Opportunity knocks?
Opportunity knocks?
Author
Discussion

Chim Chim Cheree

Original Poster:

49 posts

227 months

Sunday 25th January 2009
quotequote all
I've got to have my engine out soon, std 98 Chim 450 4.6 serp, to have a damaged crank repaired or replaced, and I started looking for opportunities.

One thing I noticed was that you can buy a short engine, lightened and balanced, and 5.2L, which I think is based on the same 4.6 I have?

I wonder if anyone knows how much of the existing 4.6 stuff I could just plonk onto it. Would I get away with retaining the heads, AFM, ECU, etc. at least until sometime in the future when I can do more to the top end.
Is this a viable 'swop' or would I have to change too much else to make it work sensibly? My guess is 'not viable' as the air/fuel is on the limit with the 4.6 already(?), and I'm just dreaming. But I don't actually know.

Seems a bit silly to take the engine out and then replace the bottom end with exactly the same, if there's no need to.
Other options seem to be 4.6 or 4.8 lightened & balanced short engine. I imagine that if I get my fixed/replaced crank balanced properly then I'd be looking at a similar price to a new, nicer 4.6 short all in anyway. Looking at balanced so I can maybe up the revs in future.

Anyone looked into this before? I'd appreciate your thoughts on this...
Another consideraton is that if I do get a new short engine, then I can also make a nice coffee table from the old one - Top Gear style. And this does appeal to me (not mentioned it to the wife yet though)

BTW, not looking to just buy a 5.0 from someone elses broken car. I'd like to keep a derivative of the 4.6, and as much of my own one as poss (sentimental old fool)

350Matt

3,914 posts

310 months

Sunday 25th January 2009
quotequote all
If you just fit the std heasd / cam intake onto the 5.2 bottom end you'll drop the power peak down the curve a bit but have more torque, you will have to re-chip the ecu tho as this will need a fair bit more fuel.

Matt

Chim Chim Cheree

Original Poster:

49 posts

227 months

Wednesday 28th January 2009
quotequote all
Thank you Matt. Kinda what I was expecting. I don't expect I could safely leave it with weak fuelling, so I'd have to do something with that now, rather than leave it 'til later.

I must admit that I'm a bit surprised that more people haven't looked into this... I expect that the bottom's so strong that they don't normally damage, so the 'opportunity' doesn't arise for many...