Main cat removal?
Main cat removal?
Author
Discussion

Meatball

Original Poster:

1,638 posts

241 months

Friday 30th January 2009
quotequote all
Ive brought a second hand y piece on the cheap (as i cant afford clives y piece at the moment frown)
The plan is to remove the cat add a wideband bung and wrap in exhaust wrap to reduce the tinnyness.
Will i need to change the tune resistor? its currently white from memory.
I know its been done loads of times but i cant find a straight answer wobble

Pupp

13,036 posts

303 months

Friday 30th January 2009
quotequote all
The cat tune resistor (and map) will work just fine with the cat out; it's actually the best choice. On mine I needed to slightly tweak the trimmer on the AFM but there are those who say it has no effect (on mine it did)

Meatball

Original Poster:

1,638 posts

241 months

Friday 30th January 2009
quotequote all
Pupp said:
The cat tune resistor (and map) will work just fine with the cat out; it's actually the best choice. On mine I needed to slightly tweak the trimmer on the AFM but there are those who say it has no effect (on mine it did)
Pupp does it sound much louder without the main cat?

drew.h

526 posts

220 months

Friday 30th January 2009
quotequote all
Don't forget the pre cats in the manifolds.

Pupp

13,036 posts

303 months

Friday 30th January 2009
quotequote all
Depends on the rest of the system. If you have a sleeved/bombed main 'silencer' then the big cat is the main silencing component and it will be loads louder without it. If with the oem box then it will be fine if a bit more 'pingy' sounding due to the increased resonance in the big hollow space where the cat was. I found the manifold cats had no effect (that I could discern) on noise but had a major effect on under-bonnet temperature (as does the main one). No brainer to have 'em out

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
Mine is/was far too noisy for comfort, I just stuck the cat back in. Yes, old fart I know hehe

If you are hacking the cat out & sensoring, you could try coning the 'dustbin' down to the outlet pipe rather than leaving it cylindrical. The change in shape might just take the edge off the resonance? I've not seen / tried that - just wondered in idle moments wink

My Lucas ran better if anything with the cat resistor anyway as far as I could tell from the short time I tried it. As with most things the engines seem quite different in tune and sound so YMMV..

Chimjunkie

2,879 posts

242 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
spend said:
Mine is/was far too noisy for comfort, I just stuck the cat back in. Yes, old fart I know hehe
Old fart maybe. But at least not smelly biggrin

Not pleasant being behind a decatted car sometimes...

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
Chimjunkie said:
Not pleasant being behind a decatted car sometimes...
Someone overfuelling or burning the liquid gold?

..or was it yet another example of an 'accurate' WBO2 installation hehe

Meatball

Original Poster:

1,638 posts

241 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
spend said:
you could try coning the 'dustbin' down to the outlet pipe rather than leaving it cylindrical. The change in shape might just take the edge off the resonance?
I was thinking along them lines but wont know if its possible (or im capable hehe) untill i open her up.
Ill post up my progress if theres any interest.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
I think it would be useful to evaluate, but if you have any doubts there are mixes of stainless & mild around there so get a real welder/fab to do it wink

retroptvr

334 posts

250 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
Remember to tell your insurance company, as it counts as a major modification, some will not even continue your insurance if you do this, I asked and they frowned, so I didn't.

Importantly, if you do it, tell them, or they have a good reason not to pay any claim you make, pre cat removal is neither here nor there.

Meatball

Original Poster:

1,638 posts

241 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
Meatball said:
spend said:
you could try coning the 'dustbin' down to the outlet pipe rather than leaving it cylindrical. The change in shape might just take the edge off the resonance?
I was thinking along them lines but wont know if its possible (or im capable hehe) untill i open her up.
Ill post up my progress if theres any interest.
scratchchin Ive cut the exhaut in half and see what you mean now...im wondering would it be easier to to cut at the lower join just before the bend an have a piece made like you say in a cone shape and join the 2 together (christ its starting to sound like a frankenstein version of clives masterpiece hehe)
or
weld another layer inside the main drum to try and cut down the tinnyness (cheap and easy option).


