Penalty charge notice for barely anything!
Penalty charge notice for barely anything!
Author
Discussion

untruth

Original Poster:

2,834 posts

220 months

Saturday 1st November 2008
quotequote all
Quite unbelievably I have a penalty charge notice for 'failing to drive in the direction shown by the arrow on a blue sign'. The photo shows absolutely nothing aside from me politely waiting to turn, but I remember the occurrence - it's at the bottom of St Martin's Lane in Covent Garden, whereby there is a raised central reservation on the road that runs at a T junction in front of the right hand side of the exit of the street. It says 'left only, except for cycles'. So you know, being very late at night and it being quite quiet, I turn right as I am on a (motor)cycle and can easily corner normally and don't even need to avoid the reservation which is to my right!

But no, I've got a PCN. I assume I sit down, shut up and pay up?

RizzoTheRat

29,172 posts

223 months

Saturday 1st November 2008
quotequote all
Your tax disk clearly states you're on a bicycle.

dibblecorse

7,669 posts

223 months

Saturday 1st November 2008
quotequote all
untruth said:
I assume I sit down, shut up and pay up?
yep, you ignored a fairly clear signal, if you thought you could, you'd appeal, but you know you are bang to rights on this one, its just one of those "didn't get away with it" moments, they happen to us all ...

untruth

Original Poster:

2,834 posts

220 months

Saturday 1st November 2008
quotequote all
Haha, yes. I know what I did, it's the old "if I post on a forum will someone comment that they got away with thisone?" trick.

Clearly not. Ah well.

  • gets wallet out*

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

221 months

Sunday 2nd November 2008
quotequote all
Actually, I'm a bit shocked at your post, because I though that "except for cycles" signs included motorbikes. Certainly in Clapham there is a road that I use that says "no entry except for busses cycles and taxis" and I have used it many times.

Typical ambiguity as a result of people forgetting bikers exist. I'd fight it. Even if you eventually have to pay, it will draw attention to this problem.

dibblecorse

7,669 posts

223 months

Sunday 2nd November 2008
quotequote all
Mr Gear said:
Actually, I'm a bit shocked at your post, because I though that "except for cycles" signs included motorbikes. Certainly in Clapham there is a road that I use that says "no entry except for busses cycles and taxis" and I have used it many times.

Typical ambiguity as a result of people forgetting bikers exist. I'd fight it. Even if you eventually have to pay, it will draw attention to this problem.
You kidding ?? on that basis you'd use every bus lane thats designated "No entry except for buses, cyclists and taxis", yet I'm sure you don't ??

There is no ambiguity, they haven't forgotten bikers exist, we just don't have the exemption.

This problem in part is being addressed by the relaxing of Bus Lane rules in 09.

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

221 months

Sunday 2nd November 2008
quotequote all
dibblecorse said:
Mr Gear said:
Actually, I'm a bit shocked at your post, because I though that "except for cycles" signs included motorbikes. Certainly in Clapham there is a road that I use that says "no entry except for busses cycles and taxis" and I have used it many times.

Typical ambiguity as a result of people forgetting bikers exist. I'd fight it. Even if you eventually have to pay, it will draw attention to this problem.
You kidding ?? on that basis you'd use every bus lane thats designated "No entry except for buses, cyclists and taxis", yet I'm sure you don't ??

There is no ambiguity, they haven't forgotten bikers exist, we just don't have the exemption.

This problem in part is being addressed by the relaxing of Bus Lane rules in 09.
That's not what I am suggesting at all. Some signs use an image of what is clearly a pedal cycle, which in my vocabulary is a bicycle. Some signs just use the word "cycle" which could mean motorcycle or bicycle. And to confuse things further, the taxation class for motorbikes is still defined as a bicycle. It's ludicrously ambiguous, and to argue the other way is just being bloody-minded.

EDIT: in addition to this, the bus lanes around my house allow motorcycles in them, but the ones heading in to London do not, and yet they are both signed in the same way. You have to be "in the know" to not get fined. Bollocks to that. It should be obvious what the law is.

Edited by Mr Gear on Sunday 2nd November 13:13

untruth

Original Poster:

2,834 posts

220 months

Sunday 2nd November 2008
quotequote all
I've paid it on the basis that if I disputed and lost (likely!) that I would pay 120 quid not 60. Sit down, shut up, and hate westminster council quietly.

dibblecorse

7,669 posts

223 months

Sunday 2nd November 2008
quotequote all
Mr Gear said:
dibblecorse said:
Mr Gear said:
Actually, I'm a bit shocked at your post, because I though that "except for cycles" signs included motorbikes. Certainly in Clapham there is a road that I use that says "no entry except for busses cycles and taxis" and I have used it many times.

