a front seat passenger come clear out of the seat. This was at less than 20 mph iirc.
quote]

Have to concur with this. I had to pull an emergency stop on the M6 a few years ago, using the Passat in front of me to assist my deceleration I was in an Avensis hatchback and hit the Passat at way less than 20mph, and both my dogs which were in the boot ended up in the passenger footwell, having hit the dash on their way. Kids should be tied down at all times, and especially in cars

fish

4,051 posts

302 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
We have a bunch of driving instructor students in the building. They display some of the worst parking I've ever seen such as: (sign- xxxxx parking only) oh that must mean me then.... and its the entrance to the car park lets park so close on the road my rear overhangs the entrance that should make it nearly inmpossible for anyone in asports car to see to pull out...

Oh well

streaky

19,311 posts

269 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
Nightmare said:
[snip]My g/f then texted me to say "we'll never get rid of middle lane numtpies...there was one doing about 57 mph in the middle lane of the M1 this morning....oh, and it was an AA advanced driving instrauctor".[snip]
Erm, and what speed were you travelling at whilst you were reading this text message? Was it a 'hands-free' unit (in which case your eyesight is extremely good )? If not, then I presume you were holding it in one hand.

Mind you, in my book that's marginally safer than an unbelted - therefore illegal (?) - child in the car.

I've stopped counting the stupid things I see so-called 'advanced drivers' do ... and that includes some of the emergency service drivers!

mondeoman

11,430 posts

286 months

Monday 6th October 2003
quotequote all
Julian64 said:
I often hear the, 'if he'd braked hard the child would have gone through the window'. I would respectfully suggest this is urban myth. Have you ever tried to brake as hard as you possibly could and see if anyone came out of their seats let alone sailed through the window.
I think the only g impact sufficent to do this would be a dead stop, eg plunge into a concrete wall.


Its a guaranteed way to get the kids in the back to belt up - emergency stop from about 20 mph soon gives them black eyes .........

Nightmare

Original Poster:

5,276 posts

304 months

Tuesday 7th October 2003
quotequote all
streaky said:

Erm, and what speed were you travelling at whilst you were reading this text message? Was it a 'hands-free' unit (in which case your eyesight is extremely good )? If not, then I presume you were holding it in one hand.

I was actually at work by the time I got said text message...I have never and would never attempt to read something like that whilst driving... Im too scared for my own life! I edited the story for the convenience of typing it into P/Heads

hertsbiker

6,443 posts

291 months

Tuesday 7th October 2003
quotequote all
ha ha ! on the brakes, a lotus derived car like the vx can keep the passenger "hanging" in the belt for several seconds when braking from certain speeds. So I imagine if no seatbelt, they'd be through the screen no prob. Scary huh?

hedgerley

621 posts

288 months

Tuesday 7th October 2003
quotequote all
I can personally vouch for the effects of emergency braking. When I was a sprog (around 10) my Dad had to throw out the anchor as we crested a hill (NSL) in our Hillman Super Minx to find an RTA a few minutes old. He managed to pull up inches from the back of the carnage - I sailed between the front seats (no rear seat belts back then), cracking my head on the dash, breaking my nose and ending up in the passenger footwell. Just as mother stopped screaming and was about to say that was close, we were rear-ended by the prat behind who wasn't so quick on the brakes and my parents ended up with severe whiplash as he shunted us into the earlier accident. To this day my only involvement in an RTA.