S2 111S best induction kit ??
S2 111S best induction kit ??
Author
Discussion

eddie main man

Original Poster:

241 posts

227 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
Hi everyone, Okay maybe this is an old subject, done & dusted, but after some serious investigations i'm still not decided, so best to ask the bible = 'Pistonhead Lotus forum'.

Okay so I have a very nice 111S, 2002, K series lump. For the induction kits, what's the verdict? I know this car will never have the sound of a V8, or at best the nice dry tone I had on my 2.8 Capri (with full janspeed), before I flogged it for the Elise. Always nice going through tunnels, in the 2.8 (memories). Anyway back to the Lotus. I have found Hurricane, Various Piper kits, K&N 57i, & the Apollo type (looks nice in black). ITG, kit a lot of people rave on about, and the rice burner, from Moto-build (based on a Piper, from what I have read).

My main points, are the sound, value for money. Talking 160quidish, up to just under 300, for ITG. Another point is I see some have a lead pipe drawn in from the side vent, and others like the Hurricane, just have a small lead pipe (maybe I'm not totally correct).

I have done the rounds on U-tube for the sounds, so that's covered, concerning Hurricane. So far I'm thinking to go for the Hurricane (seems a firm favoutite), but interested about the Apollo 57A 6030. What does that sound like? These two being about the same price (more or less). But then again the ITG kit is supposed to be the bees knees, and with a +8BHP advantage (not so sure it's that much) !!! What's the verdict on induction kits, then?

Edited by eddie main man on Monday 29th December 21:15

LRGS2

143 posts

241 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
I have a 120BHP K-Series S2 which runs a Pipercross Viper induction kit and a Janspeed Sports exhaust and this sounds great as well as passing the noise limit for trackdays (93dBA @ 4000RPM). I had the car from new in standard form and drove it for about 2000 miles before I added the exhaust and induction kit in stages. The exhaust definitely made the car sound better as well as rev easier and the induction kit added more of an induction roar - well there's a surprise! It always used to struggled to rev past the 6000RPM in standard form whereas now it bounces off the rev limiter at around 6750RPM, so in conclusion it breathes a lot easier. As to the cheaper induction kits sorry I can't help as I have never tried them!

Saied

1,575 posts

242 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
I had an ITG fitted to my Sport 160 back in June. Pricey swines they are. I'm a notoriously tight-fisted bugger, but when it comes to the Elise, I tend to come over all lavish. laugh

My car was very loud to start with having been de-catted plus the addition of a sports silencer and 340R manifold. Popped, banged even spat the occasional small flame on overrun.

Post-ITG? Minimal difference at low rpm / light throttle openings but the car sang even louder than before above 5,000rpm on a hard throttle. Still bangs and splutters and pops. smile

The car sounds so bloody good, i'm planning on a little run up to London very late tonight after midnight to seek out some tunnels. biggrin

I don't notice any more power, but Sinclaire's (who fitted it) reckon the ITG may be good for a few more horses. Must say it looks good when the engine cover is lifted, too. smile

I'm led to believe the Hurricane (which is probably better value) is a touch louder than the ITG, with a more metallic, 'raspy' sound.



Edited by Saied on Monday 29th December 21:35

S Works

10,166 posts

273 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
ITG is the pick of the bunch if it's money-no-object.

Re: London tunnels, get down around the London Bridge Tooley St. area for some classic ones through the arches. You'll get a flash of the London "nightlife" down there too if you're unlucky. Just don't stop or the rozzers may think you're a punter! rofl

Saied

1,575 posts

242 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
You missed a really good SELOC run on Sunday, Tim. smile

S Works said:
Re: London tunnels, get down around the London Bridge Tooley St. area for some classic ones through the arches. You'll get a flash of the London "nightlife" down there too if you're unlucky. Just don't stop or the rozzers may think you're a punter! rofl
There's at least 5 tunnels that run under London Bridge mainline station. thumbup

The combination of a cold night and it being Monday should ensure quiet roads.

Didn't know it was known as a red-light area. yikes

Some seriously dodgy nightclubs under the arches around there, though. The drugged-up chav sgs would come into the Underground station as we opened on Sunday morning at 7:30am. Once on the platforms, fags would be lit. Saw a couple of the bhes drop their kegs and urinate in full view of the cameras on more than one occasion.

eddie main man

Original Poster:

241 posts

227 months

Tuesday 30th December 2008
quotequote all
Well thanks lads. Started on about induction kits, then lead onto a more cultured subject about tunnels, dodgey nightclubs, and pissing in the street. Well bloody good forum this is for all kinds of stuff. No problem always an interesting read !!!

