chassis/ powder coat or paint
chassis/ powder coat or paint
Author
Discussion

TJC46

Original Poster:

2,199 posts

237 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
Hi guys would appreciate some advice/suggestions as im unsure which way to go. I have done the full bodylift and replace of the outriggers, and have degreased/removed all the old waxoil etc. Most of the chassis is now in very good condition, there is some surface rust mainly on the welds as done by the factory, most of the centre section powder coating is good. Do i shot/bead blast the whole chassis and repowder coat, shot/bead blast and paint, shot/ bead blast the surface rust areas only and paint. Really dont know which way to go. The finished colour will be bright red which ever way i go, i think this is a throwback from my TVR S3 days, it just makes any future inspection of the chassis very easy. Also i have renewed most of the wishbones, which come powder coated in a very fetching light green, so these will have to be painted. I know its a bit "belt and braces" but considering shot/bead blast and powder coat all the chassis, then 2 coats zinc phosphate primer[red lead clour] and finally bright red enamal on chassis and wishbones would appreciate input/comments thanks in advance Tom.

Barkychoc

7,848 posts

235 months

Friday 23rd January 2009
quotequote all
Tom you know what I'm going to say but after having the chassis shotblasted then powder coated the coating is incredibly tough, I've bashed it a few times pretty hard and it hasn't even touched it.
I doubt any paint would have survived the same treatment.

I reckon though that the shotblasting is probably the crucial element - it comes back quite rough so any coating would adhere really well, just get it done quickly if you have it shotblasted - once done its bare steel - don't give the rust a chance to get under your final coating whatever it may be.

Overhere

382 posts

254 months

Sunday 25th January 2009
quotequote all
Interesting, I had my roll bar sand plased and powder coated and within a month there were chips all over it, maybe it was just a shoddy job. On the other hand I cleaned, wire brushed and sanded my outriggers and then painted with POR 15 and it's tough as nails.

steviegasgas

417 posts

216 months

Monday 26th January 2009
quotequote all
Why does nobody think of galvanising the chassis? Is there a reason for this?

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Monday 26th January 2009
quotequote all
steviegasgas said:
Why does nobody think of galvanising the chassis? Is there a reason for this?
Hot dip galvanising involves dipping the chassis in a hot tank of zinc. It's almost inevitable that the chassis is going to distort when you do this.

slideways

4,101 posts

252 months

Monday 26th January 2009
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
steviegasgas said:
Why does nobody think of galvanising the chassis? Is there a reason for this?
Hot dip galvanising involves dipping the chassis in a hot tank of zinc. It's almost inevitable that the chassis is going to distort when you do this.
what about using this
http://www.zinga-uk.com
its what i will be using with an epoxy paint or por on top

Edited by slideways on Monday 26th January 02:57

Barkychoc

7,848 posts

235 months

Monday 26th January 2009
quotequote all
The guy that powder coated my chassis said there were different grades of powder coat - I can't remember what he said exactly but basically you need a higher grade for anything that is going to be exposed to the weather.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 26th January 2009
quotequote all
Quinny said:
..as long as the correct preparation, materials and procedures are used for the application required...
Subtly edited wink as exactly the same applies for painting IMHO.

I suspect that there is no easy answer to 'which is best' it all depends upon the monkey doing the work, and unfortunately the covering will always give way at its weakest point. However well 99% of the job is done if water/air gets under that flawed 1% it ruins the whole shebang!

OHere, I personally sprayed my rollbar anthracite and no chips after 4 years.. But I wouldn't guarantee everything I painted wouldn't chip hehe I was lucky with that one! 2k paints do seem stronger than soft enamels / cellulose etc. IME.

There is a great 'placebo' type effect going on here, by selecting the materials/method posters are most comfortable with, they will put in the extra effort to prove that it works. That is probably the most important element IMHO - the preparation and detailed execution.


Barkychoc

7,848 posts

235 months

Monday 26th January 2009
quotequote all
My chassis was in an oven (it only just fitted in) so hopefully I have the better type then!



spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 26th January 2009
quotequote all
Barkychoc said:
My chassis was in an oven (it only just fitted in) so hopefully I have the better type then!
We've seen you aren't afraid to cut it to fit yikeshehe

f@-pots

204 posts

234 months

Tuesday 27th January 2009
quotequote all
I seem to remember posting on a similar thread recently , just to re-iterate 'Spends' advice , it really does depend on the particular primate doing the job and also the ethics of the company used , I for one can count on one hand the number of individuals or companies I've used over the years for any amount of different tasks who I've come away from thinking 'that lot really know their stuff'!
C'mon guys, why d'you think nearly all the people on this forum who know one end of a spanner from another prefer if possible to do their own maintenance regardless of their ability to afford 'profesional' expertise? Sorry , bit of a rant but I just hate paying for shoddy work!!mad
So, I'd say prepare well and paint with a good quality 2 pack . 'Sorted'