Typical ambiguity as a result of people forgetting bikers exist. I'd fight it. Even if you eventually have to pay, it will draw attention to this problem.
You kidding ?? on that basis you'd use every bus lane thats designated "No entry except for buses, cyclists and taxis", yet I'm sure you don't ??

There is no ambiguity, they haven't forgotten bikers exist, we just don't have the exemption.

This problem in part is being addressed by the relaxing of Bus Lane rules in 09.
That's not what I am suggesting at all. Some signs use an image of what is clearly a pedal cycle, which in my vocabulary is a bicycle. Some signs just use the word "cycle" which could mean motorcycle or bicycle. And to confuse things further, the taxation class for motorbikes is still defined as a bicycle. It's ludicrously ambiguous, and to argue the other way is just being bloody-minded.

EDIT: in addition to this, the bus lanes around my house allow motorcycles in them, but the ones heading in to London do not, and yet they are both signed in the same way. You have to be "in the know" to not get fined. Bollocks to that. It should be obvious what the law is.

Edited by Mr Gear on Sunday 2nd November 13:13
You're really quite funny, whn ANY road sign refers to a CYCLE we all know it means the pedal powered, I honestly hope you don't rxcrcise any of this poetic licence with anything else in the Highway Code or road traffic signage.

FunkyNige

9,869 posts

306 months

Sunday 2nd November 2008
quotequote all
dibblecorse said:
You're really quite funny, whn ANY road sign refers to a CYCLE we all know it means the pedal powered, I honestly hope you don't rxcrcise any of this poetic licence with anything else in the Highway Code or road traffic signage.
Shouldn't it be a bit better defined than 'we all know what it means' though? My motorbike tax says 'Bicycle' on it...

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

221 months

Monday 3rd November 2008
quotequote all
FunkyNige said:
dibblecorse said:
You're really quite funny, whn ANY road sign refers to a CYCLE we all know it means the pedal powered, I honestly hope you don't rxcrcise any of this poetic licence with anything else in the Highway Code or road traffic signage.
Shouldn't it be a bit better defined than 'we all know what it means' though? My motorbike tax says 'Bicycle' on it...
Absolutely. And it wasn't that long ago that I said on here about inconsistency with bike parking too. For example, in Lewisham I know I can park my bike in a residents parking bay without a parking badge and not get a ticket. Yet try that trick in Kensington and you'd be certain to get ticketed. But there is nothing on any of the parking signs mentioning motorcycles at all. Even if you phone up the borough parking office in some case they don't know what their own policy is, and say it is up to the traffic wardens to decide if you have made an offence.

I really can't understand how "Dibblecorse" can defend it.

cmsd2

253 posts

222 months

Monday 3rd November 2008
quotequote all
untruth said:
left only, except for cycles?
The highway code doesn't really cover this properly, but the 2002 signs regulations seems quite unambiguous. Not great bed-time reading but hey: http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2002/20023113.htm
It is quite pedantic in its usage of the terms "cycle", "pedal cycle" etc.

http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2002/023113aa.gif

Despite the wordage on the sign which can indeed refer to other sorts of vehicle, the term cycle as applied here exempts only pedal cycles.

cmsd2.

Busamav

2,954 posts

239 months

Monday 3rd November 2008
quotequote all
Mr GearIt's said:
ludicrously ambiguous, and to argue the other way is just being bloody-minded.
Well i will join dibble in being bloody minded .

I actually think it is you who has the blinkered view , it is not ambiguous in any way in my eyes .

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

221 months

Monday 3rd November 2008
quotequote all
Busamav said:
Mr GearIt's said:
ludicrously ambiguous, and to argue the other way is just being bloody-minded.
Well i will join dibble in being bloody minded .

I actually think it is you who has the blinkered view , it is not ambiguous in any way in my eyes .
Well in the case of the original post, I don't think I would have been tempted to turn right at that junction. The raised section of the road would suggest that I wasn't supposed to do that (and I won't go into the rights and wrongs of weather it's any real problem for a motorbike to turn right... in most cases it isn't).

BUT... there are plenty of cases where the use of the word "cycle" is insufficient, especially since it is supposed to be a legal definition in the case of road traffic.