How does this engine sound?
How does this engine sound?
Author
Discussion

TVR_nut_2008

Original Poster:

22 posts

216 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
Afternoon gents,

Out in the Chimeara yesterday, roof off as the sun was shining and all I could hear was tappets...I think. They don't sound awful, especially thinking back to my old T series Rover 420 turbo, but rather annoying all the same. Tends to be worst when the engine is warm.
Most noticeable at lower speeds although I guess at higher speeds the noise is drowned out by the wind. The car has just been serviced at a specialist that enjoys a good reputation, they didn't mention it so I'm assuming it's not too bad, but what do others think in comparision to your engines?

These sound clips open on a blank page and take a few seconds to download. They sound slightly different to each other per se, as the first was in my garage and the second outside. Both are taken with the hood up and the camera resting above the drivers side wheel arch:

Just after starting up i.e. cold engine.

After a 20 mile blast.

Bit of background: 4.0HC, '97 serp, 43k, pulls well, uses no oil/water, serviced well, all original components. Oil pressure 45 when cold, 30 - 45 when driving about, 15 - 30 in traffic. Tempurature 50 - 70 when driving on a cool day depending on speed, 80 - 90 in traffic.

Any feedback gratefully received.

Cheers

T_Pot

2,542 posts

228 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
neither of them links work for me so cant hear sorry mate

bjarkes

122 posts

215 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
same here!

TVR_nut_2008

Original Poster:

22 posts

216 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
Doh! They work ok for me, 3MB each so take a while to download if you've a slower connction.

Have just signed up to Youtube so the whole video is on there now, link as below:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UUBywSeXY4Y

Cheers


T_Pot

2,542 posts

228 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
sounds to me from that, maybe you have an inlet gasket blown? didnt really hear too much metallic sounds from it, but i think i can hear a blow?

TVR Horsepower

119 posts

232 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
Hi TVR nut,
Check all the exhaust manifold bolts are nipped up with no leaks, it sounds like manifold gasket may be about to fail.

Cheer's another TVR nut smile

That Daddy

19,464 posts

252 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
T_Pot said:
sounds to me from that, maybe you have an inlet gasket blown? didnt really hear too much metallic sounds from it, but i think i can hear a blow?
yes just one thing,the idle seems to be to even/smooth for a HC cammed 400 they tend to be much more splashy unless someone as fitted something milder or your cam is shedding its lobes,just my cents worth although the video quality is not great so it may just be me thumbup why do you have a non HC plenum badge? forget that last comment i dont think i can properly make out the badge anyways rolleyes



Edited by That Daddy on Sunday 8th February 15:00

locodude

510 posts

226 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
Sounds just like mine! With roof off and driving it sounds like a tappety noise but with bonnet open sounds more like left bank exhaust. Could it be the infamous 4 into 1 split?

TVR_nut_2008

Original Poster:

22 posts

216 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for the responses so far guys.

T Pot - yep not too metallicy (might have just made that word up), no obvious blow to me, but I'm not a mechanic so don't really know what I'm listening for.

TVR Horsepower - will check the bolts when it has cooled down. Manifold gasket about to fail - what are the consequences of this?

That Daddy - I expect the cam is worn to a degree, no evidence of it being changed however. The plenum badge is an HC one, poor video then!

locodude - how long have you had the problem, has it got worse and do you live with it?

So it seems it's nothing terminal, but something is not right. Would you chaps expect this to have been picked up at a service?

Badmutha

658 posts

224 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
locodude said:
Sounds just like mine! With roof off and driving it sounds like a tappety noise but with bonnet open sounds more like left bank exhaust. Could it be the infamous 4 into 1 split?
I had the same, and to check if it was the exhaust I dangled a piece of shredded paper in the gap in the middle of the four pipes where they meet the single pipe and revved the motor. There was enough gas eacaping to blow the paper about.I 'temporarily' fixed it by pumping gun-gum into the void until it oozed out between the pipes and it's still sealed 4000 miles later.
HTH

locodude

510 posts

226 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
TVR_nut_2008 said:
locodude - how long have you had the problem, has it got worse and do you live with it?
I've only had the car 8 months but it's no worse now than when I got it. It always sounds worse when driving. My mates can't see what I'm on about so it could be just 'how they sound'. I need to meet up with some more chims to get a frame of reference. Not back on the road till march tho'.

locodude

510 posts

226 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
Badmutha said:
I had the same, and to check if it was the exhaust I dangled a piece of shredded paper in the gap in the middle of the four pipes where they meet the single pipe and revved the motor. There was enough gas eacaping to blow the paper about.I 'temporarily' fixed it by pumping gun-gum into the void until it oozed out between the pipes and it's still sealed 4000 miles later.
HTH
Cheers I'll give it a try!

bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
I havent managed to listen to the clip but... I had this recently , turned out to be exhaust manifold gasket blowing. It was quiet when cold but once warmed up I got a lovely tappety sound from the o/s. New gaskets (and removal of precats while it was all off) and the sound has gone for good.

My 450 also gets tappety if the wrong oil is used, 10w40 and shes smooth and quiet anything thinner and she rattles a bit.


ETA best way to diagnose, drop it into any garage they will have a quick listen with a stethoscope and identify any leaks.


Edited by bigdods on Sunday 8th February 20:06