I feel better now , Nick.............................biggrin

Zumbruk

7,848 posts

291 months

Tuesday 27th January 2009
quotequote all
f@-pots said:
I seem to remember posting on a similar thread recently , just to re-iterate 'Spends' advice , it really does depend on the particular primate doing the job
What, you get a better job at a Greek Orthodox church than a Roman Catholic one, for example? smile

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Tuesday 27th January 2009
quotequote all
If either candles or plates are involved in the job their workmanship may be quite distinguishable hehe

Chassis 33

6,194 posts

313 months

Tuesday 27th January 2009
quotequote all
After planning on powder coating the chassis, wishbones, cage etc for a while now, I've decided that I'm going to paint it. After taking advice from folks, the reason is that the paint will adhere to the metal more than the poweder coat (which will form more of a shell around the chassis); the reason this is favourable to me, is that powder coating can hide cracks in the metal beneath, whereas the paint cracks with the chassis.

Now this maynot be as much of a concern to a road car, as corrosion prevention and durability of finish rank as high as spotting cracks in welds (when was the last time anyone checked?), however on a racer, so long as it looks ok from 10ft and doesn't weight too much I'm not concerned about protecting a car from thousands of miles of salted roads etc.

Just my 2p
Regards
Iain

f@-pots

204 posts

234 months

Wednesday 28th January 2009
quotequote all
Steer clear of the eastern european primates , some of their plates are made of papier mache'biggrin

penno

241 posts

261 months

Wednesday 28th January 2009
quotequote all
Off subject ish but

Is it advisable to paint over powder coating with por15? I'm half way through cleaning the outriggers up. The drivers side powdercoating is in rather good condition with only a few areas of surface rust.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Wednesday 28th January 2009
quotequote all
I didn't strip all my chassis before POR'ing, just sanded off and cleaned with thinners first. It does stick better to rust, but quite acceptable as long as the surface is keyed & degreased IMHO.

TJC46

Original Poster:

2,199 posts

237 months

Wednesday 28th January 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for all your opinions i had a very good chat with the director of a local powder coat company in sheffield.He was very honest and didnt give me the hard sell,suffice to say, in his opinion he couldnt understand why TVR powder coated in the first place. There is a problem at all the points where the wishbones etc are fastened on of the powder coat star cracking and then water contamination and then the dreaded rust. So apologies to Barkychoc and 2 pack paint is the way to go for me personally,thanks again guys, Tom. clap

CHGRIFF

326 posts

283 months

Wednesday 28th January 2009
quotequote all
Having gone to the effort of Chassis removal I would not take any short cuts to obtaining the best solution. If the steel preparation is good, powder coating is extremely flexible and resiliant, remember the chassis flexes when under load which is why powder coating deteriorates at the welds first, i.e. the bending points under stress and load.
Paint does not flex and will crack at the welds at some point unless it is a special coating.
I would not leave the existing coating on as there is most certainly rust under the coating at various points that cant be seen.
I would suggest burning the Powder coating off, (the only way) then have the chassis sand blasted with course grade sand then Zinc powder coated prior to Powder coating to the colour of choice. The Zinc coating will act as a sacrificial coating and provide the best protection available.
This process is the same as SC Power user on their TVR wishbones they produce for the Griffith and Chimaera.
Also make sure the company applying the powder coat can handle a part of that size, it is very important the chassis bare metal reaches the application temperature of around 180 degC before the coating is applied, other wise there will be poor bonding of the coat to steel which will lead to early rust problems again.


f@-pots

204 posts

234 months

Wednesday 28th January 2009
quotequote all
Ah and theres the rub, not waiting for a chassis to get up to the correct temperature and allowing sufficient 'bake time' for correct adhesion to take place I'll wager, is the prime reason for failures in this system of surface protection. (costs money see) Unless I could be there on site watching my chassis being treated I would'nt go for it. Imagine you have had all this work done ,you then very carefully rebuild your pride and joy around the chassis, by the time you find out its pants and all falling off it's too bloody late!!However, if you prepare and paint it yourself , you KNOW the job is as good as it can be. All I'm trying to say is that although powder coating if correctly applied is a really good and tough chassis protection , your chances of actually achieving that are IMHO less than good.

Wednesday rant over, Nick..........................biggrin