A bit of Hamilton trivia
A bit of Hamilton trivia
Author
Discussion

mattikake

Original Poster:

5,116 posts

228 months

Thursday 22nd January 2009
quotequote all
No rookie has ever beaten his world champion, reigning or previous, teammate in the WDC in the history of F1, let alone publically embarrassed him biggrin , until Lewis came along... and also beat a very highly rated driver while he was at it. Someone Schumi couldn't beat, despite having a better car. (Hey, I like contentious statements!)

Sorry to keep plugging the guy, but I reckon he is that special.

Jacques Villenenuve came 2nd to Hill, but Hill wasn't a WDC at the time either (though should've been in 1994!)

Denny Hulme and Bruce McLaren have come close, the two beating WDC teammate Jack Brabham but both had been racing for two seasons by the time they managed this.

..at least to my knowledge!

Edited by mattikake on Thursday 22 January 22:10

FourWheelDrift

92,293 posts

313 months

Thursday 22nd January 2009
quotequote all
There have been some close calls.

Jackie Stewart almost did it to Graham Hill in 1965 - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1965_Formula_One_seas...
And Nelson Piquet in 1979, one point behind Lauda - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1979_Formula_One_seas...

zac510

5,546 posts

235 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
Tell it to James Allen!

(jokes wink)

castrolcraig

18,073 posts

235 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
zac510 said:
Tell it to James Allen!

(jokes wink)
yes, then he can tell you useless facts whilst serving your big mac meal.

jellison

12,803 posts

306 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
Alonso is still there best out there wink

Dugiet

279 posts

213 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
He defo has a great talent

robbom3

265 posts

256 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
jellison said:
Alonso is still there best out there wink
On what basis ???

The one and only time he's had a really top class team mate, he finished behind him in the championship. Yes, he's ONE of the best, but not THE best IMO.

ph123

1,841 posts

247 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
Rindt on Brabham in F2?
Good point though.
Like Mansell moping up in the States as a Rookie after his WChampionship, I wonder whether LH will ever be so 'free' as when he pooped on his 2 time WC team mate, outbraking KR in a Ferrari at Monza.
It was an incredible year and performance.

But watchout for Vettal. He could I think.
I'd have signed him 3 years ago if I were Ferrari or BMW.

jellison

12,803 posts

306 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
Alonso, LH/SV, RK, KR/Massa.

Order of play.

zac510

5,546 posts

235 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
I'm amazed you didn't find a place for yourself in that order of play jellison smile

jellison

12,803 posts

306 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
zac510 said:
I'm amazed you didn't find a place for yourself in that order of play jellison smile
Too modest wink

Most really fast potential driver never get to even sit in a race car, it is all down to funds, lifestyle born into.

Looking forward to the new season, pity this KERS is so pointless (0.2-0.3 sec's lap) for all the extra cost involved - just so Motorsport at the top end can say they are being more Green!

motormania

1,143 posts

282 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
mattikake said:
No rookie has ever beaten his world champion, reigning or previous, teammate in the WDC in the history of F1, let alone publically embarrassed him biggrin , until Lewis came along... and also beat a very highly rated driver while he was at it. Someone Schumi couldn't beat, despite having a better car. (Hey, I like contentious statements!)
Correct me if I'm wrong but...

1) A driver is only called a Rookie in his first year. He won the WDC in his second year and therefore is not classed as a rookie

2) Alonso, who I guess you are referring to, was not Lewis' team mate last year when he won the WDC. Alonso drove for Renault, Lewis for McLaren!!

Answer: Don't try posting 'contentious statements' when you have got all the fact's wrong!

I get the feeling, like the other post you recently uploaded regarding the pathetic comments on the cause of the legendary Senna's death clearly point you out to be the type who posts ste just to get a reaction...

Try posting something more worthwhile in future please furious

stephen300o

15,464 posts

257 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
robbom3 said:
jellison said:
Alonso is still there best out there wink
On what basis ???

The one and only time he's had a really top class team mate, he finished behind him in the championship. Yes, he's ONE of the best, but not THE best IMO.
Tied. But who hires the world champion then makes them their number two driver?

Doobs

736 posts

279 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
stephen300o said:
robbom3 said:
jellison said:
Alonso is still there best out there wink
On what basis ???

The one and only time he's had a really top class team mate, he finished behind him in the championship. Yes, he's ONE of the best, but not THE best IMO.
Tied. But who hires the world champion then makes them their number two driver?
They didn't make him the number two, they just didn't make him the number one.

FourWheelDrift

92,293 posts

313 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
motormania said:
mattikake said:
No rookie has ever beaten his world champion, reigning or previous, teammate in the WDC in the history of F1, let alone publically embarrassed him biggrin , until Lewis came along... and also beat a very highly rated driver while he was at it. Someone Schumi couldn't beat, despite having a better car. (Hey, I like contentious statements!)
Correct me if I'm wrong but...

1) A driver is only called a Rookie in his first year. He won the WDC in his second year and therefore is not classed as a rookie

2) Alonso, who I guess you are referring to, was not Lewis' team mate last year when he won the WDC. Alonso drove for Renault, Lewis for McLaren!!

Answer: Don't try posting 'contentious statements' when you have got all the fact's wrong!

I get the feeling, like the other post you recently uploaded regarding the pathetic comments on the cause of the legendary Senna's death clearly point you out to be the type who posts ste just to get a reaction...