Any tips on how to get the cat out?



henrycrun

2,473 posts

271 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
Open a tin of fish ?

Del 203

12,728 posts

280 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
Meatball said:
Pupp said:
The cat tune resistor (and map) will work just fine with the cat out; it's actually the best choice. On mine I needed to slightly tweak the trimmer on the AFM but there are those who say it has no effect (on mine it did)
Pupp does it sound much louder without the main cat?
I'm sans pussy's & sleeved biggrin


Its not that loud whistle

Well, not in the car anyway hehe

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
Meatball said:
Meatball said:
spend said:
you could try coning the 'dustbin' down to the outlet pipe rather than leaving it cylindrical. The change in shape might just take the edge off the resonance?
I was thinking along them lines but wont know if its possible (or im capable hehe) untill i open her up.
Ill post up my progress if theres any interest.
scratchchin Ive cut the exhaut in half and see what you mean now...im wondering would it be easier to to cut at the lower join just before the bend an have a piece made like you say in a cone shape and join the 2 together (christ its starting to sound like a frankenstein version of clives masterpiece hehe)
or
weld another layer inside the main drum to try and cut down the tinnyness (cheap and easy option).


Any tips on how to get the cat out?
2 cuts to remove the cat section, & cut a sheet that will wrap to form a cone from top to bottom would be my suggestion. Ask Clive he may give you some tips? Its not flowed as well as the proper ones, but must be better than just hacking the cat out the bin?

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Saturday 31st January 2009
quotequote all
spend said:
2 cuts to remove the cat section, & cut a sheet that will wrap to form a cone from top to bottom would be my suggestion. Ask Clive he may give you some tips? Its not flowed as well as the proper ones, but must be better than just hacking the cat out the bin?
What problem is the cone intended to solve? The only reason I can see is to make the exit a bot smoother, but if you look at the shape of the outlet it's already nicely smoothed out. If you think about it, the cat is just a set of parallel tubes filling the middle of the Y piece and does nothing much for the flow in or out, so there's no reason to expect any gas flow problems after you remove the cat.

Meatball

Original Poster:

1,638 posts

241 months

Sunday 1st February 2009
quotequote all
Take a look


My moneys is on these little buggers causing the resonance ringing sound theres about 1mm-2mm gap all the way through.
What do you think?

big geoff

387 posts

231 months

Sunday 1st February 2009
quotequote all
i would agree with you on that it would vibrate like a drum skin

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Sunday 1st February 2009
quotequote all
We are discussing noise implications when removing the cat internals from the dustbin Peter?

Are you on about the separator Ben, you need something to stop the opposing pulses at the Y hitting each other. Thats the advantage of aftermarket replacements - they bend it round a bit more.. I'm not sure what you could do to improve it TBH?

Gradually reducing the dia from your 2 cuts should defeat some of the sound, you could even try packing it externally with wadding and cover with the original 'dustbin' cylinder shape (but it makes the WB sensor bung a little trickier hehe). Mine did boom at certain frequencies, which I rightly / wrongly put down to standing waves and figured a non uniform cross section area might defeat these rather than amplify them wink


Meatball

Original Poster:

1,638 posts

241 months

Sunday 1st February 2009
quotequote all
spend said:
Are you on about the separator Ben, you need something to stop the opposing pulses at the Y hitting each other. Thats the advantage of aftermarket replacements - they bend it round a bit more.. I'm not sure what you could do to improve it TBH?
yes
Ive not made my mind up 100% but was thinking along the lines of welding the 2 deflectors together at the open end.
Ive got access to a precision engineer at work so may pick his brain to whats possible.

Im also tempted to just try excessively exhaust wrapping the y piece to try to keep the additional noise a little more tame. I dont have a clue if wrap will achieve this?

The problem is im trying to do this on the cheap and dont really want to get into additional fabricating and welding.


BTW any suggestions on how to get the cat out without the use of a press or grown ups tools hehe
My caveman expertise didnt work smash

Appreciate your input