Whining Diff
Whining Diff
Author
Discussion

Rebelmatic

Original Poster:

136 posts

285 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
Hi all,

seems the rear diff has started to whine on my 450.. its a 98 model, done about 45k and looked after by Fernies smile

whine starts around 75mph when you are off the go faster pedal, and is quite loud around the 50mph mark fortunately it peters out at about 40 and you can't hear it anymore ;o)

it has got worse over time, but she still pulls like a train, and there isn't any noticable drag... so my question is really how bad is it?? i hear stories of them lasting for ages, and when i spoke Fernies (not Bryan) they said that i could proabably drive it ok til it fails as there's no guarentee when it comes to reconditioned Diff's that a new one will be much better.

wondered if there was any chance new oil might help??

cheers

Reb.

Pushrod-Power

233 posts

216 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
Have you checked the oil level? dont presume because its been serviced it is OK wink and that bit about a new diff/recon not being quiet is rubbish,if assembled and set up correctly the diff should be quiet in operation.

daz the plumber

14,997 posts

262 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
i have a similar problem !its my girl freind . i changed the oil and that made a difference,you need the right stuff as its not easy to get hold of and very expensive .

Rebelmatic

Original Poster:

136 posts

285 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
it was more a case that a recon wouldn't in all liklihood last as long as the original and i might be back to square one within a few months...

gonna plead ignorance to checking the diff oil... is that a simple thing to do.. not really the oily rag type.. usually just send her in.. but if its simple i don't mind having a go smile

have to say, Fernies usually do a top job so i'm sure they would have checked it last time she was in.

Edited by Rebelmatic on Thursday 15th January 13:29

steve-V8s

2,924 posts

279 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
Does the Diff leak oil? if it does then it is probably low, if it did and has stopped it is probably empty. In my experience it will carry on working well after the noise has become so bad that you can’t live with it and you can probably buy a replacement from one of the breakers cheaper than having the old one rebuilt.

scotty_d

6,795 posts

225 months

Thursday 15th January 2009
quotequote all
I am about to change my diff oil was told to use this. think it takes 1.7L

http://www.opieoils.co.uk/p-736-castrol-saf-xj-75w...

biper

2,097 posts

248 months

Friday 16th January 2009
quotequote all
Check it isn't rear wheel bearing. Took mine to Fernnies with rear end noise and they said it was the diff, got a quote.
Anyway, bought a 2nd hand diff and poly bushes for my local mechanic to do the job. He drove it and said it was the rear o/s wheel bearing. Sure enough he was right.

rev-erend

21,624 posts

315 months

Friday 16th January 2009
quotequote all
Worth checking the central nut is tight that attaches the flange to the diff (you will need to remove prop shaft).

Symptoms are loads of shunt ..

Try 2nd gear - on and off the power at low revs.. do you get loads of driveline shunt.. if so it could be the problem. If not - it's not that..

Pushrod-Power

233 posts

216 months

Friday 16th January 2009
quotequote all
rev-erend said:
Worth checking the central nut is tight that attaches the flange to the diff (you will need to remove prop shaft).

Symptoms are loads of shunt ..

Try 2nd gear - on and off the power at low revs.. do you get loads of driveline shunt.. if so it could be the problem. If not - it's not that..
yes and a sure sign the collapsible spacer as failed which then causes the pinion bearings to collapse not long after,i would still try the nut 1st(as Rev mentioned)because if you catch it in time you can possibly avoid all the above wink

edward1

839 posts

297 months

Friday 16th January 2009
quotequote all
Had a similar issue with mine (also a '98 450), had shunt that progressivly got worse (despite being told every service there was nothing wrong), and it then started to whine and a I pluged for a rebuild (with 12 month garuntee). When I got it back it still shunted and also decided to spit all its oil out aswell. After various return trips to the garage and where it was rebuilt I am now looking at sourcing a replacement from a breaker wishing I'd done that in the first place.

It could be I've just had a bad exerience with respect to the diff but in hind sight wouldn't have bothered with a rebuild, just spent the money on a replacement. Hope your fair better

Pushrod-Power

233 posts

216 months

Friday 16th January 2009
quotequote all
Shunting and spitting out oil is not necceserily the fault of the repairer,shunting is a known fault with these cars(weak fueling issue)and driven briskly the oil can escape from the poorly placed breather on the diff case,but in saying this a diff with lots of backlash will make the shunting more noticable wink

Edited by Pushrod-Power on Friday 16th January 12:22

f@-pots

204 posts

234 months

Friday 16th January 2009
quotequote all
You say your diff's whining ? scratchchin It's not Australian is it? biglaugh

rev-erend

21,624 posts

315 months

Friday 16th January 2009
quotequote all
f@-pots said:
You say your diff's whining ? scratchchin It's not Australian is it? biglaugh
Put a few cans of xxxx with it over nite ..

should cure the whining for a while.. smile

steve-V8s

2,924 posts

279 months

Friday 16th January 2009
quotequote all
If you do go down the used route take care over the ratios. There are at least two different ratios of BTR used. You may even prefer to seek out one that makes the overall gearing lower which helps the shunt to some respect or you may prefer to stick with the ratio you have. In which case count the input to output turns on both the one you have and the one you buy. They have ratio labels attached which are not always to be trusted.

mdotrutherford

384 posts

288 months

Saturday 17th January 2009
quotequote all
scotty_d said:
I am about to change my diff oil was told to use this. think it takes 1.7L

http://www.opieoils.co.uk/p-736-castrol-saf-xj-75w...
+1 yes I had very slight whine when I got mine and its totally silent now.