Okay I'm gonna go for the ITG one then. Before though I have a second hand janspeed to pick up in a couple of days, and soon after fit. It's the super sport one (one main box). The next question is about de-cat pipe. The car is a S2 111S, so has the VVC engine. I read somewhere, no real gain to loose the de-cat concerning power improvements, as the VVC engine was conditioned, and needs the resistance of the original cat. Any thoughts on that? Then I think I'm sorted for the mo.

S Works

10,166 posts

273 months

Tuesday 30th December 2008
quotequote all
Don't decat it. VVC doesn't like it, and all you gain is noise (which you'll have plenty of with the ITG and the new can).

S Works

10,166 posts

273 months

Tuesday 30th December 2008
quotequote all
Saied said:
You missed a really good SELOC run on Sunday, Tim. smile
I was sorry to miss it, felt rotten the day before (Xmas cold) and couldn't face a long day in the car (despite the fact that it's now a comfortable GT with a big lazy V6!). Hopefully in the new year I'll be allowed to tag along wink

eddie main man

Original Poster:

241 posts

227 months

Tuesday 30th December 2008
quotequote all
S Works. Okay noted. Thanks, I know where I'm going now on this one then. Cheers...
S Works said:
Don't decat it. VVC doesn't like it, and all you gain is noise (which you'll have plenty of with the ITG and the new can).

kambites

70,811 posts

244 months

Tuesday 30th December 2008
quotequote all
yes General consensus is that you lose power if you de-cat a VVC.

lee111s

377 posts

211 months

Tuesday 30th December 2008
quotequote all
The decatting a VVC engine is a bit of a grey area. There was some testing done on a MG with a VVC and different exhaust system to the elise. There's a bit more info on it on seloc.

I've decatted my s1 111s and I must say I like the sound of it more than before. Either way, you wouldn't miss 1 or 2 bhp....it's all about personal preference.

eddie main man

Original Poster:

241 posts

227 months

Tuesday 30th December 2008
quotequote all
I saw that article on the MGF, for decat pipes. Just got back from 'Garage Performance Engine', website = http://www.performans-engine.com/ , here in Le Mans. Frédéric's the guro, for amongst others Caterhams, jags, Lotus, Porsche, Triumphs. A little plug, for him but a kind bloke and very helpful too. Had a coffee with him just now, and he confirmed only 2 options for the VVC engine. 1) Leave well alone the original cat, or 2) Install a Sports cat. Forget the decat pipe altogether.

So it's Janspeed Sportsbox + ITG induction, for the mo.

eddie main man

Original Poster:

241 posts

227 months

Tuesday 30th December 2008
quotequote all
One last point for the ITG induction kit. Available with aluminum or carbon fiber filter container. The price a bit more for the carbon fiber version. What baffles me is okay we know all about carbon fiber weight, ratio, tensle strength etc, yet aluminum ain't bad. Also aluminum is one of the best conductors, so great for a heat sink to disapate the heat. I would guess better than carbon fiber concerning this point. Anyone ever considerred this? The weight difference for the carbon fiber / aluminum would be marginal surely at any rate. The price is nearly 90 quid difference though. What's the verdict out there on that front?

bogie

16,902 posts

295 months

Wednesday 31st December 2008
quotequote all
seeing as the difference between the worst and best induction kits on an Elise is about 5bhp, which is undetectable from the seat of the pants dyno then its not worth worrying about carbon or ally - just buy the one that fits your budget, they all do the same thing (providing you compare like with like - closed box etc) the noise may be different thats all

I had carbon on my old Hurricane as I had carbon bling engine covers too ...that was about the only decision - which under cover colour scheme do you prefer LOL wink

S Works

10,166 posts

273 months

Wednesday 31st December 2008
quotequote all
Was there any decision you ever made about that car that wasn't influenced by either power or bling? wink

bogie

16,902 posts

295 months

Wednesday 31st December 2008
quotequote all
mmmm...now thinking about it ...errrr...no !

it it makes it go faster or looks cool, I would have one LOL wink