Towing
Author
Discussion

drew.h

Original Poster:

526 posts

220 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
Can one of those 'A' frame tow bars be used to tow a Chimaera?
Anyone tried it?

K4TRV

1,819 posts

283 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
I have a motorhome and understand the A-frame concept.

I sprint & Hillclimb my Chimaera and have never considered using an A frame for the following reasons;

How will you fit the brackets without cutting the front skirt/body work?? The Chimaera is so low, how will the frame go under ?? There are companies (near Poole) who may "make" you an A frame.

Secondly, you are "supposed" to have secondary braking with an A frame, I believe that it would be a right faff to organise with cables etc to the brake pedal - what do you do when reversing ??

Then there's the "Grey area" under Law with reference to towing and A-Frames. Yes, no-one has been prosecuted yet.

I'll stick to my trailer.

Trev

steve-V8s

2,924 posts

279 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
Hi Trevor

I have been thinking about this one as well however rather than going the A frame route there is a recovery service operator quite close to where I work and they have at least one transit sized van which does front suspended tow using a bit you put the front wheels on and then hydraulically lift off the ground. come to think of it perhaps that is an A frame. As I quite fancy ditching the big estate and getting a van for doing other things and wondered if this was worth looking at. Perhaps the hydraulic lift gadget could be bolted on the back of a motor home as well. I guess the car then becomes a trailer so the rear wheels would have to be legal.

K4TRV

1,819 posts

283 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
Steve-V8s,

Lots of potential, but careful with your solution!!

The front-wheels-off-the-ground is likely to be construed as a recovery dolly. You can't connect up and head off to Winscombe for weekend Hillclimb - or you can and hope you are not stopped??

Bolting hydraulics to the rear of Motorhome/Van causes serious loading issues to chassis/rear axle. Some vans have very small overhang and may work - Motorhomes, forget it, even a 125Kg scooter on a rear carrier put my last motorhome over the limit. A Chimaera front end will have approaching 500Kgs to suspend (if you are 1050kg advertised weight??). Headlights shining on the squirrels ??

Sadly trailer solutions are easier to get on with, even if I can't use the third lane on a motorway !!

Trev

bobfather

11,197 posts

286 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
Before you consider how to do it you need to think of the drive train. If I understand this correctly the gearbox oil is circulated by a pump on the input shaft. If the car is in neutral and the rear wheels are turning then the gearbox will be running without oil circulation. I wouldn't want to be doing that for more than a few miles.

I'm happy to be proved wrong but this was my understanding of the gearbox oil system.

K4TRV

1,819 posts

283 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
Agree the LT 77 has an oil pump in it - not sure about the later Chimaeras??

Never read of any limitations in my old SD1 Vitesse, TR7 and nothing in the TVR Handbook I have for my '93 version.

The gearbox is doing nothing other than in neutral and layshafts being spun. There is no "power/work" being expended, so I doubt there's a real problem in towing with rear wheels on the road.

Trev

Bluebottle

3,498 posts

271 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
I think you'll find it will raise the front of the car too much and you'll grind your exhaust off.

BRITISHBEEF

75 posts

217 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
I have an A-frame, and yes, the Chim is too low. And no, you don't need secondary braking to use an A-frame. I used to tow cars to Liverpool docks from Doncaster with it. Had to use the good old tow rope to get my poorly Chim to the garage other week!

K4TRV

1,819 posts

283 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
BRITISHBEEF said:
I have an A-frame, and yes, the Chim is too low. And no, you don't need secondary braking to use an A-frame. I used to tow cars to Liverpool docks from Doncaster with it. Had to use the good old tow rope to get my poorly Chim to the garage other week!
I refer the honorable Gentleman to my earlier answer "supposed to".....for braking (check your Max Train Weight and braked/unbraked trailer weights !! - ignorance is no defence)

Until there is a definitive "Law", do what your conscience lets you do.

Lots of discussion in Motorhome Forums, don't need it here, thanks !!

Trev

mb450

429 posts

230 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
That's really interesting I had no idea/didn't even think to check the regulations read It would be just my luck to be the first person to be prosecuted

I was planning to take a Griff rolling chassis to be welded using on one of these an A-frame things, but,
it sounds like we should file that under 'forget it' and bung in it on a trailer instead

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
You can do what you like to remove the vehicle from danger to a place of safety, but outside that it will need to comply with the towing regulations.

If you have a driver in it who can operate the brakes, you can tow it with whatever you want.

If there's no driver, it is classed as a trailer and has to comply with the trailer regs. Since it's over the weight limit for an unbraked trailer this means it has to be braked. Braked A-frames cost a lot more. You also have to stay within the towing weight limit for the tow car.

Interestingly, if the wheel are on the road it has to be road legal as a car even if it's being counted as a trailer - it can be a car and a trailer at the same time iyswim. This could be a problem if the reason for needing to tow it is that it's not road legal.

There isn't a huge amount of space under the front bodywork to fit the A-frame arms. A standard A-frame isn't going to fit. When I got mine the suppliers were happy to supply longer pegs so the arms sit lower. There still isn't a huge amount of space, but in my case I've got a splitter that will happily cope with the arms leaning against it so it's not a problem for me. For you it might be.

Although there probably are gearboxes that will cope with being towed, I don't think the LT77 is one of them. At low speed for short distances would be fine I'm sure, but higher speed or longer distances I think would be asking for trouble unless you disconnect the prop shaft.

Edited by GreenV8S on Thursday 15th January 23:58

K4TRV

1,819 posts

283 months

Friday 16th January 2009
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
You can do what you like to remove the vehicle from danger to a place of safety, but outside that it will need to comply with the towing regulations.

If you have a driver in it who can operate the brakes, you can tow it with whatever you want.

If there's no driver, it is classed as a trailer and has to comply with the trailer regs. Since it's over the weight limit for an unbraked trailer this means it has to be braked. Braked A-frames cost a lot more. You also have to stay within the towing weight limit for the tow car.

Interestingly, if the wheel are on the road it has to be road legal as a car even if it's being counted as a trailer - it can be a car and a trailer at the same time iyswim. This could be a problem if the reason for needing to tow it is that it's not road legal.

There isn't a huge amount of space under the front bodywork to fit the A-frame arms. A standard A-frame isn't going to fit. When I got mine the suppliers were happy to supply longer pegs so the arms sit lower. There still isn't a huge amount of space, but in my case I've got a splitter that will happily cope with the arms leaning against it so it's not a problem for me. For you it might be.

Although there probably are gearboxes that will cope with being towed, I don't think the LT77 is one of them. At low speed for short distances would be fine I'm sure, but higher speed or longer distances I think would be asking for trouble unless you disconnect the prop shaft.

Edited by GreenV8S on Thursday 15th January 23:58
Peter,

Kinda sums it all up and hope Drew H comments on what he'll do ??smile

I'll stick to trailering TVR or Bike with my Motorhome.

It will be interesting to see if "anything Offical " ever comes of A-Frames - lots of M'Home users haven't a clue (over loading and towing), just hope none runs into any of you's!!

Trev

drew.h

Original Poster:

526 posts

220 months

Sunday 18th January 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for all the info. Glad I asked so I didn't waste money on the A frame. This would have only been for moving cars (including the Chimaera) locally and to save having to get someone else to help.

I'll have to drive the Chimaera to the garage without the clutch for now. I'll be looking to up-grade my pickup to some thing bigger with 4 wheel drive, so may invest in a trailer as well.