Try posting something more worthwhile in future please furious
Try reading the post again, Hamilton beat his team mate in his rookie year. He beat Alonso (a previous 2 times Champion) when they were at McLaren, he finished 2nd in the Championship, Alonso was 3rd, it's the only time that has happened.

stephen300o

15,464 posts

257 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
Doobs said:
stephen300o said:
robbom3 said:
jellison said:
Alonso is still there best out there wink
On what basis ???

The one and only time he's had a really top class team mate, he finished behind him in the championship. Yes, he's ONE of the best, but not THE best IMO.
Tied. But who hires the world champion then makes them their number two driver?
They didn't make him the number two, they just didn't make him the number one.
No, I believe crazy Dave, there is plenty of favoritism at Mclaren. Might be better now the old man is taking a back seat now though.

freedman

6,015 posts

236 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
motormania said:
mattikake said:
No rookie has ever beaten his world champion, reigning or previous, teammate in the WDC in the history of F1, let alone publically embarrassed him biggrin , until Lewis came along... and also beat a very highly rated driver while he was at it. Someone Schumi couldn't beat, despite having a better car. (Hey, I like contentious statements!)
Correct me if I'm wrong but...

1) A driver is only called a Rookie in his first year. He won the WDC in his second year and therefore is not classed as a rookie

2) Alonso, who I guess you are referring to, was not Lewis' team mate last year when he won the WDC. Alonso drove for Renault, Lewis for McLaren!!

Answer: Don't try posting 'contentious statements' when you have got all the fact's wrong!

I get the feeling, like the other post you recently uploaded regarding the pathetic comments on the cause of the legendary Senna's death clearly point you out to be the type who posts ste just to get a reaction...

Try posting something more worthwhile in future please furious
His facts are right

Hamilton beat Alonso in Hamiltons 'rookie' season. He didnt say he was world champion

rolleyes

mattikake

Original Poster:

5,116 posts

228 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
motormania said:
mattikake said:
No rookie has ever beaten his world champion, reigning or previous, teammate in the WDC in the history of F1, let alone publically embarrassed him biggrin , until Lewis came along... and also beat a very highly rated driver while he was at it. Someone Schumi couldn't beat, despite having a better car. (Hey, I like contentious statements!)
Correct me if I'm wrong but...

1) A driver is only called a Rookie in his first year. He won the WDC in his second year and therefore is not classed as a rookie

2) Alonso, who I guess you are referring to, was not Lewis' team mate last year when he won the WDC. Alonso drove for Renault, Lewis for McLaren!!

Answer: Don't try posting 'contentious statements' when you have got all the fact's wrong!

I get the feeling, like the other post you recently uploaded regarding the pathetic comments on the cause of the legendary Senna's death clearly point you out to be the type who posts ste just to get a reaction...

Try posting something more worthwhile in future please furious
LOL classic! hehe

I'm always nice and empirically fair though, so I tell you what; I'll give you a couple of hours to re-read my statement and correct yourself, before I publically embarrass you. (very big hint)

hehehehehehehehe.... I'm still laughing.

As for the Senna thing, yeah it was for a laugh, but more to see what amusing counters PHers would post to such a daft claim. You might also want to read my posts in that one again too. wink

Doobs

736 posts

279 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
stephen300o said:
Doobs said:
stephen300o said:
robbom3 said:
jellison said:
Alonso is still there best out there wink
On what basis ???

The one and only time he's had a really top class team mate, he finished behind him in the championship. Yes, he's ONE of the best, but not THE best IMO.
Tied. But who hires the world champion then makes them their number two driver?
They didn't make him the number two, they just didn't make him the number one.
No, I believe crazy Dave, there is plenty of favoritism at Mclaren. Might be better now the old man is taking a back seat now though.
There might be some, but this is well after Crazy D's stint at McMerc. However some favoritism is not the same as being a number two driver. Did he have any inferior tools at his disposal, or have to support LH in the races? No, they raced the same technology and they raced each other.

I have a favorite cat out of the two my Mrs got but they both get treated the same. They get fed the same and I kick them both as hard (joke, I only kick the Mrs, never the cats!!!!). There is nothing to suggest that FA was at a disadvantage. There is plenty to suggest that he didn't like not being the top dog.

Edited by Doobs on Friday 23 January 13:53

stephen300o

15,464 posts

257 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
Doobs said:
stephen300o said:
Doobs said:
stephen300o said:
robbom3 said:
jellison said:
Alonso is still there best out there wink
On what basis ???

The one and only time he's had a really top class team mate, he finished behind him in the championship. Yes, he's ONE of the best, but not THE best IMO.
Tied. But who hires the world champion then makes them their number two driver?
They didn't make him the number two, they just didn't make him the number one.
No, I believe crazy Dave, there is plenty of favoritism at Mclaren. Might be better now the old man is taking a back seat now though.
There might be some, but this is well after Crazy D's stint at McMerc. However some favoritism is not the same as being a number two driver. Did he have any inferior tools at his disposal, or have to support LH in the races? No, they raced the same technology and they raced each other.

I have a favorite cat out of the two my Mrs got but they both get treated the same. They get fed the same and I kick them both as hard (joke, I only kick the Mrs, never the cats!!!!). There is nothing to suggest that FA was at a disadvantage. There is plenty to suggest that he didn't like not being the top dog.

Edited by Doobs on Friday 23 January 13:53
You must know that top line sports is a head game as well as physical, seeing the team "get behind" your team mate more than you, weakens the confidence and makes some wonder how else they are favoured.
This is of course Alonso's big weakness and something maybe Mclaren should have accounted for earlier.
I do not think that Mclaren physically favoured one driver though. Once Alonso was more assured latter in the season he was more his old self.